Life as a Cuckold begins

You would take a bullet for this woman. You loved her more than anything in the world. You weren't as young as you used to be but would try your best. Besides, you wanted to prove yourself to her. Prove it to yourself. Remind her why you were her perfect lover. "Of course Elsie, of course."

At your confirmation Penny cheers then wriggles down to your crotch. Taking your shriveled and spent dick between two fingers wiggles it back and forth and laughs. "Awww...look how cute it gets. You're so adorable Daddy. I think I was bigger than this when I was ten." Fuck! Talk about humiliating...yet you could feel a surge down below nonetheless. First she gives it a little kiss then she wraps her lips around it. Holding it with her lips she begins licking and playing with the knob in her mouth. She positions herself so she can look up at you as she does so. It begins to respond, again seemingly more from the accidentally condescending words than the actions...though that couldn't be the case. Could it? You seemed to be tapping into a different reservoir of kink that you were accustomed to.

Elsie whispers down to her. "Thank you for helping Penny." She turns to you. "Thank you Jesse, thank you so much for understanding. Let's show her how it's done!"

You look at her worried eyes. Something just wasn't normal here. "Elsie...what's the matter baby?"

She averts her eyes. "Nothing...I just want you. I want you in me. I need to know...that you're still my perfect lover. I mean I already know...but..." She trails off. She takes a breath then looks back up at you. "It really was different with Penny, not like the old days at all. Back then...it always hurt...but now..."

You lean down to kiss her. "It felt good this time?"

She nods. "Yeah. Really good Jesse. My body's changed. She fills a part of me I didn't even know needed filling." You had heard this was a thing some women experienced as they got older. Hell, your older sister made her living off of women like that and their cuck husbands. You were happy your relationship with Elsie was solid enough you wouldn't have to worry about that. "She was so deep baby, she filled me up so nice. Oh my goodness, I can't even describe. It was so different from what I remember, so much better." She says in her sweet voice.

Your cock surges at her talking like that, at the unwanted mental pictures flashing in your mind of her taking a much larger cock. The thought of that big dick stretching her and delving to places you could never reach. You try to convince yourself it was just Penelope's enthusiastic oral attentions getting you excited, but it was more than that and in your heart you knew it.

Currently Penny was sucking you hard up, then gobbling back down on you, then repeating. Her tongue dancing over your meat as she did so. Given her inexperience she was doing great. Doing everything in her power to resurrect your spent manhood. You could tell she was actually getting a bit frustrated though. You hear her whisper harshly during a quick break from sucking. "Come on you little fucker." As she pulls on it with her hand. It was still only at half mast. In her impatience she begins to suck even harder!

Elsie adds with a smile. "But you're the one, you're my Jesse."

"And you're my Elsie. I'm glad she made you feel good." You say softly to your life partner.

"She did. She made me feel things..." She then reaches down past her daughter's persistently sucking face and plays with your balls. "But not as good as you. Not like you Jesse." The way she said that, it sounded like she was trying to convince herself. "Come on baby, I need you so bad right now." She begins sucking on your nearby nipple, nibbling it oh so gently like she did.

You lie back and let them work their magic. Once more unwittingly your imagination rewinds a little while and you see once more in your mind's eye your precious daughter ravaging your wife's tight pussy. A heady mixture of jealousy, love, and the new strange unfamiliar arousal wells up within you. You suddenly hear Penny say with an exasperated sigh. "Finally! There you go Mom, hard enough to cut glass!" She giggles. Once more you try to pretend it was Penny's bj and not your thoughts of your own inadequacy that did the trick. It was getting more and more difficult to deny the obvious though. Something about this got you very excited.

El looks up at you with a look of lust and hunger. She wanted you so bad! She lies back as you get up and give her the center of the bed. Lying back she spreads herself for you, her loving eyes focused and dreamy as she gazes at you. As you square up between her legs you only then notice the copious amounts of jism streaming out of her sweet familiar pussy. Penny had dumped multiple man sized loads into her mother it appeared. You didn't care.

You situate yourself against her as you gaze deeply into each other as you always did, rejoicing in that special connection you had. She is breathing heavy in anticipation. Grabbing your almost totally hard dick you guide yourself into her. You slide in with such ease and smoothness it takes you off guard for a moment. Her velvety tunnel was slippery with cum...but that wasn't the only reason. Her freshly stretched and well fucked pussy offered little resistance. This new sloppy loose feeling from your partner was...exhilarating! It was new and naughty. You groan in pleasure as you maintain your eye to eye connection with her.

It is then...it is then you see it. For the first time ever...you see disappointment in your beloved Elsie's loving eyes. The question she had been wondering about had been answered and she didn't like the outcome.

She spreads for you. "Come on baby, deeper. Deeper baby." But you'd given her all you had to give. You press hard into her, sinking every last iota you had into her. You just barely hear her moan very lightly to herself in soul rending regret. "...oh no...no no no...what have I done?"

The moment is gone in an instant and she lets out a happy sigh and she smiles her pretty smile up at you. She tilts up to meet you and sighs. "That's it...that's it Jesse...fuck me baby..." She moans. "Ohhhh....god...yes...YES!"

You stop mid thrust. No! It couldn't be... She was faking it! You could see it in her eyes! For the first time ever she was faking it in order to assuage your male ego. The deception actually wounded you more than the truth.

She looks up at you and sighs. "What's wrong? Keep going...."

You feel Penny stick two fingers up along your shaft. "Looks like you got room to spare Daddy." She giggles again. "You're stretched out like a slut Mama."

"Penny, leave your Dad be. You just watch for now." Elsie scolds.

"Okay Mama. Whatever you say." Penny settles down beside you, head propped up on one arm as she lays on her side.

Elsie nods to you. "Come on my man...fuck me Jesse." You feel as she clenches mightily around your meat, jizz drizzling out as she does so. "Yeah! You feel so good baby!'

You start up once more, sliding effortlessly in and out of your precious Elsie's slick creampied cunny. Fuck...why did this feel so goddamn good? This loose sloppy slick feeling. Perhaps just the differentness of it after all these years together.

You keep your gaze on hers and she struggles to meet it. Her deception was impossible to maintain while looking you straight in the eye. She closes her eyes and sighs and moans and groans, every false noise a lash across your back and simultaneously and peculiarly providing extra excitement to your now steel hard cock. Why were you excited by this?

She opens her eyes, and sees you gazing down at her. "Kiss me!" She sighs, trying to pull you in to break the eye contact. You instead hold her down and continue to fuck her as she attempts to reach up for a kiss. You let your intense gaze do your talking, letting her know you were seeing right through her deception.

You then continue making love in silence as both of you come to grips with what was happening. Both of you experiencing new feelings that you were unaccustomed to. You'd made love hundreds of times, maybe thousands...this time was different. There was the most peculiar concoction of love, guilt, jealousy, regret, novelty and an incredibly intense arousal all swirling as one.

"Geez Daddy, pick it up. You're gonna put her to sleep at that pace." Penny complains. She was stroking herself and was hard as ever. Christ that girl was a machine!

"Penny...please just be quiet sweetie." El says softly.

Elsie then stares into your eyes with sorrow and regret. There is a long quiet moment as the pair of you acknowledge the reality of the situation.

She pulls you to her, bring her mouth to your ear, then whispers very softly at you. Softly enough so that Penny couldn't hear. "I'm so sorry. I've made a horrible mistake. I'm so sorry Jesse."

You keep your slow steady pace. You whisper back. "It's okay baby. It was too soon, we should have waited. That's all."

She bites her lip as you pull back to look down at her lovingly, she looks so very guilty. She shakes her head. "That's true. But it's not just that. I'll always know now...I'll always feel the difference now. I'm so sorry. I didn't expect her...to feel so good. Fiona warned me not to do it with the family anymore...I should have listened."

Something within you was triggered. While this was arousing you like crazy from some demented reason, another part of you was screaming at you. Fuck this! You weren't going down without a fight! Planting your hands to either side you begin fucking Elsie as fast and hard as you could. Just from the sound of the slap you could tell it wasn't as hard as Penny, but you put everything you had into it. El moans, her breathing heavy. "Yes! That's it...that's it baby...give it to me....let me feel you!" Sitting back you bring her legs together in front of you and hold them together as much as you could, causing her to tighten up a bit. She as well is trying to help by tightening her vaginal muscles...but she couldn't keep them clenched forever. You soon feel her loosen up once more. You fuck with wild abandon.

Penny chirps up. "That's more like it! Go Daddy!"

You are huffing and puffing, plowing into the love of your life with all you had. She is looking at you with wide encouraging eyes. "Yes! Yes! That's it." Her usually snug little pussy was still good but it wasn't perfectly tight anymore, it was now making little queefing pussy farts on each penetration. You fuck her deep, you fuck her hard, you fuck her fast. She gazes at you with wide aroused eyes, aroused but hardly in the grips of orgasmic passion.

You feel the inevitable come and you just keep going, giving your all to the bitter end. She was just starting to get going as you start groaning and heaving. "Ohhh...just...a bit more baby...just hold it...oh god..."

"GAHHHHH!" You cry out as you blast whatever you had left in your near empty balls into her. You release her legs which flop down to either side of you and fall forward. You bury your face in her shoulder and groan as you expend every last bit you had to give. Grunting and heaving. Your body finally relaxes and you turn to look at her with a satisfied grin.

"Ohhh." She says with a calm patient supportive smile back, you knew she hadn't cum. "That's good baby. So good. Good, good, good." She strokes your cheek. "I love you so much Jesse, so very much my wonderful man." She kisses you deeply and passionately. "I love you so much!" She hugs you and squeezes her cunt around you in an embrace, your spent meat squirts out with a little plop.

She strokes once more you as you part. "Oh Jesse. My love. My one and only." Your heart swells with love...then you then see her eyes move to the side to look just past you, to behind you. She says. "Hold on Penny, let me change positions first sweetie." Your daughter had moved up to be ready for sloppy seconds, or thirds in this case, and had her huge hard rod ready and in hand. Extricating herself out from under you Elsie kneels beside you on her hands and knees. Offering herself to her daughter doggy style. "Hurry up my girl, your Dad got me close. I need your big..." She cuts herself off. "I need you."

Despite having gotten off so many times earlier tonight El wanted more. You had gotten her to the verge without actually taking her over the edge.

"I won't let you down Mama!" Penny promises.

Penny rushes to get into position. She suddenly holds up. You see El push back against her daughter but Penny holds her off. She says. "Hold on Mama, maybe we shouldn't. I'm not sure Daddy likes it when I out fuck him." You could see by the bratty look in her eye she was playing. In her naive inexperience she thought this was pure role play and that you were all on board with the fantasy.

Elsie couldn't see the playful look on her daughter's face however. She thought she was serious. "Oh no! Come on my girl! Don't leave me wanting like this." She looks over at you desperately. "Tell her Jesse, tell her it's okay." You see her blink and get control of herself again, her impatience and desperation for satisfaction having claimed her for a moment there. She then says in a calmer sweet loving voice. "Sorry. I mean...It's okay isn't it? You understand right? You need to say if it isn't baby."