Nicoles slip

You almost breathe a sigh of relief as you read Nicoles name on the paper. You couldn't dream of doing anything sexual with her and you're sure she'll feel the same, despite the strange way she's been eyeing you up lately. Almost without thinking you blurt out your dare. "Nicole, let me put my dick away." She looked up expectantly at the sound of her name but when you finished saying your dare she looked almost disappointed. You don't pay that expression any mind as your hands quickly go to your waistband, racing to tuck your dick back into your underwear, but before you can two protests stop you.

"That's not a real dare John!" Sarah shouts. "Yeah, you can't just do that." Miranda adds, clearly upset at the thought of losing her eye candy so soon. "Oh come on. It's still a dare!" You whine, your hands still on your waistband. "Not much of one, it's no fun." Sarah replies, pouting and crossing her arms. Unexpectedly Tom interjects. "Hey if John wants to hide his shame, I say let him."

"His shame?!" Sarah responds, incredulous. "Yeah, ok Tom. Johns clearly got nothing to be ashamed of." She adds, rolling her eyes at his choice of words. Despite your embarrassment that compliment does feel a little good, but you're more grateful for Toms voice of support, even though you know his motives are self-serving. Sensing that Matt might feel the same way as Tom, that he wants your dick away from the girls for personal reasons, you decide to settle this democratically. "Lets vote on it." You announce, speaking quickly before Miranda or Sarah can stop you. "Who thinks my dare is fine?" As you say this you raise your hand and Matt and Toms shoot up in unison.

Before you even have a chance to put your hand down however, Sarah interrupts again. "Nuh uh uh, you don't get a vote." She tells you, wagging her finger at you like you were a misbehaving dog. "You're on trial, the murderer doesn't get to be on the jury." Internally you question her exact logic but externally you silently drop your hand, the fire in Sarahs eyes seems to brook no argument and it is her house after all. Turning from you Sarah addresses the room again. "Who thinks John should have to give a new dare?" She raises her hand at the end of her sentence and Miranda mirrors her. With your vote discounted it's a tie, but for one abstinent voter.

Silently all eyes turn to Nicole who blushes under the sudden attention. You watch with bated breath as Nicole lifts her hand from her lap and tentatively raises it, not even getting it above her head before Sarah explodes with joy. "Thank you Nicole!" She yells, so pleased that for a second it looks like she might burst from her seat and embrace your blonde haired friend. Instead she turns her palms to the sky as if thanking god and utters "Democracy wins again." You, however are much less enthused by the result and you make this known to Nicole by a quiet glare. "Sorry, John." She shrugs timidly, "But it really wasn't much of a dare." You can tell by the way she's looking at your crotch that it wasn't her only reason for voting against you, but you decide to not confront her about that right now.

Instead you sigh and try to lighten the mood with a quick joke. "If you only count the legitimate votes I won by a lot." Everyone laughs at that, including Matt and Tom, clearly not getting what they wanted from the vote hasn't affected them too badly. Still even as everyone laughs you can't help but feel a little frustrated and before you give in to Sarahs wishes for a new dare you try one last gambit. "What if I refuse to give another dare or just give Nicole the same one?" You ask, and then immediately wish you didn't as Sarah pins you with a sinister stare. "Don't worry John, I won't kick you out." She purrs, her voice full of mischief. "You'll just have to do a forfeit."

"What's the forfeit?" You ask, trying to keep the growing concern out of your voice. She grins wickedly as she answers "That's for me to know and you to find out, but trust me John, it'd be a lot of fun." Something about her tone of voice makes it clear that what might be fun for Sarah wouldn't be fun for you. Maybe she'd make you get completely naked, sitting with your dick out is bad enough but you're sure Sarah has plenty of tricks to humiliate you more. But maybe facing down the forfeit could be worth it if it meant you could cover up again and get the focus of the game away from your crotch. With all eyes on you you'll have to decide soon.