Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 22 by grimbous grimbous

Elsie says...

"This is my fault."

Elsie looks wounded but she steps into the room. "This is my fault." She says as she swallows her pride. "I should have known this would happen."

"El, this wasn't planned." You say to her. "It's not your fault." You weren't even sure what she meant by that statement.

Penelope just knelt at your side not knowing what to say. You were pretty sure she didn't regret her actions, but she did regret hurting her mother. "Mama...I...I came home...I found him..." Her fingers fidget and play nervously on your hip, it tickled.

Elsie walks by the both of you. You see her notice the paused video on the laptop as she passes, her head dips further. She continues on into the attached bathroom. You and Penny look at each other as you hear some water run in the next room.

Tears fill your daughter's eyes. "I'm sorry Daddy, I didn't mean to hurt anyone."

"It's okay baby girl, just go get the key and get me out of here and we'll talk about this." You say to her nurturingly. She nods.

Before she can go however her mother is back in the room with a moist wash cloth in her hand. Without looking either of you in the face she comes and sits to your side opposite Penny on the bed. Thankfully your daughter was on the side coated with her cum. Penny settles back down to a kneeling position again. Without looking up Elsie gently begins washing off your cock and balls with the cool cloth. Her touch is tender and caring.

"Mama...don't be mad at Daddy. This was my fault." She was tearing up again. "He did this to surprise you." She sobs.

El says in a soft calm voice. "I'm not angry. I just..." She looks up at you then at Penelope. "I just wish you guys had talked to me first. You didn't need to sneak around."

She might not have been angry, but she was definitely hurt. This killed you inside. "We weren't sneaking around El. I would never sneak around on you Elsie, I love you!" You say, knowing even more now how true that really was. "Penny's right, I did this to myself to surprise you. She came home and...well...things happened."

Penny takes her mother's hand in both of hers, their hands resting on your stomach. You lie there helpless, really wishing someone would let you loose!

"It's my fault Mama!" She cries. "I took advantage. Daddy told me to stop."

El looks at her muscular yet blubbering daughter and squeezes her hands. She drops the cloth on your junk as she had finished cleaning you. Looking at Penny she says. "No sweetie, it is my fault. It was unfair of us to expect you to keep one half of our family secret without being able to enjoy the other half." She reaches up and wipes some tears off of Penny's pretty cheek. "I remember what it was like to be your age. To have all the sexual desires of both a young man and a young woman. It is so much to deal with." She looks at you lovingly. "And sometimes you make foolish youthful mistakes. Wonderful magical life changing foolish mistakes."

You beam your love back at her as you remember your so called mistake 19 years ago. You sensed where Elsie was heading with this conversation.

Looking over to your daughter you say. "Penelope, would you like to know the other half of our family secret? The one we've kept from you all these years?"

She sniffles as she looks at you. "That the women of the family are like this." She points at her groin. "And we're really big?"

"That's half the secret." You say, Elsie glows with pride as you do the honorable Bailey thing. "The other half is, well, let's just say what your Mom and I do, and what you and I just did, isn't so weird for our family. In fact, it happens all the time."

She blinks as it sinks in. It takes a minute before she finally says. "You mean...Aunt Fiona? Chloe? Great Aunt Peg? Grandma!?"

Elsie nods. "Yes, they do it with each other all the time. Your Dad and I used to as well until we realized..." She smiles at you. "Until we realized what we had together."

"These feelings you have Penny, they kind of come natural to our clan." You say. You then lay it out for her. "In fact, until you get a boyfriend or girlfriend you want to share your secret with..."

Elsie finishes your thought. "...we'd be happy if you'd join us. From time to time."

Penny had stopped crying, she was now simply dumbstruck. "You guys aren't mad? You want me to join you?"

Elsie is still grinning at you, her deep brown eyes glimmering. "I'm happy to share him, for a little while at least. He's a pretty amazing guy."

You heart went pitter-patter as you fell in love with El all over again.

Penny smiles and sniffles and then lets out a little giggle. "Yes! A thousand times yes! You guys are the best parents ever!"

Your beloved queen and your beautiful young princess both lean up and begin kissing you on the cheeks and lips. You are still bound so you just move your head doing your best to kiss them back. Your bond with these two wonderful ladies had never been stronger. They lean back from you then give each other a hug across your naked body.

You lay there a moment, giving them some time, then finally say. "Could someone PLEASE get me out of here!"

You all laugh together. The warmth and love of the moment fills the room.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)