Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 10

What happens next?

Josh comes back home

As the night progressed, Melissa got more and more annoyed with her friends. Sure, they were good friends and she loved them to bits, but they could at least be a little more considerate.

Take Tracey for instance - the girl was still naked, legs spread on the couch with two fingers knuckle deep in her pussy. While Melissa wasn't a stranger to public masturbation, she longed for the girl to cum and finish already. Despite her bravado, the brunette felt really self-conscious sitting next to her naked counterpart. Sure, she was just as beautiful as Tracey, but it was hard for a fully clothed girl to compare with a naked one.

Although she couldn't really blame the girl for not cumming. She was evidently stressed, she kept on glancing to her and the rest of their friends, as though she was scared someone would tell her to stop. Melissa didn't know why she was worried, no one cared if a girl openly masturbates.

Heck, Abigail had just finished herself! Thank god the girl was openly gay because she was doing a piss poor job at hiding it! The moment Tracey had started touching herself, Abby soon followed suit. Melissa understood where the gay girl came from, she knew she'd openly masturbate if she saw a guy do it (and a guy masturbating was so much hotter anyway, considering it was much more taboo), but still. You'd think the girl would have more self control.

With both Trace and Abby momentarily lost to the realms of self pleasure, Melissa resigned herself to chatting with Sara. But even that fell short when her boyfriend Josh arrived home. The girl fought to roll her eyes and she watched her friend run up to her partner, embracing him in a tight hug.

Josh returned the tight embraced, and politely greeted the remainder of the foursome, barely acknowledging the two masturbating girls as well as the fact that Tracey was naked. In fact, his only comment was "Hey Trace, you're looking beautiful today", but the girl was too focused to reply.

"Pay no mind to them" she heard Sara whisper and immediately his attention shifted back to her. "Could you go do the dishes? I haven't had time with the girls here and besides, you owe me.". Melissa knew that last bit was probably bullshit, but Josh begrudgingly kept his mouth shut and obeyed without question.

Bless his soul, he was just like all the others. Melissa never understood what Sara saw in him. With how obedient men were, she could easily find herself someone more in her league. With her mane of red hair and a rack to die for, any guy would jump at the chance to sleep with her. Alas, the girl had one of the lowest sex drives Melissa had ever seen.

Still, something about their relationship had always intrigued her. While men had always obeyed orders, Sara handled Josh with a naive cluelessness, almost as though she didn't recognize the power she had over him. Sure, he did whatever she asked, but the curious part was that she was always asking, never demanding. Melissa, having dancing from eager man to eager man, had never experienced the urge to do that.

Could it have to do with the fact that they were serious about one another?

With her friends otherwise indisposed, Melissa picked up Sara's discarded phone and found herself browsing through the app they'd previously discussed. Making the personal decision that it was as useless as the rest of them had deemed, she half-absently scrolled through the list of endless rules, her mind focused on Josh and Sara.

She had to admit, she was getting tired of bouncing from guy to guy. And, Tracey's argument about losing her virginity only because a guy wants too without being told did have some merit. She couldn't help but wonder what it felt like to have guy like that in her life. If only Sara would share the one she had.

Maybe.... She glanced more seriously at the phone in her hand.

No, she couldn't...

And yet...

"What the hell" she reasoned, "everyone else tried it and nothing came of it. Fuck it."

  • When a guy starts dating a girl, he's shared with all of her closest friends, becoming a communal boyfriend for the entire group.

With that, she locked the phone just as Abigail was pulling her hands out of her pants. As the two resumed their chat, it wasn't long until Melissa herself forgot about her brief exposure to the app, her change seemingly unnoticed.

Who gets Josh to themselves first?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)