Penny's Other Side

Penny hesitates, in the snap of a finger her whole demeanor changes. "You want me to...to ride you? Ohh boy, um...I just...I only had Daddy's little guy. Yours...it's too big Mama." You could see trepidation in her eyes as she scans up and down Elsie's big fleshy club. "You let me do you, I guess it's only fair, but...um..." She hesitates. "But...you did seem to like mine so much better...I really should try it...I guess..."

Elsie just smiles. "Just lube us up real good and go slow, you'll be okay my girl. I was the oddball liking Jesse's...um...normal sized cock, most of your family like nice big ones. I bet you will like a big one too. Listen, if you don't like it we'll stop, okay?" As Penny reluctantly begins lubing her mother's knob and her own tight slit Elsie looks over at you. "Thank you for being so understanding baby. You're just the best Jesse. This won't change anything between us, I still love you so very much."

She might still love you, but things had most definitely changed already.

As Penelope straddles then slowly lowers herself onto her mother you can see her face is a mask of confusion and worry and...and mental anguish. You actually saw tears form in the corners of her eyes. She looks over at you, her peircing blue eyes scared...lost. Your little girl was terrified about something.

She suddenly cries out. "NO!"

"Oh my goodness. Baby girl, what's wrong?" You ask as you quickly kneel up beside her, instantly forgetting about all that had just happened. Your fatherly instincts were kicking in. Your girl needed you!

She is suddenly scared to speak. Her 'role' as the dominant bull had completely washed away to be replaced by the scared innocent recent virgin that she was, the transformation was incredible! Her cocky confidence gone. "Um...I'm sorry...I'm sorry Mama...I..." She mumbles and stumbles over her words. "I don't like...no I can't..."

Elsie is looking up with as much concern as you had. "Woah woah, it's okay Penny, it's okay. Calm down. What's wrong?"

With a pained look Penelope shudders and says. "I'm being selfish...I'm sorry. I'm so selfish. I'm sorry Mama."

It was obvious the sex was over for now, Penny was too rattled. You pull your daughter off of Elsie and take her in your arms, she snuggles tight into your chest. Elsie sits up and hugs her from the other side...you got the distinct impression Penny didn't welcome that attention right now. She whimpers into your chest. "I...just want Daddy...I just want my Daddy in that way. I don't want you like that Mama." She adds even more quietly. "My pussy is only for my Daddy."

El hadn't caught that last bit. You and Elsie look to each other with concern. El strokes her daughter. "Shhhh. It's okay. As I said, you don't have to do anything you don't want to. It's okay Penny." El shakes her head. "This was too much too soon. I'm the one who should be sorry Penny, don't be upset...okay?"

Penny turns to her mother. "Um...I really liked Daddy's. I don't want any bigger...do you understand Mama?" Despite her words you had a sneaking suspicion size was only partially to do with her ****.

Elsie nods. "I understand more than you know." She smiles. "I remember what it was like at your age...I only had eyes for your father. He was perfect in every way." The pair of you smile warmly at one another. Things may be changing between you sexually but the love you had was rock solid.

"He IS perfect in every way." Penny corrects her in an impudent hushed voice.

You see El flinch a bit at the rebuttal. "Okay sweetie, okay." El whispers.

You both stroke and comfort your daughter as she continues to hold you tight. At no point does Penny return Elsie's affections, she only held onto you in her iron embrace.

El finally says. "We should get cleaned up and hit the sack." She pulls away from the group hug and gets up on unsteady legs. You could see the sheen and streaking globs of leaking jizz all down her inner thighs. "I'll go get the shower started." She looks at the pair of you one last time with loving eyes before making her way to the washroom.

The instant she has left the room Penelope grabs your head in her hands and plants a deep hard passionate kiss onto you. Your eyes go wide and you go to push her away but she holds firm...you knew your daughter was strong but it was in that moment you come to realize that she is even stronger than you. You push against her compact muscular frame and cannot budge her.

She pulls back, a loud smack sound as your lips part. "Daddy...those mean things I said. Those are just play okay Daddy. I was playing. You need to understand that Daddy! You know that right Daddy? You like that stuff right Daddy?" You knew she was referring the the cuckold scene that had just played out in front of you.

There was a desperation in her voice. You want to be stern and fatherly but something about that begging look in her eyes makes you tell the truth. "I...yeah, I liked it. It was...arousing." You try to settle her. "I know it was just a bit of role-playing. You know that too right? It's healthy to explore our sexuality, we all have our fetishes and kinks." You smile. "It's all good baby girl. It's just bedroom sports."

She lets out a happy sigh. "Oh good! I'm glad you understand. I liked it too. I had so much fun with you tonight Daddy. Thank you so much." She is just staring up at you with a wide eyed look of unfiltered adoration. "I'm going to stay so nice and tight for you, don't worry. I'd do anything for you Daddy."

The way she was looking at you just now...you shake your head. Nah! "Okay Penny, just take it easy okay? Let's go clean up." By this point you could hear the water running.

The pair of you get up and make your way into the bathroom. You see Elsie's fine shapely ass bent over the tub checking the temperature of the water coming from the faucet, her well fucked pussy a messy dribbling creampie. Penny suddenly hauls off and gives her mother an open hand slap to the butt. SMACK!

"Hey slut." She says with a worrisome edge to her voice.

El straightens up suddenly, grabbing her ass. "OHHH!" She lets out a giggle, obviously not entirely offended by the remark. "Oh my!" She giggles some more. "Okay, let's leave that talk for bedroom time."

Penny smiles. "Sure Mama, whatever you say."

The three of you shower together and clean each other's love spackled bodies. You dry off and head back to the room. A quick change of bedding later and you are ready for bed. Penelope is extremely upset when she finds out she is expected to head back to her room.

"I...I don't want to be alone right now!" She protests.

You and El look at each other with sympathetic eyes. Being alone after sex was a pretty hollow feeling. But the pair of you had a lot to talk about, privately. Reluctantly you agree to let her stay...this time only!

Penny is pleased. With your daughter cuddled up to your right and Elsie to your left the group of you all drift off to sleep. The dreams you have that night are so raunchy and so erotic they make any previous ones utterly pale in comparison.