Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 15 by Cheesers123 Cheesers123

Do you leave?

Yes

You turn your back on Miranda and Tom before following the others out the door. You **** yourself to not look back and instead focus on moving forward and ignoring the pair behind you. As you climb the stairs behind Sarah you can't help but catch a glimpse up her short skirt. You avert your gaze quickly but not before taking in the sight of her perfectly toned asscheeks hanging out of her too small pink panties.

When your procession of four reaches the landing you part ways, Nicole and Matt going off to Sarahs bedroom, quietly and clumsily flirting, whilst you and Sarah stop to go to the bathroom. Sarah goes in first whilst you pretend to wait outside, at least until Nicole and Matt are out of sight. Once they are you knock on the door and Sarah immediately opens it and pulls you inside by your shirt.

Once you're inside Sarah slams the door shut behind you and locks it, leaving you trapped with the door pressed against your back and Sarah pressed against your front. Her bare breasts push against you and her hot breath tickles your neck. You know what she wants so you cut her off before she can speak.

"I thought we'd settled this before" you say curtly, glaring down into her blue eyes. She's nonplussed by this as she replies "Oh I know, I just thought you might have reconsidered. I mean, all I want is to make you happy." She pouts up at you cutely and bats her eyelashes.

"I know Sarah and I'm grateful but-" as you try to reply she cuts you off.

"But now I think I know what would make you happiest." Her pout is replaced with an evil smirk as you look down at her quizzically. "And it's not me and you fucking, even though I'd give you the best fuck you'll ever have in your life. What would make you really happy, happier than you'd ever want to admit to yourself, isn't you fucking me, it's Tom fucking Miranda."

You're so stunned by what she just said that you can't even speak for a moment. Eventually you manage to stutter out "What- what the fuck are you talking about?"

"Oh don't be coy" She giggles " A guys dick is like a divining rod for what turns them on, and I've been sat in your lap all night, feeling it throb and pulse and push against me, and I could tell that what got you hardest, what made your cock press against me with the most lust was watching Tom turn Miranda into a moaning quivering mess in his lap."

"You're being ridiculous! I was already hard from having you rub yourself off on me and I was just enjoying seeing Miranda topless!" You snap at her, anger flaring inside you at her words, but she doesn't back down, instead she traces one hand down your stomach to your crotch as she speaks. "So if I were to say something like," She pauses to grab your dick through your jeans "Miranda is probably gagging on Toms fat dick right now, that wouldn't effect you at all?"

You don't say anything but it doesn't matter, your penis betrays you as it blatantly throbs in Sarahs soft hand eliciting a smug smile from her. "I knew that would turn you on" she says as her fingers gently caress your hard cock. "So now I have a new deal."

"Since I've got you by the balls," she jokes whilst fondling them through your pants "I want to give you a proposition. if you fuck me like you mean it, right here and right now, you might convince me that I'm wrong about your naughty little fetish and I might forget all about it. Or you can walk out that door, and I promise I will do everything in my power to make your precious Miranda into Toms cocksleeve."

Her words make you so infuriated but you dick still in her hands proves that that's not all you're feeling. Even as you glare furiously at her, trying to find words to argue she continues to tease you.

"It might not even matter what you choose, we've been gone quite a while and I'm sure Toms already shown her his big dick. I bet once he got that out she was completely entranced by it. She's probably on her knees right now, licking his heavy balls or sucking on his swollen dickhead, desperately trying to fit it into her tight throat. Or maybe they're already on to the main course, with Miranda on her back trying not to scream as Tom deflowers her cute little pussy with his rock hard rod."

Everything Sarah is saying makes you angrier and, to your shame, hornier. When she says "Do you think he'll fill her pussy with his creampie or cover her pretty face in cum first?" It all becomes too much and you suddenly act.

What do you do?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)