More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 6 by odinrandom odinrandom

Who does Josh pick? Or does he defy convention?

It's declared a tie!

Josh put in the command:

  • If both girls are able to eat cum then a second round must commence at the man's home.

    Josh grunted and came right in the middle of a switch off. Veronica and Ashley plastered their lips to his cock head and slurped up any cum they could find with their tongue. Josh flipped up the table cloth and saw Veronica and Ashley licking at each other's faces.

    “Hey ladies. So who won?”

    Veronica and Ashley blinked out of their cum induced haze and looked at each other.

    Veronica spoke first, “It looks like we'll have to see about that later.”

    “Yeah, take us home and you'll find out how good we are with more then just our mouth.”

    They straightened their dresses and ended up on the other's original seat. There wasn't much conversation from there as each girl seemed to race in everything now. Veronica did win the salad wars. Or maybe it was just that the double blow job turned them on so much that they needed the fucking that was to come. Josh had only just finished his meal before Ashley grabbed him and dragged the two of them to her car. A short trip home and Josh's two girlfriends where waiting in the living room.

    “Hey Josh? Who won?” asked Sara.

    “Ooooooh, double over time, eh?” Sara smacked Kelly for the pun. She rubbed her arm, “Come'on, it was funny!”

    Sara rolled her eyes. “We'll just watch a movie while you three go at it then.”

    They went into the master bedroom. The bed was much larger then he remembered but he's starting to get used to the random changes. He looked to his dates and they smiled back. It was a long silence bordering on awkward. “So, um, It's been a while but what are we suppose to do?”.

    They shared a questioning glance but Ashley answers, “Well, first you get to set some rules and figure out the best way to choose between us.”

    Josh tried not to show his excitement. “Well... We've already done blow jobs and that was a tie so I guess the next step is fucking. Who's got the better pussy?”

    “You got it, Boss,” said Veronica. Veronica pushed a strap to the side and it dropped, pooling at her feet. Her huge breasts on display and Josh couldn't help but fondle them.

    “Hey, no fair! You're inspecting pussies, not tits!”

    “Duh, It's obvious I got yours beat.” Veronica grabbed his hands and held them to her breasts. “Feel as long as you want, babe.”

    Ashley chucked her dress off and stood beside Veronica. She stamped her foot down, causing her tits to jiggle. “That's for him to decide...” She said, suddenly unsure of herself.

    Josh took one hand to feel up Ashley. “Well, while yours are wonderful Ashley, I must give this round to Veronica, but Veronica, we are inspecting pussies so the round doesn't count. You two on the bed. I want Ashely on her back and Veronica on top, facing her.”

    Each not wanting to lose, nor miss a good fucking, did as they were told. The ladies looked away from each other, trying not look the other in the eye. Josh noticed they didn't really seem to enjoy the position and went into his pants to fish out his phone. “Hold on ladies, work text, hold that position.” They sighed irritably but held still. He went into the phone app to quickly add: “Women are 100% bisexual.” and hit enter. He looked up to hear the sounds of his dates fiercely making out. “Much better. Are you girls ready?”

    “Mmmm-hmmm.” They said in unison, never leaving each other's lips.

    Josh got beside thier heads. His dick hard and pressed them between their kissing lips. “I need to get nice and hard ladies.” They opened their lips and licked his cock from both sides. He slid forward and back a few times. Man this phone is great, he thought to himself. He moved behind them and lined up for Veronica's pussy. “I'm going to start now.” Josh slid in effortlessly into her pussy. It felt great and slippery. He thrust a few times and enjoyed Veronica's moans. Then Josh pulled out to line it up for Ashley's pussy.

    Veronica whimpered, “Awws, thats hardly enough.”

    Ashley kissed her and gave a sly smile, “It doesn't take more then one bite to know you dislike the food.”

    “Shut up slut.” Veronica tried to make a frown but a smile won out and went back to kissing.

    Josh pushed his hard-on into Ashley and she groaned into Veronica's mouth. “Fuuuuck, momma needs this...” Veronica sucked on Ashley's slender neck. Josh rammed into Ashley, going from tip of his cock to the base on each stroke. Josh took turns fucking each pussy, enjoying Veronica's slickness and Ashley's tightness. Josh was close to cumming but didn't know who should get the second date.

Who wins the better pussy round?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)