Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 4 by SanctifiedVillified SanctifiedVillified

Do you visit the Redhead club? Go for a walk?

Dye Dye Dye!

After you have breakfast with Ashley, Sarah, and Derrick. You decide to go for a walk and have a long think about what fun you could have in this new world. You walk out of the restaurant and start meandering along the sidewalk with your eyes to the pavement. What was it Ashley said earlier? She thought about dying her hair red so she could … do it … with you.

It’s interesting how she worded that. It seems that when talking about redheads people are totally vulgar without even thinking about it. I FUCKED Sarah, but Sarah and Derrick haven’t DONE IT yet. So sex still has the same taboos for everyone else AND for you with all women who don’t have red hair. You decide to see how far you can push the limits of this strange rule.

Who in the world would absolutely for no reason ever touch your penis no matter what? Married women? Supermodels? Celebrities? Then it occurs to you. Your family members! You have an older sister named Caitlin who is about 30 now. She is a high school teacher about a 30 minute drive south of your college. Your younger sister, Dana, is turning 18 tomorrow and she still lives at home. And your mother, Erin, is 49 and lives just a few hours away by car. As you walk down the sidewalk you start to smile uncontrollably. All of them dye their hair blonde! They’ve done it for so long that you had trouble remembering.

A plan starts forming in your mind. Alright, you’ve got to buy red hair dye before Dana’s birthday tomorrow. You get so excited that you start to run-walk to the nearest department store.

After your purchase you think about how you’re going to switch the dye without any of them noticing. They are going to see the color difference right away, surely. You decide that the best route is to mix it with the blonde dye to it’s not so noticeable. You’re not sure what the reaction is going to be if they find you out so you’ve got to be careful.

The best time to mix your concoction is likely going to be while your family is asleep. So you decide to drive home for sisters birthday tonight. It’s only about a two hour drive without traffic so you know you can make it early. You figure you’ll head out after dinner so you get home just before your mother and sister go to bed.

So you spend the rest of your day wandering around campus, playing video games, watching tv, and pretending to do homework. You have trouble not fucking every redhead you see, but you really want to save it for the fun tomorrow.

After you eat dinner you head to your car and drive towards home. It’s a pretty boring drive. Just a bunch of cornfields as far as the eye can see. It feels even slower than usual given your anticipation. Finally, you make it to your exit and pull off the highway. From there it is only 10 minutes to your house. You pull into your driveway at about 9:45pm.

Then you walk up to your front door carrying a small suitcase and knock. It seems that your younger sister saw the lights and guessed that someone was coming because she opened the door almost immediately. “Hey bro!” said Dana excitedly, giving you a nice hug. “I’ve missed you around here! It’s just mom, dad, and I now. I’ve been stuck with two old people all day.”

“I heard that!” You’re mom says smiling as she comes around the corner out of the kitchen. “How are you son?! It’s been such a long time! You haven’t called home in over three weeks!”

“Yeah sorry,” you reply. “Classes have been hell lately. All those damn math problems are tiring me out.”

“Oh that’s okay sweetie. Just call when you can,” your mother says as she gives you a hug and a kiss on the cheek. “Your father is upstairs sleeping. He had a long day so turned in early. “Well, we didn’t expect you to come today so your bed is not made but that is easily fixed. The blankets and sheets are in the …”

“Closet at the end of the hall,” you interrupt. “I used to live here ya know!” you say jokingly. Your mother roles her eyes and walks back into the kitchen. Your sister follows you upstairs.

You’re looking at your family in a whole new light now. You’re mother, although a bit plump, has an amazing body for a 49 year old. It’s really incredible. You never appreciated it until you saw her just now. She has what must be E-cups hiding under that bulky blouse she's wearing. You now understand why your high school friends always wanted to come to your place to play video games.

Your sister on the other is not plump at all. She is a gymnast at your former high school and god does it show. Her body it muscular and tight. She has cute, perky B-cups and a perfect hip to waist ratio. Her hair is long and silky blonde. She looks like she straight up bleaches her hair.

After you gather together sheets, a pillow, and a blanket you start making your bed. When you’re just about done your sister walks into your room and asks, “So did you get me anything?”

“Yeah, I did. I’m telling you right now. Nothing could possibly surprise you more than my present,” you reply with a smirk.

Suddenly there is another knock on the front door. “Oh that must be Caitlin!” shouts your younger sister. Then she rushes down the stairs to greet her sister. You walk behind her at a more leisurely pace. When you get downstairs again you see Caitlin and Dana hugging by the front door.

When they’re done Caitlin smiles at you and says, “Hey! How is my little bro doing? You look like 10 years older than when I last saw you.”

“Thanks, I guess,” you reply. Your older sister is much taller than either Erin or Dana. She must have gotten those genes from your father. She is almost as tall as you! You’re starting to notice her body as well. She has DD sized tits! And her ass is big and plump. She must be doing kegels all day at the gym! “Your looking good sis. Have you been working out?”

Caitlin stares at you with a bemused look on her face. “Yeah bro. I’ve actually been working out everyday for the past year or so. It’s kind of sad that the first person to notice is my brother, but I guess I’ll take what I can get,” she says with a laugh.

Your mother, sisters, and you decide to go and sit in the living room and chat for a few minutes before bed. You talk about work, high school, college, politics, bar-hopping and a bunch of other stuff before your mother lets out a big yawn and starts to head to bed. This triggers the rest of you and you all start heading upstairs to sleep as well.

When you get into your bedroom you lie on your bed wide awake for about an hour and half just waiting. When you finally can’t hear anymore movement in the house you climb out of bed, take off your shoes and head out into the dark hallway with the bottle of red hair dye. You slide along the hard wood floor with your socks until you reach your mom and dad’s room at the end of the hall. You slowly open the door and tip toe inside onto the carpet. You move slowly to the master bathroom and feel around in the dark for the hair dye. You find a bottle and bring it up close to your eyes. That’s it! You unscrew the cap, pour out about half of the bottle and then mix in the red dye. It looks alright to you but it is pretty dark in there. It’ll have to do. You screw the cap back on and replace the bottle. Then you leave the room, close the door and head to your sisters rooms. You successfully sneak into both of their rooms without waking them up and replace about half of the dye in each bottle.

Then you take the empty red dye bottle and bury it deep in the trash in the kitchen so nobody will see it. Finally, you wash your hands thoroughly to remove any remaining evidence. DONE! Now all you have to do is try to get some sleep. You’re definitely going to sleep in later than everyone else. So hopefully you’ll wake up after the fun has begun.

You head back upstairs, climb into bed, and close your eyes. You get a good nights sleep. Until you are woken up by a loud scream from your parents bedroom. It jolts you awake, but you quickly realize what happened and smile with glee. “My hair! It's orange!” your mother shouts. You swiftly put on some clothes and head out into the hallway. Your mom storms out into the hallway and yells, “Who did this!? Who was it!?”

Your younger sister opens the door to the shower room and peaks out, wearing a towel around her body and one wrapped around her hair. The room is filled with steam from the shower. She looks at your mother and stifles a big laugh by covering her mouth. “Mom. That’s a unique look,” she says trying not to smile.

“I don’t want to hear it missy!” mom shouts. “Is this some kind of prank!?

Then your older sister comes out of her room dressed in a tight white t-shirt and blue jeans. “What’s all the commotion?” she says quizzically. Your mom and your sister both stare at Caitlin’s head. Her hair is bright orange as well.

Caitlin!” your mother says. “Someone got you too!”

“Oh no!” shouts Caitlin. “I put the dye in earlier this morning! I didn’t even notice. What the hell is going on?”

Dana is laughing out loud at this point. She can barely contain herself. But then you step up behind her and whip the towel right off of your head. Just as you’d hoped. You got all of them! Not one of them noticed before it was too late!

You raise both your hands up in the air and shout, “Yes! Gotcha! I snuck into all of your rooms last night and swapped out your hair dye!” Then you start laughing and dancing around around in the hallway.

John Doe! Your mother shouts! Why on earth did you do that?! You’ve ruined your sisters birthday with this ridiculous prank!”

Your mother, father, older and younger sister are all staring at you completely livid. Erin and Dana are both in just bath towels and have their hands on their hips. You decide to be bold. You walk past your father, right up to your mother and rip her bath towel off in front of your whole family. “It was so I could do this mommy.” Then you put one hand one her left breast and used the other to pull her in tightly and kiss her. Your sister’s expressions move from anger to understanding to something more.

You’re younger sister says, “Awwwwwwwww John! Was this the big surprise you mentioned? Did you do this so you could fuck our family during my birthday party?”

You pull your lips away from your mother’s mouth, look at Dana and nod happily. “That is the sweetest birthday present I’ve ever been given brother! I can’t imagine a better way to make us closer than fucking each other silly!” With that she runs up to you gives you and your mother a big hug and kiss. Your mother is breathing a little heavily since you starting fondling her but happily hugs both of you back tightly.

“I guess that is pretty sweet John,” your mother says still holding you both closely. “It will bring us together as a family.”

Your father slaps you on the back and says, “You’ve always been a pretty thoughtful guy, son. What a great birthday present! Now you can fuck your mother and sisters while we have Dana’s friends over. Should make for a fun and memorable birthday party.”

You’re older sister now slowly comes into the group hug between you, your naked mother, and younger sister. You all hold each other tightly for a few moments then move apart and let out a communal sigh. “Well, we better finish getting ready for the party! Dana’s friends are going to be here pretty soon!” your mother says excitedly. “Honey could you go set up the table downstairs?” she asks your father. He rushes off down the steps to get things ready. “Alright girls lets all get dressed!”

“Oh there is no need for that!” you say proudly. “Since I am going to be fucking each of you for the rest of the day you might as well get undressed.”

“What a great idea son! That will make it much easier for you to fuck each of us as you see fit!” says your mother. Your little sister unwraps the towel from her body and throws it onto the bathroom floor, revealing her perfect, muscular gymnast’s body to you. Then she walk up and gives you a big kiss. Your older sister walks into her room while pulling her t-shirt over her head. You can see her unhook her bra as your younger sister grabs your hand and pulls you down the steps to the living room.

As soon as you both make it down the doorbell rings and you hear three women outside shout, “Happy birthday Dana!”

Dana runs to the door and opens it, gives the three women a big happy smile and beckons them to come inside. But they all just stare at her with their mouth hanging wide open. “Dana! You … you’re not wearing any clothes!”

“Oh yeah! That’s John's birthday present to me!” squeaks your sister. “He snuck some red coloring into all of our hair dye so he could fuck us all during my birthday party! Isn’t that sweet?!”

When she explains the situation all of their facial expressions change immediately. “That is so cute! John wants to fuck his family. Ooooooh I could just eat you up John!” says Maria. She is the mother of one of Dana’s high school friends. She is a short, stout Latina with some pretty interesting tribal tattoos on her neck and arms. She is a hairdresser at the salon that the women of your family use so she has become something of a surrogate aunt to you and your younger sister.

Maria’s daughter is named Rosa and there is nothing short and stout about her. She has an absolutely incredible body. Straight out of a magazine. A big beautiful bubble butt and perfect, perky C-cup titties. Rosa is wearing an ultra tight black top and pink/black yoga pants. Her hair looks smooth as silk, and black as pitch.

Standing next to Rosa is Dana’s oldest and closest friend Ailani. She is a very cute half Hawaiian/half Japanese girl that has been hanging out with Dana since they were in diapers. She is extremely short, only about 4 ft 10 in tall, but she also has a very beautiful body. She has been a lifelong dancer and it definitely shows. She has a very outgoing and warm personality. You’ve actually kind of had a crush on her since you were just a boy, and it’s never really worn off.

All of the girls walk in and give your naked sister a group hug just as Erin and Caitlin walk down the stairs. They move into the fray and start exchanging hellos and talk excitedly about the plans for the party. You all move into the living room and seat yourselves around the room on various couches and plush chairs.

Since you woke up in this world you’ve developed a much bolder personality. So you decided to sit next to Ailani on the couch, between her and your sister. “Hey Ailani. I haven’t seen you in forever. How’s life been treating you?”

She tells you some of the ups and downs of the past couple years and you listen attentively. You both exchange stories about school life, grades, work, partying, and dating. Then your father comes into the room and says, “Hey everybody! I set up the table and put the food out. Ready when you are!”

“Hold on just one second everybody,” you say. “I think we should start with presents. That’ll give us something more to talk about while we eat! How about I go first?”

Your mother says, “That sounds like a good idea John. Go ahead!”

So you stand in the middle of the living room while everyone watches you and start taking off your clothes. Your family is looking at you and smiling. You look down at Ailani as you pull off your boxers and your erect penis pops into the open air. She looks down at it, bites her lower lip and smiles up at you. Then you walk over to your younger sister, who is also looking up at you and smiling, and lift her off of the couch and then push down on her shoulders until she crouches down on all fours in the middle of the living room.

“Do you need any lube John?” your mother asks. “I can go get some from my bedroom if you like.”

“I’ve got a better idea mommy. Why don’t you and Caitlin come over here and suck my cock before I fuck my little sister?”

Your mother and older sister then hop up out of their chairs and get on their knees in front you. When they are in position you reach down and grab your mothers head and stick your cock in her mouth. Then you push Caitlin’s head down so that she can suck on your balls. Your mother is really good at this. Her skill inspires you to push her harder. So you take both of your hands and push her head all the way down on your cock until she starts gagging. Spit starts flying out of her mouth as your mother coughs and chokes on your cock. She pulls back and breaths in sharply. “Ohhhhhh my sweetie. You’re being very rough with mommy today!” she says.

You push Caitlin over a bit so you can kneel down behind your waiting younger sister. “Finally bro! I thought you were going to cum before you got to fucking me!” she says jokingly.

“Noooo. I wouldn’t do that on your birthday sis!” Then you slowly push your cock into her tight pussy and start moving your hips back and forth. You look up at Rosa and see that she has her smart phone out and looks like she is taking pictures. She sees you catch her and says, “You two are just so adorable John. I have to post some of these pics on Facebook! Everybody is going to fall in love with them.”

“You're right Rosa we should get a lot of pictures of this special day,” Maria says. Then Ailani, your father, Maria, and Rosa all start walking around the room taking pictures of you fucking you sister’s pussy at various angles. Rosa brings the camera in and asks you to smile. So you look up at her in ecstasy and put an awkward half smirk on your face. Ailani comes up behind you and leans her head in close to yours and wraps her arm around your neck and makes a peace sign. Then she takes a bunch of selfies with you. When she is done she stays kneeling next to you. You can tell that she is getting a little bit excited. She puts down her phone, leans up against you, and starts rubbing your chest as you penetrate you sister.

“Woah! Ailani don’t get too carried away here! You’re in public!” your mother shouts sternly. Ailani pulls away quickly and despondently moves back to the couch to sit down.

“It’s alright mom,” you say. “She was just rubbing my chest. No big deal. I’ve actually kind of had a crush on Ailani for a long time, so I don’t mind.”

“Aaaaaaaaaaaaw John! That is so sweet! I had no idea you liked Ailani!” says your older sister.

You look at Ailani, who is now beaming at you. She looks so happy. “Oh my God! I’ve always liked you too John!” shouts Ailani excitedly and then she hops back down to you and plants a kiss on your lips and gives you a hug.

All the women in the room are now beside themselves. They have their hands clasped in front of them with big smiles on their faces as they watch you fuck your sister while Ailani hugs you.

“That’s wonderful Ailani!” your mother says, “I think that you and John will make a cute couple. I just want you two to be responsible. Sex is not just a fun activity that you can do whenever you want. It’s an important part of life that you have to take seriously and only do with someone that you really love.”

“Mooooooooooom gross! Are you really going to give the sex talk to one of my friends at my birthday p…pa…par … oooooooooh John!?” says your little sister as you start to fuck her faster and faster. The sound of your hips slapping against her bouncing ass are now emanating loudly throughout the room. You’re face starts to contort in pleasure and you don’t think you can hold it much longer. Your sister starts to scream and jerk uncontrollably as she begins to cum. Her back arches and strains as she starts squirting all over your cock, your legs, and the living room carpet. Just when you are on the edge of cumming your mother and older sister both run up to you. Your mother sticks her tongue in your mouth and your older reaches down and plays with your balls and shouts encouragingly, “Come on little bro! Cum inside our baby sister! Cum! You can do it!” Your ass tightens as you squeeze your jizz inside your little sisters pussy and moan in pleasure.

When you’re done you leave your cock inside Dana and keep moving it in and out slowly as you continue to make out with your mother. Maria, still taking pictures with her phone shouts, “Yaaaay! Oh my God Erin your family is so beautiful! It was wonderful watching you all have fun together. This was an incredibly thoughtful birthday present John!”

“Alright, foods up! Come and get!” your father says behind you.

Do you stay at the birthday party? Go on a date with Ailani?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)