Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 23 by grimbous grimbous

What's next?

You need some womanly advice

It is closing in on 3 am when you finally get home. The big decision was coming fast and you really wanted to talk to someone about it. There was really only one person you wanted to talk to. As you quietly creep up the stairs you are happy to see a light on under Elsie's door, on one of her late night video game sessions no doubt. You approach and knock lightly. You hear some rustling then the door opens slowly. Your younger sister peers out, when she sees it is you her face brightens into a beaming smile.

"Jesse!?" She whispers, her eyes big and hopeful. "What brings you to my door this late at night?" She has a big silly grin on her face. She is wearing an oversized white t shirt with a little Totoro on it.

"I need someone to talk to." You whisper back. "I need to talk to you Elsie."

Her face goes more serious, genuine concern on her face. "Oh, yes, of course. Come in." She says. Good ol' Elsie, you could always count on her.

You walk in and see her mess of a room. You'd never been in here before and you were definitely expecting something different. She closes the door behind you.

She turns and shuts down her game then clears a spot for you on the bed. You take a seat and she sits beside you, she is facing you with an expression that tells you that you have her full support and attention.

You begin. "You know El, since the whole family secret was revealed I have been thinking about something."

"Yeah." She says.

"It's kind of a stupid thing...I...I'm really not sure how to say it..." You falter, a bit embarrassed by the topic.

"Yeah...yeah?" She nods, encouraging you onward. She takes your hand in hers.

"I...Elsie..." You look her in the eye. Her deep brown eyes are wide and twinkling. "Elsie...I just want to say..."

"Yes?" She says in a small whispered voice, she leans in toward you.

"I want a bigger cock...and you know what? I'm gonna be able to get one thanks to Aunt Peg!" You say excitedly.

She is dumbfounded for a moment, obviously stunned by this revelation. "What?" She says as her face falls.

"Yeah...isn't it great?" You smile. "I mean I always wanted a bigger one, but ever since I saw you guys I really wanted it. Tomorrow Aunt Peg is going to do it for me. It's like a dream come true!"

A weak smile plays across her lips. "Yeah...that's something..." She pulls her hand back from you, she crosses her hands on her lap.

You look at her intensely. "But I need some advice. I need to know what size to make it, I need a woman's point of view."

She looks away from you and bites her bottom lip. Boy she was acting funny. "Um...some women like it just the way it is Jesse."

"I don't care about those women." You say bluntly.

"You don't?" She asks.

"No. What do you think Mom or Allison or..." You grin. "...Fiona would like?"

She swallows. "Jesse...I like it...just the way..." She hesitates, she struggles to continue. Obviously she is just trying to appease your ego.

You give her a little slap on the shoulder. "Ha ha, come on now. That doesn't matter. I'm not going to do it with you."

"You aren't?" She says meekly.

"No! You're my buddy, my little sis, my best pal. Ha ha ha! Imagine us doing it? How awkward would that be huh?" You laugh.

Her eyes are locked on the floor as she swallows hard again. "Yeah...he he...that's so stupid...god that's so stupid isn't it...that would be awful..." She turns away from you and coughs to clear her throat, she trembles. Was she feeling okay?

You put your arm around her and give her a shake. She was obviously as overwhelmed by this news as you were. "But you know, I've always had a thing for Fiona."

"You did?"

"Oh yeah, I fantasize about her constantly. Isn't that nuts, fantasizing about your own sibling?"

"Yeah...nuts."

"Anyways, I'd really love to surprise her with a nice big one, ya know. So what do you say Elsie, what do women like?" You press her again.

She takes a deep long breath and grips her knees. She takes a long moment before answering. "I can't say about Allison of course. Mom would like it as big as possible. As for Fiona...she kind of likes it my size. Mom's just a bit too big around for her."

A bit too big around? Yeah...perfect. You wanted Fiona to really feel you.

"Okay...I'm thinking as big around as Mom's and maybe as long as yours, what do you think?" You ask.

"Yeah...that'd be great Jesse...just great...you'll make them really happy with that." She pats your knee without looking up. "Say...I'm real tired Jesse..."

You give her a squeeze. "No prob sis, I'm heading off to bed myself." She gets up and leads you to the door. You say to her as she closes the door behind you. "Hey...thanks for the help El. You're the best."

She just nods then shuts and locks the door. You hear a little gasping noise through the door. Was Elsie crying? Nah! Probably just a yawn.

You head to your room and turn the radio on, the volume low so as not to wake anyone. Katy Perry's The One That Got Away was playing. You strip down and look down at yourself. Tomorrow would be the beginning of a whole new life for you. A better life, what a future to look forward to! You would have traded anything for this, and now it was happening. You just couldn't wait.

What's next?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)