Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 17 by yesterdayspapers yesterdayspapers

Who takes the initiative?

Tom

"Right, my turn!" insists Tom. A shiver of dread passes over you, mixed with anticipation - is he going to humiliate you further?

"John, you're going to fuck Nicole. Hard." A grin passes over Tom's face, and you feel the hate rise in you. "Wha...aat? No, please!" begs Nicole. It is clear from the expression on her face that this is a lot more than she bargained for when starting this game.

"Come on, Tom, you know how they are together - that's a bit harsh," reasons Sarah. You are surprised at the support coming from that particular corner, but the gag prevents you from expressing your gratitude.

"Ok, fine - all she has to do is drop her panties and get on all fours in front of him," Tom suggests, half-charitably. "It'll be more interesting to leave it up to him, anyway..."

Nicole is still clearly not happy with the proposal, but nervously removes her panties exposing a neatly trimmed blonde landing strip. You notice the short hairs are matted with her juices. "Ok, here goes..." she mutters to herself, under her breath. She positions herself on all fours in front of you, shaking with nerves. You can see her tight, pink virgin slit, glistening with moisture.

"Closer than that!" Tom roars, and Nicole shuffles towards you. Your cock hardens further at the prospect, and the tip grazes Nicole's pussy. She shudders and looks back at you, a look of fear on her face. Clearly, getting eaten out by you was one thing but the prospect on penetration has genuinely spooked her. Suddenly, the lust you felt earlier is gone - you see your childhood friend, afraid and frightened, her maiden pussy exposed. She looks at you helplessly and shakes her head, a tear running down her cheek, further smudging her makeup. Whispering quietly, she manages to utter "Please...don't...I'm saving myself..."

Overcome with sympathy, you try and pull back but are prevented by the restraints. Your cock is also, frustratingly, still rock hard and twitching up and down, brushing against Nicole's still wet pussy lips. You try and mouth something soothing, but the gag blocks you.

What do you do?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)