Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 25 by grimbous grimbous

What's next?

Cucked by your Daughter

You kiss Penny's cheek. "You can do this baby girl."

"Thank you Daddy." Penny responds. "I'll make you proud."

You crawl up beside El. Taking the bottle of lube you motion Penny forward, she crawls in between her mother's legs. Taking a good squirt of lube you apply it to the end of your daughter's massive tool. You wanted to make it as easy as possible on Elsie. You knew from talking with her that Fiona had been difficult for her to take, of course your older sister also didn't bother to get Elsie aroused like she was now.

El lifts up her ball sack so there is an unobstructed view of her pussy. "Jesse, want to help her start?"

You nod. Taking her thick meat in hand you guide her forward, placing her tip against her mother's tight slit. It felt so weird guiding another, much larger, penis toward the oh so familiar pussy of your beloved Elsie. You hear Elsie let out a puff of an exhale as you situate the knob into her luscious pink folds.

"Okay my girl, now you just push in. Strong and steady." You direct her.

Penny nods and then, unexpectedly, SLAMS forward like she was doing a deadlift or kettle bell swing. She buries her huge cock balls deep into Elsie's unsuspecting cunt, stretching her to the limit.

Your daughter sighs in delight but your wife/sister screams out. "AHHHH FUUUUUUUCK!"

"Slowly! Slowly!" You say way too late. You grab El's hand for support, she grips it with all her might.

Penny's eyes open wide and she stops moving, buried to the hilt, worried she hurt her mother. "Mama! Are you okay?"

Elsie's eyes were tight shut, her teeth clenched, her breathing shallow. "GOD! FUCK! You're...so much bigger...that what...I'm used to." She whimpers. "Ohhh...you have to go slower sweetie. You're stretching meee...ohhhh..."

"I'm sorry Mama, I was just so excited." She says.

"It's okay...it's okay..." Elsie breathes, struggling to adjust. "Whoooo...I haven't felt this full since Mom and Fiona...woah..." She gasps, trying to control her breathing. "And you're pressing my cervix...wow...you're just so much bigger...than you father..."

Penny slowly and carefully pulls back then pushes forward again. Both of them let out a long sigh.

"Ohhhh Mama! You are soooo tight! I never imagined it would feel so tight!" Your daughter moans. She tries another careful thrust, then another. Both of them are totally subsumed by the experience.

You lie back beside Elsie as your daughter stretched your 'wife' and plunged to depths you couldn't dream of. You still had some lube on your hand so you begin stroking yourself. You were hard as steel watching this scene unfold beside you.

Knowing Penny couldn't last long you say to her. "It's okay if you have to cum. It's your first time baby girl."

She just grunts as she presses in once more, eliciting a moan of deep sensual pleasure from your partner. "It feels different...this way...I think I'm more ready this time...I'm not gonna cum yet. In fact...I'm feeling pretty good!" You could see some confidence start infuse into her demeanor as she starts a proper slow steady rhythm.

You had been pretty confident Penny would be your typical college aged 'two pump chump', it appeared this wasn't to be. Despite your assurances to Elsie you began to have second thoughts about this, you felt jealousy stir within you.

"God...you are so deep sweetie...oh god I forgot what it was like..." You could tell Elsie was already getting close! It took you at least three times this long to get Elsie ramping up to this level. El was also hard, her big cock moving up and down her stomach as Penny thrust into her. You lay right beside her stroking yours, your little dick looking so sad and tiny in comparison. You had long since come to grips with it of course, but things seemed different again. Your old insecurities were bubbling up as your own little girl brutally cuckolded you with the love of your life.

Elsie's eyes turned to you. They were wide and almost ****, as if she was overwhelmed and losing control. Despite this she could sense your doubt and jealousy. "Oh baby...oh Jesse...don't worry baby... I love...OHHHHHHH!" Penny plunges her full depth once more. Elsie cries out. "OHHHH GOD! God damn she's so big...she's so big..." She turns to look up at her daughter. "You're so big sweetie...you're gonna make Mama cum...ohhhh...you're gonna make Mama...OHHHHH..."

Elsie convulses hard as a body wracking orgasm consumes her entire being. Her eyes are squeezed shut again as she lets out a long feral groan. You honestly couldn't remember her ever cumming this hard before. "UNGHHHHHHHH!" She yelps out. "Stop! Stop!" Penny stops her movement and lets her mother recover. It takes a few moments but El finally regains her senses. She is panting and out of breath. "Oh fuck sweetie. This feels different than it used to. So so different. Ohhhhh...probably changes in my body...from having a baby...from having you...it is much better than when I was your age...woah!"

"Are you okay Mama?" Penny asks again, concern on her face.

Elsie nods. "Mama's okay sweetie. I just wasn't ready for how you'd feel. Wow." El looks to you with worry. "You okay Jesse? Everything alright?" She huffs and puffs. She reaches out and strokes your cheek.

You nod. "It's okay El. You guys have fun." You were feeling a confusing cocktail of emotions right now. You thought you'd be okay with this, especially with it being your own daughter, but El was feeling things that you could never do to her. This was tougher than you thought it would be. But what could you say now?

Given the go ahead Penny asks. "Can I go harder?"

Elsie nods. "Yeah...I think I'm good now...I'm adjusting...just slow down when I cum okay?"

"Yes Mom."

She slowly pulls most of the way out then SLAMS back in. Both of their sizable pairs of tits bounce at the slapping impact. Penny grunts as she bottoms out while El lets out a little cry. Slide out...SLAM! Slide out...SLAM! Slide out...SLAM! The slow then fast causing El to feel every long girthy inch on the way out the suddenly be completely filled as it hammers back in. She groans. "God that feels good sweetie. Ugh. You don't know what you're doing to me. Ugh. You are filling me so full! Ugh."

Watching this happen was unbelievably arousing. You didn't care to admit it but you were getting close to busting a nut. Jesus! Your daughter seemed to have her mother's size, her own incredible strength, and her great aunt's legendary stamina. Your little girl was twice the man you were!

Not wanting to cum yet you stop stroking, you bring your hands behind your head and just lay and watch the show. You watch as the stacked young blonde fucked your soulmate better than you ever could.

You daughter notices you had stopped. "Getting tired Daddy? I can help out." She reaches over and begins stroking you as she holds on to her mothers leg for good purchase with her left.

"No no baby girl, it's okay."

It was too late. She was determined to help you out. She strokes you at the same tempo that she fucked her mother. She giggles. "It feels so weird, stroking another cock. One so...um, different" You knew she wanted to say small. She gives it a good squeeze on the next stroke. "You're lucky Mama is so tight Daddy."

You feel a blush come to your face at the inadvertent slight on your already wounded pride. You were getting so fucking close now. You grunt. "Wait...let me..." You couldn't talk straight as the feeling swelled in your balls.

Sensing what was about to happen Penny stops and really starts stroking you fast. "Don't worry Daddy, I've got it, I've got it." You let out a low bellow as you shoot your load up your stomach and chest. "Oh Daddy! Good job Daddy! There it is." Penny cheers encouragingly as she milks your jizz out onto you as you squirm and groan. "That's it, let it all out Daddy. What a nice little load."

Elsie panted, her words coming out quickly between breaths. "That's good Jesse...that's good...I love you...I love you so much..." She was having trouble stringing thoughts together at this point.

Penny reaches back and picks up the cloth from earlier and wipes off her slimy hand. She tosses it onto you. Taking both of Elsie's legs she brings them up to rest on her own muscular shoulders. "Just you and me now Mama, you're all mine." Leaning forward she pushes her mother's legs down which causes her pelvis to tilt up, exposing her to maximum penetration.

Your darling daughter then puts those hard earned and finely tuned firm muscles to their full use. She starts slow but builds her pace and intensity steadily. Within moments she is pounding relentlessly into her mother's tight tunnel with a deep rapid powerful pistoning onslaught that would make Superman jealous, her big balls slapping hard on each impact.

By this point you have cleaned yourself up. You lie there awkwardly, not sure what your role here was anymore.

As she pile drives into your beloved like a pussy destroying machine Penny glowing face looks to you. She was feeling her oats to say the least. "Am I doing good Daddy? Am I doing good? Mama is so tight, she feels so good."

Elsie is out of her mind, crying and wailing as she is brought to the very heights of passion again and again. She desperately reaches for you. "God! God! Jesse! Hold me! OHHHHHHHH!"

You sidle over to her and lean over her to embrace her. She buries her face in your neck as she whimpers. "Jesse...fuck...she's so big...she's so good...ohhhhh ho ho hoooooo..." She bucks with another orgasm, gripping you tight. She looks up into your eyes, her hair messy, her brow sweaty, her head being pushed up and down from the pussy ****. "Oh Jesse, I love you so much. I love you so much." She pulls you down and kisses you deeply, whimpering into your mouth. "Look at your little girl go." She whispers. "Look at our girl, all grown up, isn't she amazing?"

Tilting back to your side you look up at your daughter. She smiles at you proudly, her pretty blue eyes twinkling. She was getting close. She is sweating, grunting, flexing. But she looks to you, wanting to see your reaction. She was showing you what she could do. She was trying to make her Daddy and her Mama proud.

Something snaps within you and you shake your head. Why were you feeling this way? You knew what your family women were like, you were a fool to compare yourself to them. Who were you mad at exactly? Elsie? It wasn't her fault she was feeling this way, it was a physical reaction. Penny? This was her first time, she was trying so hard to do her best after her parent's unexpected invitation. Yourself? Who did you think you were?

You take stock. Elsie loved you, Penny loved you, you loved them. What else really mattered?

You expel your negative feelings and focus instead on the love. "That's it baby girl. You're doing so good. You're doing so good. We're both so very proud of you!"

At that she groans and buries her cock once more into her mother's well fucked honey pot. She flexes as she pumps El's pussy full of her hot jizz. Elsie also cums yet again, bucking up at her daughter. You position yourself between them, grabbing them both you bring them into you and hold them close. They each clutch to you and each other, their hot breath and moaning voices on your face as they ride out their world shaking climaxes.

You feel them both relax in your arms as they crest the wave and come out the other side. Together you all collapse down onto the bed. Elsie shudders as Penny's massive anaconda slithers out of her. You lie in the middle, Elsie manages to snuggle into your shoulder on your right before she goes limp, Penny snuggles into you on your shoulder to the left.

The three of you lie together. The two women, the two women you loved most in this world, let out long satisfied sighs. You hug them tight.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)