More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 23 by jhonny182 jhonny182

What did John do?

Tried to start (nice guy's path)

Upon hearing his request, knew that there was no turning back. But my dick was too flabby to penetrate my friend's virgin ass. I positioned the head of the dick on the Nicole anus door and tried to **** it inside. In vain. I was too nervous about the situation and couldn't concentrate on making the stick go up. If Lucas could speak, he would probably make fun and say something like: "I can't believe this, Mr. Soft Dick!"

I heard a spitting sound beside me. Miranda had spit in the hand, and was towards my dick. Miranda took it in his hand and started making light movements back and forth. I couldn't believe what was going on. Miranda was masturbating me. I looked at her and she looked me in the eye. My cock stiffened quickly. She lowered her head towards my dick and gave another spit, looked me in the eye again and said:

"You heard her ... get this over with." and guided my cock to Nicole 's virgin hole.

So hard it was and so wet that Miranda it had left it, my dick slid into that ass halfway. Nicole gave a cry of pain. I could feel every crease of Nicole 's virgin ass. His sphincter contracted hard every time I tried to penetrate further. I felt my cock throbbing with pleasure inside, pressed against the hot, moist walls of Nicole 's ass. I had only taken two thrusts when I came to and realized that Nicole was crying in pain. What was I doing with my friend?

Please log in to view the image

In this clash of conscience I ended up making a decision. I took one, two and on the third stroke I gave a cry of pleasure and pretended that I had reached the climax. Turning my face to the others, I said:

"It has always been a shame for me and now I will share it with you. I suffer from premature ejaculation when I am fucking a girl who is too much for me, it would probably be like that for any of you."

Telling that lie was not in the plans, as it could end my reputation not only with the girls here, but also with the girls from college. Miranda I wouldn't want someone like that as a boyfriend, for sure. But at the same time, I thought it was the right thing to do with my friend. I couldn't fill her ass with cum while she cried with sadness.

The atmosphere in the room was not good at all. Sarah decided to intervene once again:

"Well ... what do you think of us taking a break to clean up and come back with everything for a great ending?"

"Excuse me." I whispered in Nicole 's ear and went to the bathroom. Before entering I saw the corner of the eye Miranda leading Nicole, still in tears to the other bathroom. And Lucas had a look of satisfaction that I have never seen before.

The game continues

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)