An Alternate Path (Cuckold/Cuckquean Path)

(Okay all, this will be a huge departure from the usual Jesse-Elsie stuff. This will be a short alternate history sort of path from the main thread. Don't take anything in this tread as 'canon' outside of this side thread. If you don't care for the SPH/Cuckold/Cuckquean stuff PLEASE STOP READING NOW. Jesse and Elsie will be cucked and egos will be bruised. I totally and completely understand that these aren't popular fetishes. Sorry for sounding defensive but these types of stories just seem to invite criticism and negativity for some reason, it is downright brutal over at Literotica.)

You lie together for a long time, the three of you snuggling and bonding in the afterglow. You finally break the silence. "Whooo...what a night." You sigh.

Penelope giggles and snuggles into you as El just lays quietly kissing your chest. She's not just quiet, she's very quiet. Her face reacting subtly to thoughts as they passed through her mind. Something was definitely on her mind.

Your daughter reaches down and tickles your balls. "It's not over yet I hope!" She laughs. "You and I only came twice and Mama hasn't even gotten off that way yet. The night is still young."

You and El look at each other in disbelief. You turn back to your daughter. "Penny...how many times can you usually cum?"

She seems confused by the question. "I dunno, with my cock? I guess four if I've got the time. First time is always so fast, I don't really count that one."

"Oh my goodness Penny." Elsie marvels. "That's not...that's not normal honey. Four? Plus a fast one? That is highly unusual. Your poor father is probably down for the count at this point." You can't help but note she didn't include herself in that statement.

"Noooo!" Penny laughs, as she sees you are both serious she laughs even harder. " Ha ha ha. No way! You're joking! Twice? That's it? And he doesn't even last that long..."

"Penelope!" Elsie interjects, attempting to shield your ego. "Your father does just fine...for a man."

Penny keeps giggling. " He he he. I honestly thought his time with me was his first fast one, but..."

"Penelope." Elsie says again. "Your father's a wonderful man." She kisses your chest once more and strokes it lightly with her fingers.

You remind yourself to focus on the love and good feelings. Those jealousy pangs were hard to ward off though. You decide to grapple with these feelings head on. You and El's relationship was based on openness and honesty in all things, you had absolutely nothing to worry about. Besides, you knew for a fact that she preferred a normal sized man over her super hung family women, she had always said so. Although, something Elsie had said earlier...

"Whooo..." You say again, trying to keep the tone light and easy. "El, you said she felt different than you were expecting? Than you were used to in the old days?" You give her a smile though she isn't looking up at you at the moment. You feel she is specifically avoiding eye contact at the moment.

She laughs nervously. "He he...yeah, I guess so...yeah...it was definitely different this time...way different..." There is a long pause as you and Penny wait for her to continue, but she doesn't. She seems at a loss for words or lost in thought.

Penny smiles proudly. "I did good, didn't I?"

Elsie sighs, reaching across she takes her daughters hand. "Oh my goodness my girl, you did more than good. You were incredible."

"Better than Daddy?" Penny asks with a little wink up to you.

"Mmm..." El hums noncommittally, neither confirming or denying. Elsie was definitely acting funny about this. Why didn't she just tell Penelope the truth? Somehow by dancing around and avoiding the this issue El was making this even more difficult and awkward.

In the early days when you would often have your moments of insecurity concerning your size compared to the rest of your family but Elsie would always assure you about her preferences. Swear to you that you were her perfect lover. These assurances weren't forthcoming this time around. Sure, El had enjoyed a big one this time, but surely she was still the same old Elsie. And why the fuck were these doubts titillating you?

Penny sensed the awkwardness in her mother's silence, her bratty side got the better of her. "He he he, I was too! I was better! Ha! I mean it was pretty obvious I guess."

El just says quietly. "I didn't say that. He's a wonderful man and I love him so very much. It's not a competition."

You sigh and squeeze them both to your body. You say confidently. "Sorry Penny my girl, your mother likes them like mine baby. Yours is just too big for her." Even if Elsie had changed and Penny did have you beat on the physical side, you knew what you and El had went so much deeper than the physical.

Penny's competitive nature is sparked. "It is not! Tell him Momma!"

She says in an over rote manner. "Your father's the one for me...he's..." She trails off, then picks up again with more feeling. "He's my perfect lover."

Elsie hugs you tight. You squeeze her into your side letting her know everything was okay. Although you weren't 100% sure anymore. El's peculiar evasiveness was stoking old fears and worries like nothing else could.

Suddenly El looks up at you in something approaching desperation. "Jesse...make love to me. Now. I need you to make love to me right now." As you look into those deep brown eyes of the woman you fell in love with you see that she wasn't worried about you, she was worried about herself. "Please baby, I need this." She pleads.

"Awwww...that's so sweet." Penny says. "Make love to her Daddy. I want to see you guys in action." Her hand is still fondling and playing with your testes. "Don't worry Daddy, we'll get your proud little soldier up and at attention again."

There was a dire urgency in Elsie's expression. "Please Jesse...I need this. Right now."