Fake Innocence

"Did you enjoy it? For me that felt great" - Finn whispered, slightly exhausted, as he placed himself on top of Lilith's small body, and felt his cock twitching a few last times inside of her, to spurt the last bit of cum he had stored in his balls. And while they both were trying to recover from their mutual climax, they did agree on having a lot of fun with their first time, specially Finn, who was proud of taking Lilith's virginity.

"Yea, I really liked it... Thanks for taking my virginity... I love you..." - Lilith whispered back, as exhausted as Finn was, who didn't really hear her, since he started paying attention to the mess he had created inside of the catgirl. He looked down to see how much of his sperm he had pumped inside Lilith, and in the middle of a pool of the catgirl's juices, Finn found a creamy river of his thick cum flowing out of Lilith's pussy.

"No problem... I love you too... and thanks for letting me do this with you, that is a wonderful looking creampie right there..." - Finn casually replied, as wasn't too worried about knocking Lilith up. Most of his semen poured out of the catgirl in a gorgeous sight, and even though he felt like none of it even got inside her womb, Finn still kept the idea of risking a pregnancy, since accidentally fertilizing a girl turned him on so much.

"What's a creampie??... Oh, you came inside of me... Is this how babies are made??" - Lilith asked playfully, as she slowly got over her orgasm, and turned back to her cheerful self, who did all sorts of innocent jokes, even after experiencing sex for the first time. But even though Lilith wasn't worried of seeing a bit load of Finn's cum flowing out of her, and seemed generally very calm about losing her virginity to him, he did get a little nervous, since he felt the need to explain to her what all the sex they had meant.

"Yes, I mean... technically, we are both different species, so it would be strange if we could make a baby but yes, I think this is how babies are mad-" - Finn awkwardly tried to explain to Lilith about his choice of ejaculating inside of her. He didn't really have a reason to do it, except that he was confident, and too horny to think of the risks, but he did start to realize it could have been a mistake. And while Lilith seemed to be very calm to hear all of that, as soon as she heard about the possibility of making babies with Finn, she freaked out.

"DID YOU GET ME PREGNANT???" - Lilith exclaimed in shock, which Finn couldn't figure out if it was because she was excited to get pregnant with him, or if she was terrified of the idea of getting his baby. But since Finn believed the latter option made more sense, he finally realized that he actually took advantage of Lilith's innocence, and he may still risk the chance of knocking her up.

"What?? No, no, no, no... is not like that... I think... I mean, I don't know... I believe two different species can't create a child that easily, or something like that, I'm not sure... Sorry, I didn't mean to cum inside you like that..." - Finn replied nervously, as even though the idea of impregnating Lilith excited him, he did feel the need to apologize to her immediately, since it would only be his fault if she actually got pregnant. But since Finn got worried that he ruined Lilith's innocence with sex, he couldn't stop thinking of how to fix this situation.

He felt like he just had sex with a naive child, that didn't know anything that was happening, and since having sex with a child would be considered ****, Finn thought he had really messed up this time. He started thinking of all the things Faranne would do to him, if she learned that he took advantage of her innocent sister because he was horny, or even worse, if she saw Lilith with a pregnant belly, and discovered that the father of the baby is actually Finn, he would be doomed then.

In a short moment, Finn already feared all of the consequences of this night, and started regretting having sex with Lilith, since even though it felt great, it also seemed wrong. He was going to say goodbye to Faranne's love, respect, and even make her his enemy, and probably the same with Zoey. Finn thought no one would look at him the same if he found out he had sex with Lilith, and that they will never forgive him for taking the virginity of such a precious being. But while he began to panic, Finn was surprised to hear he was just overthinking it, and instead it was all just a joke.

"Don't worry... I know all about sex, I was just pretending not to know anything to make it more fun and mess with you... I can't believe how much you panicked there..." - Lilith giggled maliciously, after watching how Finn almost lost his sanity, and mocking him for believing she was actually that innocent, who still couldn't believe if Lilith was joking or not

"Oh, so you just wanted to see my reaction?" - Finn asked with an amused, but mostly confused smile, as he couldn't figure Lilith's intentions. He was caught off guard by this revelation, although it quickly became a bit predictable, since he knew Lilith would do these types of pranks, even when it involved sex. But while Finn felt like he was being pranked all along, he was very impressed to see Lilith joking about sexual topics, or talking about her virginity, because he never thought he would do something like this, or why she would even do it. And considering that it was clear they did actually have sex, and they did actually kiss, and even confessed real feelings for each other, this didn't seem to be just a simple joke.

"Yea, it was priceless" - Lilith casually replied, with a playful smile, like nothing had ever happened. And while it was clear Finn wasn't in a dream, and the creampie he gave the catgirl was actually real, and in fact, it was still flowing out of her, he was very confused by her sudden change of behavior.

"I knew you were joking, you are always like that..." - Finn chuckled nervously, as he didn't want to admit he didn't understand what had happened. He still felt like Lilith wasn't joking about most of the stuff that happened, since it did seem genuine that she didn't know if sex was going to hurt. But since Finn couldn't tell how, or why Lilith was trying to mess with him, he just knew there was no point in trying to understand it, and just let Lilith do her usual pranks, that don't really feel like pranks because they involve real sex.

"Yea? Well, thanks for coming to talk with me today... I really enjoyed it and I hope you feel better" - Lilith continued replying, with a suspicious playfulness, that Finn decided to ignore. And since he actually got to experience all of the pleasure of having sex with the cute catgirl, Finn was satisfied, and definitely felt better than before. Although the main reason he was happy, taking Lilith's virginity, could have also been a lie, so Finn decided to confirm that before he left.

"Me too, it was great... thanks for doing this with me, but were you actually a virgin?" - Finn asked casually, with a bit of shyness, as he didn't want to get nervous from Lilith's jokes. And even though she did want to mess with Finn a little more, she could tell he genuinely cared about the sex they had tonight, and since she did too, Lilith decided to give her a serious answer for once.

"Yes, you actually took my virginity so congrats!... Oh, and also... squirting is basically peeing, so I did piss on your hand and penis..." - Lilith replied, with a big cheerful smile, to finally show some honesty, but also a bit of her playful nature, that made both her and Finn laugh. And while Finn didn't mind knowing that Lilith peed on his fingers and cock, he got happy to hear her joke, since it did show that Lilith valued the fun they had, and she probably had real romantic feelings for him, that he had too.

"Alright Lilith, keep being you... I'll see you later then..." - Finn said somewhat sheepishly, as he didn't have the courage to confirm his doubts with Lilith. But before he could leave with his doubts, Lilith seemed to know what Finn was thinking of, and to prove her love for him, she gave him a quick kiss on the lips that he received with pleasure.

"Bye Finn... I don't know if we could do more of this, but I hope we can talk again, and you know, have more fun... I do love you, and well, I just want you to know that... goodnight..." - Lilith replied with a sweet smile, to confirm all the doubts Finn had, who was full of joy to hear there was actual pure love between him and Lilith. But since he knew they weren't going to talk too often, he just gave her a smile, to then turn around, and walk away, hoping one day they could talk again, and maybe have more intimate sex with Lilith... it would be hard to know though, but maybe soon Finn could spend more time with his favorite catgirl...