Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 15 by cphi cphi

What's next?

The race...

Sarah lays out some ground rules. "Remember girls, only hands and voices. You can spit on the cock, but don't put it in your mouth. And boys, no touching. Hands behind your backs." Matt and Tom both oblige, and each has a shitty grin.
"Don't worry, Miranda. When I cum first for you, it's only because I want you to win." Tom chuckled."Though with John in the game, I can't make any promises."
"Tom, shut up." Sarah held up her hand. "On 3. 1.... 2.......3!"
Each girl grabs the cock in front of her, and the race begins. Nicole spits a big load of saliva onto your cock and starts to work it with both hands. Her hands are small, so she can work your rapidly hardening shaft easily with both.
"Did you like... watching me cum....?" Nicole's voice quavers a little: she's attempting dirty talk, but you think she's finding it a little more difficult than anticipated. "Tell the truth..."
You nod. It was the truth: you had enjoyed it, despite the awkwardness.
"W-was it hot... watching me squirm?" she's gaining a little more confidence now, and your cock reaches full attention. Her fingers work the shaft and her thumb rubs the underside of your glans, and then she begins to stroke up and down in a slow and steady rhythm.
"What were you trying to pull, Matt? How could you choose Miranda over me to take into the closet? " You hear Sarah's voice from your left, and you can see her working expertly on Matt's cock.
"Are you jealous?" Matt says breathily: Sarah is definitely having an effect on him, and he can't hide the fact that he's incredibly turned on at having his cock stroked by his crush. _Maybe that was his plan, to get her interested by denying her. Playing 'hard to get.' It's an interesting strategy, you have to admit.
"Maybe... but I'll make you pay for it.. just you wait..."
"...just as good as I expected, baby." Tom's voice also cuts through, from your right. "It's good to get acquainted, so you'll know your way around it for later..."
"shut up..." Miranda's voice seems a little hollow, and she seems almost hypnotized by his dick in her hands.
"Hey...don't look around, look at me..." Nicole grips your cock under the head, and you look down. "Look at the girl stroking your cock, baby." She smiles. She's sounding more comfortable, and more confident. "Tell me something... all those sleepovers and campouts... did you ever fantasize about this?"
Only once! It was just a wet dream! You had cleaned yourself before she had woken up; You had been sharing a twin bed after a concert. You feel compelled to nod.
"That's naughty..." Nicole makes a face, and begins to stroke harder. "I never knew you were a naughty boy, John. My image of you is ruined..." her mocking voice seems calculated to drive you wild.
"Oh, you like when I play with your balls, do you?" Sarah's voice again. Matt is leaning back now, face scrunched in pleasure and effort. He's close, and he's trying to hold it.
"You're going to cum for me, Tom." Miranda is working a corkscrew grip on Tom's cock. "It's the closest you'll ever get to fucking me, so you better enjoy shooting a load. I'll even let you cum on my face." Tom is starting to squirm.
"The night is young, baby." Tom squeezes his eyes shut. "fuck...."
Nicole starts working faster. "Maybe after you 'crown' me the sexiest girl here... we can see what other things we can have fun doing..." She is doing an admirable job at completely changing character from the girl you thought you knew. Was she secretly always like this, just waiting to let it out? Or maybe she's just trying to win. You can feel the cum churning in your balls at the thought of exploring...

Which girl wins?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)