Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 26 by grimbous grimbous

What's next?

Pillow Talk

You lie together for a long time, the three of you snuggling and bonding in the afterglow. It is Penelope that finally breaks the silence.

"Mama?" She says in almost a whisper.

Elsie moans a satisfied moan once more then open her eyes. They look across at each other over your chest, their heads resting on your opposite shoulders. "Yes Sweetie?"

"Um...thank you guys for letting me join you, but..." She hesitates. Elsie reaches across and strokes her daughter's long blonde hair.

"Go ahead, you can tell us anything." El says.

"Um...is it okay if, uh, you and I...how can I say this?" She then just blurts it out. "I don't want you in me Mama. I don't think I'm ready for that. Daddy filled me up so nice, and...uh...I want to stay nice and tight."

Elsie continues to stroke her daughter. "Penny sweetie, you don't ever have to do anything you don't want to. Not ever. Once you find someone of your own you won't even have to worry about us anymore."

You squeeze your daughter and kiss her forehead. "This is just a temporary arrangement my girl."

She lets out a relieved sigh. "Okay. Thank you." Then she asks. "I did good, didn't I?"

Elsie groans. "Sweetie, you did more than good. I can tell you I have never been fucked like that in my life. You are truly gifted my child."

"Even better than Daddy?" She wonders.

You intercept the question to help El avoid having to answer it without hurting your feelings. "Baby girl, you put me to shame. You are incredible." You squeeze her.

She looks up at you with her wide blue eyes. "And how was I for you Daddy? Was I good?"

You chuckle. "Well, I couldn't really move, and you kind of just did it all yourself, but yeah...you were great. You felt great."

"Even better than Mama?" She asks.

"No." You answer truthfully. "You felt incredible. But there is really only one woman for me." El sighs and kisses your chest as she presses into you.

"Humph!" Penny's face scrunches up, this obviously bothered her. "I'll do better next time. I promise." She seemed absolutely serious about it.

Both you and El let out a laugh. "This isn't a competition Penny, just relax and enjoy it. Okay?"

"Okay, I guess." She says reluctantly. "So...what else do you guys like to do? What do you want to do next?"

You and El give each other a look of disbelief, you were both spent at this point. Penny seemed to have the idea that things were still in full swing.

"You guys want to watch some of your videos? Maybe we'll get an idea." She rolls out of bed and bounds across the room. At the laptop she closes out the video and starts looking through the other videos in your favorite collection.

El says. "Penny sweetie, I'm pretty tired."

Without looking back she giggles. "That's okay Mama, Daddy's had plenty of time to rest." She seems to have found a video she liked. "Hey, this one says Family Strap On Adventure....wow. The thumbnail shows a girl doing a guy in the butt! Do you guys do that stuff?" She starts the video, maximizes it, and skips back to bed and flops down beside you.

"Well...yeah." You answer. It was really the whole reason you had the bottle of lube. "We do that from time to time."

"No way! That's amazing! Let's do that Daddy! You and me." She beams at you as she strokes herself. Holy fuck! She was starting to get hard again already!

"Penny...aren't you tired?" You ask.

She giggles again. "Of course not. I only came twice Daddy."

"How many...how many times do you usually cum?"

She shrugs. "I dunno, four. First time is always so fast, I hardly count that one."

You and El look at each other again, stunned by this revelation. Aunt Peg had some questions to answer! By this point in the video the brother character was slurping on his sister's strap on phallus. Penny was sitting cross legged beside you watching the movie. She reaches out and begins stroking your very soft and very sensitive penis. You groan in discomfort.

"Look at that Daddy! He's gonna take that in the butt. Wow, we're sure gonna have some fun tonight. Do you want to do me first?"

El looks up at you in sympathy. "I'll get you a pill." She whispers. You nod to her. You kept a stash of emergency boner pills for the nights you and El really wanted to do a marathon session. It looked like tonight was going to be one of those nights! These were new cutting edge pharmaceuticals, not like the crude little blue pills of the past, these new ones let you recover much faster so you could go an extra time or two in a night. You felt it in the morning though.

"He he he he." Penny was tittering as she watched the show. "They're gonna do it. They're gonna do it. She's putting that little dildo in his butt." The 'little' dildo was probably seven inches long. "This is pretty hot Daddy." You could see she was stroking herself with her other hand.

El returns on unsteady legs, you could tell just by how she walked that she had been well fucked that night. Without Penny seeing you take the pill, it would take a little time to work.

By this point she was getting a bit impatient. She flops your little guy between her pointer and index finger. "Your still soft, what's the matter Daddy?"

You sit up and scooch forward to sit beside her. "I need more time Penny. It's uh...it's really not normal for you to be this excited again already." From here you could see her front, along with her massive and fully erect cock jutting upward! She was fresh and ready for another round.

"It's not?" She asks innocently.

"No!" You say. "You've already cum twice, you should be done. Once is usually enough for most of us."

"Once!?" She says with incredulity. "That's just the warm up one. You mean? But... Oh no! You mean I'm even more of a freak than the rest of the family?"

"Aww Penny, you're not a freak. You're just...unique." You hug her. Looking back at El the pair of you share a determined moment of parental togetherness, Penny was a going to be a real handful in the bedroom. "Don't worry sweetie, we're gonna make this night special for you." You pull back from her, pointing at the screen you say. "You want to do that, we'll do that. Anything for my girl."

"Oh thank you Daddy!" She kisses you. "You're the best!"

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)