Hope for the best...

On the one hand, you feel possessive, like Nicole belongs to you. You’ve known her for so long, it feels like through your action alone would something as important as Nicole's virginity be at stake. Or in this case, inaction.

But as much as you’ve been waiting for an opportunity to get together with Miranda, there is just too much conflict and taboo eagerness watching Nicole get taken advantage of. Besides, Nicole is not drunk and she is a willing participant in the game. You can always step in if things go over the line, but suddenly you wonder where the hell that line is tonight.

Tom's thick cock rubs at Nicole's clit, massaging it rhythmically and causing Nicole to tremble. Moans and grunts intertwine while Tom is kissing Nicole's neck and occasionally pauses to nibble on her earlobe.

Miranda's pace on your cock builds, along with the pressure within you. Her glorious 36C breasts smash against your side as she begins to suck and nip at your neck.

Nicole's hips begin to buck dangerously, and jam Tom's cock almost too close to her slippery entrance. Tom's speed begins to increase and Nicole keeps pace as her moans get louder.

You gather Miranda’s thick, brown hair into one hand and pull her lips to yours. Miranda's mouth meets yours with such urgency that she bangs your lower lip with her teeth. You both giggle as she whispers, "sorry, John" and resumes kissing you with aggressive tongue. You can feel yourself working towards the makings of an orgasm.

Despite the euphoria, something seems off...

Nicole suddenly opens her eyes and freezes, albeit panting. With the moaning silenced, it just occurred to you that the music had long stopped.

The music gone, Nicole realizes what she was doing and quickly got off of Tom's lap.

“Ugh! What was I thinking?” Nicole asks with mild disgust, which seems especially unconvincing with how wet her blonde carpet is.

Just as quickly as it started, Miranda pulls away from you and tries to appear presentable. Your poor cock is begging for release at this point, but you find some solace in knowing Nicole didn't do something she would regret. Miranda makes a distressed face and adjusts her ass on the couch, no doubt trying to get comfortable with her butt plug.

Nicole tries to swing a leg over Tom's lap, but Nicole underestimated how shaky her legs were. Just as quickly, Nicole comes right back down onto Tom's lap, this time directly toward his raging erection.

You couldn’t comprehend what you were seeing and, from the gasp next to you, neither could Miranda. Unexpectedly, Tom quickly braced Nicole with his hands on her ass, her inviting pussy mere inches from Tom's monster cock. Nicole's eyes were wide open as Tom, wordlessly, stood up and helped Nicole regain her balance.

Everyone remains silent from the recent close-call penetration and Tom's uncharacteristic chivalry, until Tom wrote something and shows Nicole the notepad.

“Thanks, Tom, for protecting my modesty, but next time feel free to fuck me like a whore paid by the hour.” Nicole twists her face into a snarl of disgust. “Eww, Tom! You’re so creepy, I’d never fuck you.”

Despite her outrage, Nicole sits right next to Tom, on the arm of his usual chair, completely naked and within arm’s reach. Tom stayed quiet and shot her a knowing wink.

“Yeah, besides,” Matt starts, a little flustered and adjusting his erection, “Even if Nicole would ever fuck you, she definitely wouldn’t let you be her first time.”

Again, silence fills the room. You cannot believe Matt just said that to Tom. Sarah is trying to hide her surprised laughter. Nicole has become ghost white and really stiff in her perch next to Tom, who is steadily widening a sinister grin.

Only Nicole's closest friends knew she was still a virgin, so it’s no surprise that Tom didn’t know. But you had confided that fact in private conversation with Matt , and he wasn’t supposed to let on that he knew. Now you shoot Matt a pissed off glare and hope Nicole doesn’t fixate on where he got his info.

Overwhelmed by embarrassment and without saying a word, Nicole realized it was her turn to draw a name.