Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 31 by olly olly

What's next?

It’s time to take Bethany's virginity

You break your kiss with Bethany and she’s surprised by how much she’s disappointed in the ending of the kiss. She had lost herself while kissing you. But then she quickly remembers where she is and what’s about to happen. She spots your hard cock and her body tenses as she wonders how something that big will ever fit inside of her. Even just one of her fingers feels tight when she plays with yourself - and your cock, well that will be like her hole fist.

Isabella can feel Bethany’s tenseness and massages the young girl’s shoulders trying to calm her.

You stick a finger inside of Bethany and her body tenses some more. Isabella whispers words of comfort. You tell the women you need to get some lube and you get up to grab it. You know where Isabella keeps it, of course. Despite all the oral sex, it’s clear from Isabella’s tightness the lube will be necessary. Her pussy is the tightest you’ve ever felt. She’s tighter than most asses you’ve fucked.

You apply a liberal amount of lube to your cock. The chill of it feels great on your cock. You also put some on a finger and squeeze that into Bethany’s tight tight pussy. You fuck her a little with your finger, and then you slip in a second. You apply a little more lube, and you can see how Bethany’s body has relaxed, she’s responding to the pleasure.

Bethany’s eyes are closed and she imagines that your fingers are your cock. She imagines she’s being fucked and she finds that this thought turns her on immensely. She feels Isabella’s hands massaging her large breasts and she moans when Isabella teases her nipples. She begins to move her hips, shifting her pelvis forward to meet the movements of your fingers. Yes, she likes being fucked. She’s ready for your cock.

You remove your fingers and position your cock at the entrance to Bethany’s young body. You slide the head of your cock against her very soft young pussy lips. Her pussy is puffy and bald, and it feels amazing. If you were less experienced you could probably blow your load just from the feeling of touching her baby soft pussy with your cock head. But you are far from inexperienced. You’re going to give Bethany quite the fucking.

You slowly ease your cock forward. It takes a fair amount of pressure to inch your way in. Bethany clenches her teeth and moans out. The pleasure consumes her pain though. Surely this is what she wanted. This is why she went on a date with a stranger, an older woman on her 18th birthday. This is why she went back to this stranger older woman’s house. Bethany wanted to lose control - she wanted to be taken. She was taken by a woman and now also a man. This is what happens when you lose control and submit to what life brings you and it feels incredible.

When you’ve finally gotten your cock all the way inside of Bethany Isabella tells her “Happy birthday,” and Bethany smiles brightly.

Not many girls orgasm the first time they’re fucked, but Bethany had the help of Slave4U to excite her. Once you got to fucking her harder, when you were really pounding her de-virginized pussy, she came right on your fat cock. Her body shook in Isabella’s arms and Isabella burst out laughing, thinking how hard of an orgasm Bethany was having considering she was so **** to get fucked in the first place.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)