More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 26 by electricstar electricstar

Whose name does she pull out? Will Tom interfere?

Tom and Yes

Nicole looks down at the name she has drawn and said nothing. After a few seconds, her arms start shaking. Her back and legs stood straight, her head tilts and locks eyes with you. Her smile is fierce, in her eyes burns a flame. It promises vengeance. Oh no, you know whose name she has drawn. And judging by him getting up, he knows too. You suddenly remember Nicole has a terrible poker face. She turns around, words at the ready, body vibrating with the desire to enact terrible vengeance.

It was not to be.

"Tom..." she starts before trailing off. No doubt her voice is much softer than she wanted it to be, surprised by Tom's close proximity to her. He holds up a page for her to read out. Unwillingly, he locks his eyes with you, a wicked grin across his face. You can only return one of surprise and horror. You heard her ****, you break off your staring competition and redirect your gaze to her. Letting out a soft wail, she pauses before reading out "Please Tom. Make me cum again and again with your rock hard body. Nothing is off limits". She hisses out the last sentence. She turns to Tom, "Please don't" she pleads but he is unmoved. She then turns around to you, looking you in the eye, silently asking you to get her out of this. Before you can say anything, she breaks it off and looks down onto the floor.

Looking right behind, Tom locks gazes with you once more.
His grin is wider, you can almost smell the intent off him. The hungry look in his amber eyes is intimidating. You know that once again, this is a situation where your will and words will influence Nicole's mind. If you say something now, this game will end and Nicole will keep her virginity. But at the same time, Tom's expression speaks to you. In your now over-active imagination his expression says:

"You hate me but I will take her. Again and again and again"
"Your best friend will cum on my giant dick many many times and you will watch"
"And she will see what kind of a man you really are. She is getting filled and all you can do watch and whack off"
"She will see you wrap your hand around your cock, unable to truly pleasure her as a man. You are impotent and she knows that real sexual pleasure will never come from you"

And so on. Some of it, you know is absolute bullshit but it still makes you hard. Breaking it off, you looks down at her. You can see dried cum all over her head, sticking to her hair and across her face, her while pale skin still flushed her earlier stimulation, goosebumps all over her shoulders and upper arms. She looks afraid. You think she is not ready to lose it all just yet but Tom won't care.

She is waiting for you to say something. Anything. To make her feel warm, to reassure her that everything is going be alright and that you will protect her from all harm. Dimly you remember a time where she would be the one protecting you. You were a small boy. A little more in touch with his feelings, easily intimidated by all the big boys. But she was headstrong, fierce and completely unafraid. Boys twice her size would think twice about bothering you when she was around. Course, that all changed after middle school, she grew more girly interests and you grew tall with muscle. But often times, you fell into the same old roles, she would still look after you. Too timid to go after girls, she had to shove Miranda down your throat after feeding you several bottles of beer for you to man up. Now was a chance to do so, to protect something precious to her!

But you won't, a dark whisper sneaks into your thoughts, making your dick hard. She is expecting you to protect her from the Big Bad Wolf. The Woodsman to Little Red Riding Hood. But you're not a brave woodsman, you're not even much of a man, you're a horrible pervert who enjoys watching precious things get taken from you. Little Red is your friend but you're going to offer her to the Big Bad Wolf to satisfy your carnal cravings. And at the end, she may not hate you but she will like him...

And with that thought, all your protests died in your throat.

Nicole finally looks up at you, locking eyes. You stare at one another, her eyes wide with fear and wet with tears. You know her well. You can read her expressions. You can read her thoughts. She wonders why are you not saying something. Do you want tTom to fuck her?

Of course, you couldn't answer that and despite her knowing you for so long, she couldn't have known this side of you. A side brought into life right after meeting Tom with his constant dirty talk about Miranda and Nicole. A fantasy you have always squashed until tonight. A fantasy brought fully to life when you watched Miranda cumming loudly on Tom's dick. She had looked into your eyes as you give her your heartfelt but pathetic request. After which, you watched her face warp in pleasure, her loud moan screaming "Yes!" ringing in your ears.

You are both startled by Tom's hand gently being laid on Nicole's right shoulder. She turns towards him with a nervous expression on her face, he offers a reassuring smile is return and offers her a page from his notepad. She freezes at this when she sees the page but accepts it after offering him a glare. You watch her freeze as she reads the page then she looks up at Tom then rereads the page again. She looks to be in disbelief. You look over the shoulder at the message, it reads "You don't have to do this if you don't want to".

What?

You look at him is incredulously before switching your sight for Nicole's reaction. She looks stunned. She glares at him but it noticeable softens as she sees Tom's patient expression. Her expression hardening, she steels herself. She turns around rapidly in your direction and pushes the notebook page into your chest. You quickly grab the page with your hands and look at her in confusion. But she is glaring at you. Stunned, you say nothing. Satisfied, she turns back to face Tom is gesturing with his left arm to his seat. She offers him a smile and walks towards it.

You look at Tom, confused. What did he just do? Why is he being so gentle? It's not like him. But as he turns to you, there is an evil smile spread across his face. Your stomach sinks at this. That was his game, to turn your oldest friend against you so that she would willingly offer herself right in front of you. To ride on his cock into oblivion. And because of his proximity, nobody else could see his smile. Which means the others likely bought his good will act and you're someone who wouldn't step in to protect his friend.

You look around, Matt looks concerned but offers a reassuring smile. No doubt, he thinks you didn't act because you want to keep playing the game. Miranda looks like she fell for it. She refuses to look in your direction. Sarah on the other has a confused expression on her. She only notices you looking when she turns her face back to the centre, offering a smile at you. It might be that Sarah doesn't buy his act, seeing as she knows him best out of all of you. But she offers nothing and I offer just as much in return.

You sit back down and hear Matt slurring "Its fine. She a big girl. She will not need us to protect her". You offer him a smile and nod at his words. He seems satisfied that you got his message, he turns back to the front. Internally, you argue "But you don't know her like I do". It is some way complete bullshit, he has known the both of you since middle school, just over half the time you knew each other but long enough to know someone well. But 15 years is a long time and it apparently comes with extra baggage.

You look up ahead, he is offering her a cloth towel he grabbed somewhere and is helping her wipe away his dried cum of her face and a bit our of her hair. He offers her a bottle of beer. She hold out her hand make a stop sign and asks mildly "Are you trying to get me drunk?", he writes out something in reply. She reads it and laughs, she then grabs the beer and take a swig before swishing it around in her mouth and for few seconds and swallowing. She does this two more times and at the end, she puts the bottle down and opens her mouth wide and showing her tongue, like at she were at the dentist.

He laughs wordlessly and stands to wrap her arms around her. She leans in and presses her chest against his, rocking side to side. He catches her lips in a searing kiss, one that she returns. Her arms are now wrapped over his neck but his own arms sliding downwards, his left fondling her breasts and flicking her nipples. His right cups one of her ass checks, provoking an audible gasp which soon turns into moans as he reaches underneath to touch her pussy. He turns her around, making her face the rest of us, she tries to cover her face but her traps against her sides with his upper arms and reaches down to fondle her breasts and her pussy once more. Her arms trapped, she lowers her head and looks to the ground with her eyes closed. Removing his left arm from her tits, he tilts her head upwards until she is facing straight ahead and he whispers something in her ear. Her eye lids slammed open, her eyes looking in direction. You freeze, hand moving towards your cock, as she locks eyes with yours. You stare at each other, unable to look away as her breathe slowly got deeper as Tom gets her closer and closer to the edge. She breaks it off first as a succession of loud moans escape her lips, Tom's fingers moving faster, sawing in and out, making soft squelching noises. She finally cums with a long moan. She is breathing heavily now, her cheeks red with embarrassment and her eyes closed. Unwilling to look anyone in the face.

After a few seconds, she attempts to move away but Tom arms prevent her from moving out of his grasp. He leans back, one arms still around Nicole, to grab a notebook page for her to read. She reads aloud "Please Tom. Make me cum again and again with your rock hard body. Nothing is off limits". It's the same notebook page from before! He probably means to use again and again until he is satisfied. Looks like Nicole understands that too, as she has stopped protesting.

Smiling, Tom lifts her up by the armpits and lays her down onto the floor on her back. From her angle, tilting her head up, she can see the rest you upside down. Despite her initial anger, you can see her eyes searching for yours. She would feel reassured, just to see you. The eyes are wide with fear, you can tell how nervous she actually is now despite her earlier enthusiasm at Tom touching her body.

But her body tells you so much more, her breaths sweet with arousal, the flushed cheeks, her wide open mouth, her hard nipples...

She is eager. She can't wait for Tom to take her roughly. To wrap her legs around his waist, to feel stretched out, to see nothing but stars for minutes at a time, to scream his name....

To be made into a woman...

As Tom rests his hands around her waist, she breaks it off first to look at him. He offers her a reassuring smile. She visibly relaxes and gives him a sweet one in return before leaning and closing her eyes. Tom looks, his eyes searching for yours. You match his gaze, trying keep your expression neutral but judging by his indulgent smile, he doesn't buy it for a second. He knows you're just as eager as Nicole is to be made into a woman. If not more so.

He starts stroking his cock. To the others,he's just keeping himself at full mast but you know the truth. He's taunting you. He wants to see whack off. He wants to see you whack off to the sight of your best friend getting fucked for the first time. To the sight of her face warped with pleasure. To the sound of her moaning another man's name. To the knowledge that you sacrificed her to satisfy yourself. To your shame and horror, as you look back at him, you feel your right hand obeying. Without breaking his gaze, you can feel your fingers moving up and down your cock. You can see him suppress a laugh.

“Wait!” Nicole shouted, shocking both you and Tom. Her eye lids slammed open and her eyes wide with worry, seeking your own. But before you can meet her yes, she turns back to Tom and apologizes “Sorry, just got a bit nervous”. Tom nods back at her but a calculating expression on his face. His eyes darts to the right to look at your before darting back to her face. Taking out his notebook, he starts writing out something which he then passes to Tom to read aloud. Her eyes widen with shock, but she looks eager, aroused at whatever he has written on that paper.

John, I'm scared. Could you please hold my hand?”

Despite your shock at his request, you're not really that surprised at this point. Since the day you met, neither of you have ever got along. The whole night now, he has made every effort to humiliate you. To make you feel less of a man. To take everything you love. And pervert them. Steal them. Make them his.

But Nicole, on the other hand....

Does she really want you to do this? To reassure that it's going to be alright. That it's ok to take pleasure from Tom's body? To feel the bite of her fingernails as he takes her. To look into her eyes as she screams in his name?

Dimly, you notice the other 3 recoil from this request and turns to face you. Matt starts to say something but you ignore him. You feel as if your mind and your body are of two different consciousnesses. You look through your eyes, the only thing you hear is the thumping of your heart, your body moving outside of your control. You scream internally to refuse her request but your body refuses to listen and no sounds escape your lips. By the time wrestle back control, your body is already kneeling down above her, facing Tom, Nicolelying on the floor between you. Your hands wrapped around her thin wrists, her fingers fitting snugly in your palms. You look at her, from your perspective, she is upside down. She looks happy to see you.

Suddenly Nicole's fingernails are biting into you. She lets out a gasp which turns into a low moan. You tilt you head to see Tom's cock prodding her entrance. Her breaths have turned rapid, her cute cheeks flushed with arousal. Her body, previously relaxed with your hands wrapped out each others, is now in eager anticipation for her first cock. Eyes closed, she lets out a long moan as Tom's monster starts sliding slowly into her.

With her no longer paying much attention to you, you look up to see Tom's wide victorious smile and bright amber eyes looking into yours. You can't blame him for it. In less than half an hour, he has fucked two of your friends, two of the few women he knows in high school and college to continuously reject his advances. Best of all, he did them in front of you, because as much as you tell everyone how much you don't like him, he doesn't much like you in return. And it was easy to see how much you dote on Miranda and Nicole. **** and vindication in two moaning, wriggling packages.

And worst of all, you're getting off on it! And he knows that. He knows your secret shame. The one he unknowingly planted inside of you years ago in high school. The one he made bloom as he made Miranda cum loudly in front of you. The one thing your best friends don't know about you. And he knows that if he plays his cards right, you help him humiliate yourself. With your cooperation, he will make Miranda,a girl you have been pining for since high school and Nicole, your best friend, your first crush, worship his monster cock. And you will whack off to the sight of it. You will whack off as he shows you how much he made them into his sluts. You will whack off as they tell you how much of a 'man' you really are. You will whack off as you know that you could prevented all of it this night.

Ashamedly, you turned away from his gaze only find yourself drawn to the sight of his other head. Although you know, your own is quite large and that size really doesn't matter, the sight of of a cock, one that is bigger than yours, pushing into your best friend's tight, now non-virgin pussy is emasculating. It is the cock of a real man. A man who is bold. A man who is brave. A man unafraid of women. A man who takes what he wants without overly worrying about the consequences. A man not like you. You're just a boy. Still the small timid boy who needs a girl to protect him. And now Tom is showing Nicole that with every inch of thick meat he is slowly stuffing into her while you are holding her hand. And with those thoughts going through your head, you watch as it slowly hilts itself in Nicole. Tom rests and doesn't move for a few seconds, allowing Nicole time to get used to him. You can feel her fingers loosening, her nails no longer biting your palm, you tear you gaze away from his cock to look at her face. Her blue eyes peeking out between her eyelids, a giddy expression on her face.

“Hey” she mumbles
“Hey. How are you?”
“I feel so full...”

She trails off at the end. You offer no reply in turn. Your hard cock on the other hand jerks at this. You are glad, with how you two are positioned that she is unable to see how hard your cock is. Not to say that she doesn't know you are hard, but you don't want to tell her why. You are less glad both are hands are occupied, as you would be happy to masturbate to the sight in front of you.

In the back of your mind, you try to remember when it was that you first realised you had a crush on her but you can't. Perhaps you always have. However you do remember in high school, that you have fantasized on several occasions what is the exact expression on her face when she gets filled in by her first cock. Well now know. Pity its not your cock that's filling her.

Suddenly she gasps out and her fingernails bite down once more. Looking up, you can see Tom starting to fucking in earnest, slowly picking up speed. Looking directly down, you can see Nicole's eyes are shut and her mouth letting loose low moans, as soft squelching noises drifted from her pussy. Before long, as the squelching noises come more and more rapidly, her moans start getting longer and louder, building into a crescendo. Finally she lets loose a small but long shriek that builds in pitch before her voice breaks close to the aspect. She just came but you know Tom is not done, you look up to see him continuing through her orgasm, building her towards another shriek. You watch him go in fascination and he continues to fuck her through her second orgasm and into her third. As Nicole lets off her fifth orgasm of the night (her 4th in the last 3 minutes, 4 directly given by Tom, 1 indirectly), he finally cums, emptying him balls with loud wet sounds into her pussy. As Nicole comes down from her orgasm high and he Tom rests, you are both glad and regretful that this is now over.

But as Tom pulls out, you can see he is still hard. He picks up Nicole but gripping her waist between his hands and flips her over, propping her up so that she is standing, legs wide, her arse presenting herself to him, her arms around your shoulders and her head leaning against yours. You assisted them by moving to sit crossed-legged, giving Nicole a more stable platform to lean against. He hands her a notebook page to read aloud.

Ah this old chestnut. No doubt a list of humiliating and emasculating lines for her to read into your face.

Arms around your shoulders, the paper behind by head, she takes the time to read it in silence. Looking behind her, you can see Tom grinning at you, stroking himself again. Feeling Nicole shift, you look up to see her looking over her shoulder at but you cannot see her face but you can see Tom's. His expression is blank but his eyes glittering with amusement, he shakes his head in disagreement and positions himself behind her, gripping her waist between his hands. You hear her gulp audibly and she leans down so that she is face to face with you, unintentionally pushing her ass higher.

John, I....”she starts in a low whisper but she is **** to moan low and long. You look over her should Tom is slowly fitting himself in her tiny arse. You realize dimly that there is now no inch of Nicole's body he has not explored, no hole he has not filled with his cock. As he slowly slides in, Nicole moans shift to include more and more pleasure. Finally hilting himself, he rests, allowing her to get used to having his girth in her asshole.

"John, I...." she starts again before a loud slap rips a shriek from her. Looking behind her, you can see Tom is readying another slap. He is spanking her ass around his cock! You briefly worry about Nicole's but her pants, heavy with arousal, in your ears tell you she's going to be fine.

"John, I like you" she blurts quickly before another interruption can occur.

Seeing you blink and stare in surprise, she continues "I mean I really like you, I..." she stops to let out a moan. Looking behind her, you can see Tom starting to fuck her. Rocking back and forth and hissing her next words through her teeth,

"Ever since middle school, I had this crush on you and aaaahhhhhh", another shriek leaving her lips and you hear another spank. Her breathing starting to get heavier now.

"But you are such a dumbass! You never notice! and I...I.....IIIIIIIIIIIIIIII", her last word let out as a long moan. Judging by her body shaking, Tom has ripped another orgasm from her. He doesn't even look tired, he continue to saw in and out, pushing her another orgasm.

"And all you talked about is other girls. I never came into the equation! I was just never a woman to you! And thaaaaaa". Another loud spank.

"And that stupid girl, Miranda! How long have you known her? She doesn't even looooooo" Another spank. And another. And another. Looking over, you can see Tom, spanking her again and again. Turning her pale ass red. She hisses out a groan in your ear. Her arms are shaking. Another orgasm.

"She doesn't look at you like I do John. Please go out with me". With that she hides her face in by shoulder. Letting out moans and groans in your ear as Tom continues to fuck her in the ass. There's a sudden sharp pain on your shoulder! Nicole is biting you! Before you can shake her off, you notice her body shaking again. Another orgasm.

If that, it seems Tom is done. He removes himself from Nicole's ass and allows her to drop to the floor. Exhausted and still shaking from her last orgasm, she pulls herself up to sit face to face in your lap. Unfocused, she still tries to lock gazes with you. Stunned at her confession, you just stare back at her. So neither of you were paying any attention when Tom walks up and startles you both by presenting his cock. Stunned, you stare at it. You have never been this close to a cock before. It's unbelievably still hard and heavy with the smell of sweat, pussy and ass. Covered in veins, with a large mushroom-like end. Tearing you gaze away, you look at Nicole's face. Only looking mildly surprised, she leans in to clean in. Grabbing it by the base, she first starts gives the underside a long lick. Before she can continue on, Tom places his hand on top of her head and guides her to deep throat it. Controlling her movements, Tom makes her **** on his cock less than 2 inches from your face. From this angle, you can see the bulges her throat makes as his cock pushes its way downwards. After several long seconds, he grips and handful her hair and shoves her face onto his cock much more rapidly, making loud squelching noises with her mouth.

And finally he stops. Letting out a grunt, he shoots off once in her mouth before pulling her head off and shooting several across her hair and into her hair, grunting with each stream he shoots off. Due to your proximity, catching several drops on you is unavoidable. Still, he didn't aim at your face, so that was a bit of a blessing. Asides from flinching, you find yourself completely uncaring that that several drops of Tom's semen landed on your face. With your dick hard, you convince yourself that it was appropriate given the events of the last few minutes. Turning back to you, her face covered in cum, an empty happy expression across her face. Your heart thumps. She looks amazing. And the smell is horrible, heavy and salty. She stares at you for a second, before slumping over onto your chest. You let her rest in your arms, not minding that she is spreading cum across your shirt. There's a poke in your side. Tom is poking you with his feet, you look up.

His dick is huge. This is a fact you knew at start of the night, but there's nothing like being this close to it. Due to his close proximity and your body position, trying to support Nicole, his intimidatingly large cock fills up half your vision. If you blow out, you can tickle his balls. You look straight pass his still hard cock, up his well muscled stomach and chest until you reach his head and look his eyes,. He offers you a strangely happy grin, amber eyes shining and winks at you before walking away.

Looking back at Nicole, you know what you have just heard is the truth. Although it's likely she was given similar lines to repeat. You can tell how sincere she was. Especially trying so hard to say them to you as orgasms are ripped out of her. You don't know what must be going through her mind through all that. Confessing to her crush while the asshole her crush hates is giving her multiple orgasms. You let out a sigh.

You look around. Tom is sitting on his chair. Miranda and Sarah doesn't appear to have moved. Matt looks completely out of it. How much has he been drinking?

Looking at him, you wonder how much do everyone know about her feelings? Besides Tom of course. He seems to be very observational. She whispered her whole feelings there to you so you know they didn't overheard her. You know you have a bit of a crush on her but how much can you return her feelings? You still feel strongly about Miranda despite what happened earlier tonight. Do you even want to pursue one with her? Does she still want to after Tom seduced her and turned her against you?

You look back at Nicole. She looks out of it, 7 orgasms in less than 10 minutes. Seems ridiculous if you had not just seen it been done. It's Tom's turn now. You could let him pull out a name but it'll only count with either you, Miranda or Sarah. Nicole and Matt will need a break. Maybe you should just call for one in general?

Maybe take the time to talk to Nicole?

Do you call for a break? Or do you let Tom pull a name?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)