Play time

"Tell you what," Mia says. "Karishma and her gang are outside looking for you right now. I know I wouldn't want to be you if they find you. Especially in here."

"My sister and I share everything," Lisa says. She's still groping you, and your erection is responding appropriately. "But not necessarily with the whole squad."

Mia continues, "So, you all just do as we say, especially Sammy Boy. If you don't, we'll call everyone back in here; and we can't be held responsible for what might happen then."

"And if we do?" says Rachel.

Lisa answers, "Once we're satisfied, you can all leave. And this can be our little secret."

"Well, what do you want?" you ask, not sure whether you're feeling more excitement or dread.

"I think we'd like to have a little play time," Mia says as she walks over to you.

With the twins' attention on you, Rebecca snaps out of her own reverie and resumes putting on Rachel's pants. She and Rachel exchange a look and face you and the twins. Doesn't seem like they're going to interfere one way or the other.

Lisa's hand has moved from massaging your left buttock to exploring your entire ass. She traces her fingernails along your flesh and runs her middle finger up your crack. Mia approaches you and puts her hands on your chest. "I like you, Sam," she says. "I'd like to get to know you better." She rubs her hands over your chest. You're in decent shape, nobody's vision of a god, but clearly you've captured the interest of these two gorgeous girls. You've fantasized about threesomes before, but usually they don't happen with an audience, and usually you have some say in how (and whether) they go down.

Suddenly, Mia grabs your cock, and you instinctively pull away. You back right into Lisa, who digs her nails into your butt. "Easy there, Sammy Boy," Mia says, as she strokes you. "There's no need to get jumpy." The lust in her voice is obvious, and as embarrassing as it is to be jacked off in front of your crush and a girl you barely know, there's definitely something erotic about this situation. May as well go for it, you think as precum starts to ooze out of your penis.

"Whoa, not so fast," Mia says, removing her hand. Lisa's hand has definitely not been removed, as she reaches under your ass and starts tickling your balls.

"Lisa, come here for a second," Mia says. She walks a few steps away, and Lisa follows, smacking your ass (hard) as she goes.

The twins confer for a few seconds; you can only hear whispers and giggles. Then they turn their attention back to you.

"Okay, here's the deal," says Lisa. "We want to finish playing with you, Sam, but this isn't really the best atmosphere."

"So, since you're a pervy voyeur, we thought you should get a taste of your own medicine."

"What do you mean?" you ask, your mouth dry.

"We're going to watch you get off. With one of these two," Mia says, gesturing to Rachel and Rebecca. "And you get to pick which one."

You look at the hotties in front of you. Either of them would be a total score, and of course you've had a crush on Rebecca for a while now. But not like this! This is awful - you're really not into the **** stuff, especially if you ever had any shred of a chance with either of these girls. Not to mention the humiliation of cumming on cue; not much sexy about that, at least not for you.

But what can you do? In a sense, complying with Mia and Lisa is good for Rachel and Rebecca because it might get you all out of there faster. You have a sinking suspicion, though, that either girl you pick is going to hate you. And the realization dawns that the twins know this as well.

You take a deep breath.

"Is there any other way?"

"This is the way, hot stuff," Mia says as she takes out her phone. "Unless you want me to invite Karishma in here to take over for us."

You look at Rachel in the eyes; she looks scared. Rebecca looks disgusted, though you're not sure whether, at this particular moment, that's directed at you or the dark-haired devils.

"Okay," you say. "I guess I pick..."