Make Emma give up her ass for penance

"There's only one way I gave forgive you, Emma," you tell your slut who is kneeling in front of you. "Only one way I'll know that you truly are sorry for what you've done and that despite everything, you still are still loyal to me."

"What is it, John?" Emma asks desperately. "You know I love you and will do anything to prove it."

"Turn around and give me your ass," you say.

Emma looks relived. She can do this, she knows. She smiles at you and does as you say. She turns around and bends down over the side of the couch and spreads her ass cheeks for you, presenting her puckered asshole to you.

It's unclear if Emma is an anal virgin or not. Back in college one guy managed to persuade her to let him stick his dick up her butt, but it only lasted at most two minutes before she made him pull out. The pain was too much for her. Did this count as losing her anal virginity? One short, painful experience? She wasn't sure.

You look at your girlfriend's tight hole and think that if she hadn't gone and cheated on you, you'd be a gentleman and spend a lot of time stretching her out and lubing her up. But right now she doesn't deserve that. Her punishment for cheating is you're gonna take her ass with your gigantic cock with just some spit for lube.