Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 23 by YZS YZS

Is it finally time to actually lose their virginities?

The First Time ♡

"Love! Let's make love... actual sexual intercourse! I want us to become one and be together as true lovers... I want you inside of me to finally take my virginity!" - Zoey exclaimed cheerfully, but also blushing, as she was very shy to request Finn to take her virginity, but he seemed excited too, so that made her smile.

"You mean... we are finally having sex?... but what if we don't know? What if we are not good?" - Finn asked nervously, as he was very afraid of losing his virginity.

"It doesn't matter... just for fun, let's try it and if we are not good at it we can always try again and get better... also, we will be losing our virginities and honestly I've always wanted to do that with you" - Zoey said with a sweet tone, that enticed Finn, and he smiled as a response to the idea of losing their virginities, and since he knew it was probably not a big deal, he decided to give it a shot.

So after agreeing on it, Zoey lied down on the soft grass, and spread her legs to allow a good view of her still soaking wet pussy to Finn, who lowered himself, and prepared his cock for penetration. He was extremely nervous, but after seeing the cute shy expression on Zoey's face, he decided to go for it, and started kissing her body seductively, to tease her a little. He started with the neck, and then moved to her perky breasts, and small nipples, before he found himself kissing Zoey's inner thighs. All of this was arousing her even more, but since she was more than ready for him, it frustrated her a little that he was taking so long to take her virginity.

"I know you are nervous... I am too, but don't you see I'm already soaking wet for you?? I need you inside me right now... I'm ready for you to take my virginity, please do it..." - Zoey said nervously, while she looked away shyly, since she was very nervous to see how Finn popped her cherry, and she covered her face, to hide her embarrassment.

After Zoey practically begging for him to penetrate her already, Finn gathered up some courage, to place his erected cock on her crotch. He didn't know what he was doing, and also was confused by the two holes that were present in between her legs. He remembered where she had inserted her fingers to pleasure herself, so he knew where he had to insert his dick. He tried to ignore the hole below the one he had to focus on for now, and he pressed the head of his cock against her wet entrance. He took some very big breaths, and looked at Zoey to see if she was ready, but since she was covering her face, so he couldn't see.

"Okay, I'm ready... Are you ready?" - Finn asked nervously, as he rested his meat on Zoey's sex, and after an akward silence, she replied.

"Yes... just do it already... but please be gentle with me... I love you baby, now take my virginity" - Zoey muttered nervously, as she was more shy than ever. But since she was covering her eyes, she couldn't get to see the moment when Finn decided to push his large dick gently inside her. It was very easy, as her wet folds were basically inviting his cock to enter her pussy, and so he slid it right in, with no effort whatsoever, it even felt normal for him at first, but Zoey felt it pleasurable immediately.

She moaned softly, as she felt her small lips stretching around his thick cock. She started shuddering, as the feeling of having Finn inside her, gave her a mix of emotions. He took it calmly, as he found the way the head of his penis disappeared inside of Zoey's pussy quite satisfying, and that incentivized him to go a little deeper, just an inch deeper, to feel how it was. It felt tighter, but very soft, like the walls inside her caressed his dick gently, as Zoey started relaxing, now that she had a full inch of Finn's meat inside of her. It already felt pretty good for her, but the fear really took a lot away from the experience.

This was the case with Finn too, as he was very scared of going further, since he felt the walls inside her already very tight, and thought if he went deeper it could hurt her.

"Are you okay? Should I continue?" - Finn asked, with a concerned tone, as he didn't know what he was doing, but neither did Zoey, so it was an awkward situation.

"It feels nice... I think you can, but I already feel like you have filled me up with your penis... just continue to be gentle please..." - Zoey replied softly, as she was very shy, even when they haven't even started having sex yet.

"Okay... I will, I promise... tell me if it hurts and I stop" - Finn said nervously, before pushing his cock deeper into her. Now it was probably 3 inches deep, and her insides felt very tight at this point, so tight in fact, that it felt like it was gripping his dick somehow. He got scared, but then distracted by Zoey's soft moan, as he pushed deeper inside of her pussy.

"Are you comfortable? Does it hurt? What do I do now??" - Finn asked, a bit scared, as he didn't know what to do, but thankfully Zoey replied calmly.

"Is okay... it feels even better... you can start thrusting now... slowly, try not to go any deeper than that... I don't know how to do it but I guess this position kinda works" - Zoey replied, quite unsure of her answer, as she really didn't know how to have sex, but since Finn also didn't know, he just followed her instructions, and started thrusting.

Finn started thrusting his dick inside of Zoey's pussy, but he wasn't moving too much, even then, as he always reached around the 3 inches length, he was getting some pleasure out of it, from how good her pussy gripped his penis. He didn't know how to properly penetrate her, so he just thrusted slowly, in an awkward position, that became a little better, when Zoey locked her legs around his hips, allowing better penetration, and some more pleasure to her, but it all still ended up being pretty awkward.

So with Finn on top of her, thrusting slowly, and gently into her to try, and give her some kind of pleasure with his rock hard cock, Zoey just stared at him, with a shy look, as it felt weird having him on top, while being so focused on making love to her. He was looking down at his cock, to see how he was doing, so he didn't notice Zoey staring at him for a while, and when he finally did, she gave him a sweet smile, and giggled in heat.

"Am I doing a good job?" - Finn asked nervously.

"Yes... it does feel nice... but it’s a little... I don't know, maybe it can get better with time or maybe we just need more experience with sex" - Zoey replied, with an optimistic smile.

"I'm sorry... I don't know what I'm doing..." - Finn said, with an insecure frown, as he looked down, but then Zoey placed her hand on his cheek, and caught his attention.

"Don't worry... you are doing great... is not your fault, we just need to learn and I'm sure then we can make some sweet love... for now just continue making love to me" - Zoey whispered softly, as she looked at Finn, with some sweet eyes, before pulling him into a small kiss, while he continued penetrating her young, tight cunt.

"How does my pussy feel?" - Zoey whispered into Finn's ear, before chuckling, as she has never used that word before.

"It feels... great, is like tight around my penis..." - Finn muttered nervously, as he was too distracted maintaining his slow pace with his gentle thrusts. Zoey wrapped her arms around his neck, to hug him, and hold him, while smiling, after hearing her lover was getting some pleasure from penetrating her virgin, wet pussy. She continued holding him, as she closed her eyes, and just enjoyed the moment.

It was a little awkward, as it was all silent, apart from the ambience sounds, Zoey's occasional soft moans, and the hot, wet sounds, from Finn slowly penetrating Zoey, that were barely hearable, but made the moment more special. It made Zoey smile, as she loved hearing how Finn's cock stretched her tight pussy, and created those small wet sounds, but as she paid attention to those sounds, she also noticed Finn's heavy breathing.

For the both of them, it was a truly beautiful ,and special moment, where both lovers got to experience sex for the first time. Sure, they were unexperienced, they only tried one position, it was awkward, a little uncomfortable, Zoey barely got any pleasure from it, as the penetration wasn't deep enough, and it felt like Finn had a great, and big tool, but he didn't know how to use it. But all of that was normal, it was part of the experience, they were shy, and scared, and it wasn't the best sex in the world, but the fact that they were sharing such an intimate moment, was all that mattered to them, it meant that they were finally lovers, and they were able to share their true love, after years of frustrations and doubts, even if it that true love is akward at first.

And it was all coming to an end apparently, as Zoey heard Finn's breath getting heavier and heavier. She knew he was about to cum, and she got very excited for it, so she kissed his neck, and started whispering in his ear to encourage him.

"Are you going to cum, baby?" - Zoey whispered seductively into his ear.

"I... think... so..." - Finn replied, as he struggled to keep the pace of his thrusting.

"Then cum... cum for me... please baby... let it all out, is okay..." - Zoey whispered softly, while caressing his neck, and nuzzling up to him, while holding him closer, to feel, and share his orgasm.

"Alright... I think I'm about to... cum!!" - Finn announced, as he felt his cock throbbing inside Zoey's pussy. He stopped thrusting, and just waited, as he felt a rush of pleasure travelling through his body, and up his shaft, to shoot all of his semen inside of Zoey. But as she felt Finn's cock pulsating, she quickly remembered something Faranne had warned her about years ago.

"Wait!! No!! PULL OUT!! PULL OUT NOW!!!" - Zoey squealed. as she remembered the risks of having vaginal sex. She got very scared all of a sudden, so she screamed to alert Finn not to creampie her, and since he was so startled by her, he immediately pulled out of her pussy, right as he started shooting a big load of cum, that ended up on Zoey's belly. She got covered with his semen, but didn't even notice, as they both got scared. Finn didn't even get to enjoy his orgasm, as he was very worried about what happened.

"What's wrong??" - Finn asked in panic, as he noticed he had ejaculated all over Zoey's belly.

"Thank Light!! You almost came inside me!! I couldn't let you do that... I'm sorry... is just that I forgot that I could get pregnant by this so you know, you had to pull out..." - Zoey explained calmly, as she stared at Finn, who was still startled, but understood what just happened.

"Oh, okay... yea, right... I forgot about that... good thing you told me and I actually listened, I almost shot all of that inside of you..." - Finn said playfully, as he pointed at her belly, covered in his seed. She looked down, to see how big his load was, and was surprised to see that her belly was covered in cum.

"Oh wow... yea, good thing you pulled out... if you had shot all of that we would have ended up having a couple of babies" - Zoey said flirtatiously, before they both laughed, and stared at each other, while Finn went soft.

"Come here... I love you" - Zoey whispered, before Finn leaned forward to kiss her, but stopped mid kiss, as he noticed his own cum was sticking to his body. They both looked down, and giggled, before Zoey asked him to bring her a towel, so they could clean up.

After that rather anticlimactic, and mostly akward first time sex experience between the two new lovers, they both relaxed, and spent the rest of the night on the hills, looking at the sky, and talking about this experience...

First time of many, what are the young lovers going to do next?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)