Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 19 by grimbous grimbous

What's next?

A Penny for your Cock

Penelope crawls onto the bed next to you. She reaches out tentatively toward your member. You try to twist away from her but she pulls you back again with her other hand. As she lightly takes it in her hand it flares to full hardness.

"Oh Daddy! You're so excited!" She says with a wide smile.

"Your mother is going to be home any minute young lady." You threaten.

"We better hurry then." She slowly brings her face closer and closer to your dick.

"Penelope...Penelope..." She isn't listening. You switch from ordering her to pleading with her. "Please stop this, we can't do this Penny."

You fucked your sister all the time, but your daughter? This was totally different.

She sighs. "But...but you're so ready...and so am I..." She kisses the tip of your raging hard on and giggles as it responds to her touch. She then licks it like one might a candy cane. "Sorry Daddy, I don't really know what I'm doing." With that she takes you in her mouth and begins to suck. Suckle would probably be the better description as she began sucking on it like a nursing calf on its mother's teat, as if she could start drinking out of it. Her head isn't moving, just suckle suckle suckle suckle.

A groan escapes your mouth. "Noooooo....stop sweetie...ohhhhh..." It felt so FUCKING good! Elsie gave amazing head but after 19 years together this was something...different. And different felt good.

A little hum of building arousal comes from Penny. She reaches down and begins playing with her pussy.

Pulling away with a long slurp she smacks her lips. Looking up at you she says breathily. "Oh Daddy." She trembles. "I'm so excited. I'm kinda scared too." She begins kissing up your stomach and across your chest. She licks and nibbles your nipples. "I'm so happy..." She starts kissing your chest again and works up toward your neck.

"Okay sweetie. Let's just settle down okay. Let me go and we'll talk all about it, okay?" You say in a calm supportive tone.

She still had the naughty twinkle in her eye as she looks up at you, but you could see a touch of trepidation as well. "No...I won't get another chance..." She crawls over you then straddles you, her giant boner rubbing across your chest. Precum smears across you as she moves, she was very excited by all of this. "I'll never get another chance like this. I don't want to lose this chance."

You look up at your darling little girl, all grown up now. "Sweetie. You don't want this, okay? You want your first time to be special. You want your first time to be with someone you love. Do you understand?"

By the look in her sky blue eyes you can tell you'd just made a terrible mistake with the previous line of argument. Your words only seemed to solidify her resolve. Penelope had always been a daddy's girl. "I love you more than anyone Daddy, and I always will. This is so special to me."

She leans down and kisses you hard on the lips, her hair smelled of apple blossoms and she tasted of mint. Despite the intoxicating mix of feelings and sensations you were feeling you don't return the kiss. You close your eyes and purse your lips. Your dick was surging for action however, you feel your nob brush against her sweet young snatch. She lets out a little gasp.

You take a deep breath. This was going to happen whether you wanted it or not. It was time to stop trying to swim upstream and just let it happen.

She raises up on her hands and knees over you, her legs straddling your midsection. She looks down at you with a mixture of love, passion, and something like a tender reverent awe. Her long blonde hair cascading down from the right side of her head, lightly brushing your cheek and neck and shoulder. You marvel at what a stunning young woman she had grown into!

Looking up at her you ask. "You've had 'the shot'?" Unlike when you were her age birth control was no big thing anymore. Thanks to 'the shot' women were only fertile if they wanted to be. Oops babies were a thing of the past.

She nods. "Of course."

She reaches down between her legs and takes you in hand, guiding you toward her entrance. Her cock practically quivering from the excitement. She is nervous still, a little scared even, but she was one hundred percent committed. It is clumsy and a bit awkward but she positions you against her hot wet slit and sloooowly sits back onto you. You feel as you enter the tightest little pussy you had ever experienced. You both let out a simultaneous moan. Yours in carnal bliss, hers from pain and discomfort.

You see her face scrunch up and cringe as she takes you to the hilt. "Oww...owww...unghh...it hurts...OHHHH..." The mixture of the overwhelming situation combined with the new biting sensation as you tore through her hymen proves to much for her, her big cock spasms as she prematurely ejaculates. Thankfully it was pointed slightly to the right, the stream of hot jizm coating the pillow beside your head, your shoulder, and in beside your arm pit. Her face is a mask of confused feelings as pain blends with bliss. "OHHHHHH" She cries out in muddled pain laced ecstasy.

You can't help but worry about your little girl. "It's okay, it's okay sweetie, just stop for a minute. It gets better."

She is frozen on top of you as she tries to adjust to the conflicting feelings. She takes a stuttering breath as her dick eventually expends itself and comes to rest. She takes a few long breaths.

"Sorry...it hurts more than I thought...it would." She bites her lip as she continues to try to come to grips with things.

"We can stop." You offer.

"No. No. Just give me a second. I'll be okay Daddy." She looks at her gooey mess and can't help but giggle a bit despite everything. "Oh my...I was kinda excited..."

You smile. "It's okay, you're young, it happens."

She leans forward a bit then sits back again, giving you a test thrust. She was so fucking tight and wet! She grits her teeth then goes again...then again...then again. Each time it was easier. You thought of Elsie as you watched Penny struggling on you. You knew her first time had been with Fiona and that she didn't near this much control of that situation. She didn't like to talk about her first time and you knew it was a point of contention between her and her sister, it must have been awful.

Penelope is starting to develop a rhythm as she rides you. While pleasure isn't exactly the emotion she is expressing it was getting better with every motion. She is studying your face as she repeatedly comes down on you, her love filled eyes recording every detail of the experience. She lets out a sigh of genuine passion, now she was getting into it. Her large breasts sway to her movements.

"Ohhh...Daddy...it feels...ohhhh...you fill me up..." She was trying to describe what couldn't be described. It was obviously different from what she had expected. "Ohhhh...it's really starting...to feel...goood...ohhhhh..."

You grunt a response. It had already been feeling good to you from the word go. As she continued to build in intensity you could feel her young virile member begin to harden on top of you once more. She really began to fuck now, the pace fast and relentless. The sound a steady beat of clapping flesh. Her whines and sounds and breathing all indicating her approaching crescendo.

On a purely tactile physical level this was absolutely off the charts. As she picked up her pace you knew you wouldn't last too much longer. On a spiritual level it was a total revelation. Despite the undeniably arousing wickedness of this taboo act, despite her firm young perfect body, despite her tight incredible pussy, despite having only the same partner for almost twenty years, all you could think about was your Elsie. While the pair of you had gotten together of necessity you now knew beyond all doubt that it was what you truly wanted for the rest of your life.

You snap out of your daydream as Penelope pauses riding you and clamps down on top of you. Her legs squeeze your hips, her arms wrap around your chest, and her already tight pussy clenches. Fuck she was strong! She is growling and whimpering as she climaxes. She trembles and shakes on top of you.

"Ohhhh god...Daddy! Ohhhhhh." She says, muffled into your chest.

You were so very close yourself so you start to thrust your hips up into her to finish the job. As you do so she wails in passion. A few more quick pistoning thrusts and you let out a long groan as you flood her formerly virgin cunt with your sticky load.

"Oh my god...I feel it...I feel it..." She gasps as your throbbing manhood pumps repeatedly inside of her. "Oh god I feel you."

She stays clinging to you, on top of you, then her muscles go slack. She repeats into your chest between kisses. "Daddy, oh Daddy, ohhh." You let out a long contented sigh as your orgasm fades. You feel drained, utterly spent from the intense experience.

It is only then you notice the familiar figure standing in the doorway watching you.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)