Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by JustForFun5676 JustForFun5676

What's next?

A Buttplug Tail!

Amber watched while speechless at the sex toy carefully fitted into the box. As soon as she opened the compartment, she quickly recognized what it was, she wasn't so innocent that she didn't know what a butt plug tail was. Nervously, she bit her lower lips.

"That can't be true!" She thought , while brushing her hair with her hand

It was a reasonably large butt plug, bigger than any object she'd ever tried to shove up her anus. The object was also made of shiny metal, having a widened base that served to hold it in position and support the weird white cat tail. She held it in her hand and looked at the toy for a few moments, until she heard the voice again:

"Two minutes" announced the mechanical voice.

She barely noticed the time passing...

"Shit!" She thought as she ran towards her closet to get an old lube she didn't even use properly.

Thankfully she found the liquid fast, in time for her to lie on her back at the bed, wet the sex toy with lube and slowly start to insert it into her anus while opening her legs.

"Aaaaahhn" She moaned a little and rolled her eyes a bit, as the thickest part of the butt plug slowly entered her hole. But after a moment of acute pain, the toy was already lodged...

"BEEP" Her leash sounded in approval.

"Whoever did this to me will pay!" She thought, as tears began to flow from her face again. Now, she constantly felt the invader, with every movement, which made her anus feel stretched, burning and sensitive, while she felt the tail fur rub her inner thighs.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)