Kitty Virginity ♡

"Alright Lilith, if you want this, then let's do it..." - Finn replied to Lilith's offer, with an enthusiastic, and wicked grin, that not only made Lilith excited, but a little nervous to try having sex.

"Okay... is it going to hurt?" - Lilith asked, back to her shy tone, as she saw how Finn got into position to penetrate her. And while he didn't want to waste time to take her virginity, he did slow down, to let her know everything was going to be okay, and relax her to make their first time easier.

"No, I think it will feel really good for both of us... I know we both are going to find this very pleasurable..." - Finn replied with a reassuring smile, that did calm down Lilith a bit, until she saw him pull out his massive cock. She immediately got scared again, when she noticed the huge length of Finn's dick, and even though he didn't treat it like a big thing, to Lilith his cock was definitely huge, specially when it was hard.

"You already did this with Zoey, didn't you??... You have experience with this sex thing..." - Lilith asked somewhat playfully, to hide most of her nervousness, as Finn grabbed his cock, and prepared it to take her virginity with it. And while Finn knew Lilith was making a joke about his sex skills, he did felt confident about himself, and was going to take this very seriously, since it seemed Lilith was still a bit scared.

"Yea, I guess you could say that... but I promise you I will be gentle... And hopefully I can make you orgasm again..." - Finn replied in an alluring manner, as he believed he could give Lilith a lot of pleasure with his big cock. And as he started rubbing his meat on the catgirl's pussy, she realized Finn knew what he was doing, and she trusted he would treat her right, and not harm her with his giant member. So even though she was still very nervous, she was going to allow Finn to take her virginity.

"Just put it in already..." - Lilith sighed, in fear, but a bit of arousal, as she genuinely wanted to feel Finn's dick inside of her. But after getting confirmation of proceeding with sex, Finn let out a confident chuckle, and rubbed himself a bit more on Lilith's wet sex, to then press his cock against her small entrance. And in a long moment, of anticipation for Finn, and intense fear for Lilith, her lips finally gave in to the pressure, and with one swift motion, Finn pushed his cock nearly half inside the catgirl's pussy.

"AHHH!! You said you were going to be gentle!! You are going to break me!!" - Lilith screamed instantly, as she felt a moderate amount of pain from the penetration, since Finn almost filled her up completely, and as soon as he got his cock inside of her tiny hole, he stretched her out more than if she gave birth to kittens. Finn immediately noticed his mistake, and even though he understood Lilith's pain, he decided to start thrusting gently, with hopes of her getting used to his cock quickly, so the pain could go away soon.

"Sorry, I swear this is as slow as I can go!!" - Finn blurted out, as he wasn't sure if he was causing more pain with his thrusts, or if his method was actually working. But while Lilith didn't gave him a clear response, and just lied in embarassment, and covered her blushing face, Finn did notice a change in how his dick penetrated her sex.

In the initial thrust, when Finn took Lilith's virginity, he ended up stretching her walls so much, that he almost tore her up. But after using his thick cock to thrust a little more, he actually got Lilith's pussy to loosen up a bit, allowing them to have a more enjoyable sex experience. And although Finn couldn't notice this change that much, since it still felt like Lilith's lips gripped him as tightly as before, she did feel less pain. And with every second that Finn continued to penetrate her, she started getting more pleasure, and finally being able to enjoy his cock stretching her out.

"I guess you are just really big for me... but it is fine, I can take it..." - Lilith muttered in embarrassment, which is what made Finn feel so guilty for doing this to his catgirl friend. He still felt like he was hurting Lilith with his massive cock, so he tried slowing down. And since he couldn't realize she was actually starting to like the sex, Finn just tried to apologize, because he couldn't stand seeing Lilith so shy, which he saw it as her being scared.

"Don't worry... I'll try to make it quick... I hope I can cum soon..." - Finn replied with shame of himself, as now it felt like he was taking advantage of Lilith. But before he could stop, or try to finish quickly, Lilith tried to convince him to keep going, since she was starting to get used to his size.

"No, please... try to make it last as long as you can... I want my first time to be the best..." - Lilith moaned softly, and it was these shy, but extremely hot words from her, that encouraged Finn to try to do his best. He heard all he needed, and since he felt like he had already been in a similar situation, specifically when he had his first time Zoey, he knew he needed to make Lilith's first time the greatest possible.

"Okay, I'll try..." - Finn whispered to Lilith, as he started saving energy to give his best in bed. After a quick look at the catgirl's shy, but aroused face, Finn realized he had the potential to give Lilith a lot of pleasure. He made her cum twice with just his fingers, and almost with his tongue, so he knew he could make wonders with his greatest gift, his glorious manhood.

Finn placed his hands on Lilith's hips, and firmly grabbed them, so he could have more control of his movements. And now that he was able to pull the catgirl's body towards him, or keep her steady, he started thrusting deeper inside of her, which wasn't really too much, since with just half of his length, he was able to reach the entire depth of Lilith's pussy. But since he still wanted to be gentle, Finn just proceeded to make slow thrusts that varied in depth, while keeping Lilith's body in place, to make love to her in a calm, intimate manner. And even when he was being gentle with her, since Finn's cock pretty much filled all of Lilith's insides, she was very stimulated with very little effort.

"Finn... you... really... feel... so good... i-inside m-" - Lilith moaned, with every word being separated by Finn's gentle thrusts, as she felt so much pleasure, that she couldn't even focus on speaking. And since Finn knew his dick was making Lilith's mind, and body hot, he felt the need to ask if she was about to climax again.

"That's it... are you going to cum soon Lilith??" - Finn asked, with a rather erotic grin, that Lilith couldn't even see, as she was too distracted by getting pleasured by Finn's cock.

"I think I'm going to pee again, yes..." - Lilith replied in heat, as she wasn't even able to keep a normal face even more. And while Finn thought the catgirl's pleasured face was funny, he laughed more at the fact she was using such childish words, that actually he had probably used until not too long ago. He could relate to Lilith's feeling of not knowing what will happen to her when she orgasmed, even when she already experienced it twice. But even though Finn was beginning to remember his first sexual experiences with Faranne, and Zoey, not even two weeks ago, he also started feeling like he was about to cum too.

"Okay... I will too... I'm going to cum inside of you, is that good??" - Finn asked with a wicked smile, as he knew Lilith wouldn't know what happened if a guy came inside of her. His arousal was actually making him take advantage of the catgirl's naiveness, but since he knew his sperm wasn't too good for making babies, Finn considered it a lighthearted joke.

"You are going to pee inside of me????" - Lilith asked in a childish surprise, that still sounded hot in Finn's ears. And while he got the innocent reaction from her like he expected, Finn genuinely believed that cumming inside of Lilith would be harmless, so he didn't think much about it, and decided to trust what Adeline told him.

"No... I'm going to cum... is different... you don't understand it but cum is... i-... ahh, you'll see in just a second..." - Finn tried to explain, as he struggled to contain his laughter, but also getting distracted, as he struggled to contain his orgasm. Without even realizing at first, Finn's cock started throbbing inside of the catgirl's tiny pussy. And while Lilith didn't fear the risk of getting pregnant with him, she did get nervous, since she didn't know what would happen if he didn't pull out.

"Finn??... Finn!!... Finn, I- AGHHHH!!" - {Liltih} asked in fear, before exclaiming in overwhelming pleasure, to then finally burst out in exhilaration, as she wasn't able to get any answers from Finn, and ended up having an orgasm for the second time this night, and third time in her life. But as Lilith's climax came with another huge squirt, it caused Finn to cum not long after, as all of the fluids gushing out of her pussy pressured him into releasing his load inside of her.

So with an equally ecstatic scream, Finn got to cum sooner than he expected, but luckily, it was right after Lilith's orgasm. And since his cock was already throbbing inside of her, after Lilith's orgasm, Finn felt his thickness being engulfed by all of the catgirl's juices. And as the pressure of Lilith's squirt hit his dick, right as he started cumming, Finn got to pump out all of his sperm inside of the catgirl's no longer virgin sex. But since there was so much going on inside of Lilith, it was difficult to tell what happened in all of that mess of fluids, not even Finn knew how deep he got to cum, but he did feel like he poured a thick load inside of Lilith.