Tracey

Unfortunately for Melissa, she left that night believing that the app was a dud. In fact, all of them did.

Josh, being the obedient boyfriend that he was, had spend the rest of the evening in the kitchen, washing whatever dishes came his way. Having left first unceremoniously, she wasn't around to see that, when Abigail herself also left, she'd taken the extra time to rush into the kitchen and give Josh a goodbye kiss on the cheek. Despite being gay, she didn't want to neglect her boyfriend-by-association.

And that even considering the double standard that her friend's didn't return the same courtesy whenever she brought one of her new girlfriends into the mix.

As such, when Josh finished cleaning and went to relax in the common room, only Sara and Tracey were left. The blonde, having been too nervous to get off, was once again clothed, much to Josh's disappointment. She was, after all, much more beautiful with nothing on. Still, it didn't stop him from sitting next to her on the couch. Upon his arrival, the girl snuggled closer to him, and he wrapped his arm around her.

From the **** of her grip and the haze in her eyes, it was clear she hadn't cum. Sara didn't fail to notice.

"A little bit boy crazy there Trace?" She mocked, hiding a laugh.

"What? Oh, sorry!" she said, jumping out of Josh's grip, who just joined his primary girlfriend in a shared laugh. "I forgot that's rude when you're around. I just-"

"Relax hun," the other girl interrupted, her tone soft. "He's just as much your boyfriend as he is mine."

"Yeah, come on Trace. I don't bite!" Josh confirmed, bringing the blonde back into his arms.

"It's just so... weird." She mumbled, accepting his embrace. "I'm just not used to being affectionate with you when Sara's here. I mean, she's your primary and..."

"Would you quit it with the social norms, Trace? That's Abby's job." That got a laugh out of the three of them. "Listen, as the primary, I dictate how much of Josh is shared amongst you all. And, I don't care how affectionate you are. I welcome it even! Hell, with my low libido, I'm more than happy to throw him at Melissa if it means keeping him satisfied!"

Josh just grinned in confirmation. Tracey still look unconvinced.

"You know what you need Trace?" she asked, causing the other girl to perk up. "You need to get laid, stat. You'll feel much better about Josh after you've actually fucked him. I can tell from the look in your eyes and the way you clinging to him, you're horny as hell."

"That's just because I wasn't able to get off earlier!" she counter argued.

"Sounds like an excuse to me!"

"And don't use that whole 'I want someone who wants me back' thing either!" she quickly added, dismissing Tracey's follow up before she could say it, "Josh wants to fuck you. Right Josh?"

To which he nodded, being unable to disagree.

"See? And heaven knows, you've sucked his dick plenty of times!" she finished, crossing her arms.

"I..." Lost for words, Tracey snuggled deeper into Josh's embrace. As she did, she caught a glimpse of his cock, hidden underneath his shorts and she could tell from the bulge that her boyfriend-by-association was hard. That brought back memories from how delicious his cock was, and her arousal reignited itself.

"Alright, fine!" she agreed, receiving a smirk from her two compatriots. "But you can't be there, Sara!"

At that, the girl laughed. "I wasn't planning on it; I'm heading to bed. Use the spare bedroom, will you?"

With a wide grin, Josh stood up and brought his blonde girlfriend-by-association to her feet. "Come on!" he said, dragging her with him. Nervous, anxious, and excited, the girl silently followed.