Miranda

"I got Miranda", Nicole says, still trying to cover herself up. "And for your dare, I dare you to let me put my clothes-"

"Wait right there" Tom says, before Nicole can finish her dare. You all turn, and notice he's scribbled something onto the notepad again, holding it out for Nicole to read. She glares at him, and looks at it. Reluctantly, she begins to read.

"Miranda, I dare you to let Tom give you a matching butt plug as well..." Nicole says reluctantly.

"What? No way! I've never had anything in... THERE before!" Miranda protests.

"Oh come on, there's a first time for everything! I promise I'll be gentle. After all, it'd be a lot easier for you to take this than it was for Sarah to take me!" Tom brags.

Looking around, Miranda finds no signs of support from the other players, and reluctantly nods her head.

With a grin of triumph, Tom gets another butt plug the twin of the one Nicole currently has inserted in her ass, and approaches Miranda, who nervously turns around, and gets down on her hands and knees, presenting her slender ass to Tom.

Tom slowly pulls Miranda's panties down, and you stare as her nether regions are slowly revealed, taking in her perfectly pink rosebud asshole, and then her clean shaven pussy lips, just slightly moist. Tom presses the butt plug against her ass, and starts applying pressure, causing Miranda to yelp and wriggle forwards.

"What are you thinking?! It's not lubricated at all! It'll never go in like that!" Miranda yells at Tom indignantly.

"Hmm your right. But we don't have any lube handy... hmmm... what can we use instead..." Tom says, in mock deliberation. His eyes travel down from her ass, and reach her pussy lips, and he grins as a devious idea comes to him. Sliding the butt plug down a bit, he lines the tip up with the entrance of Miranda's pussy lips, and again start pushing it forwards.

"Hey! That wasn't part of the deal!" Miranda exclaims, involuntarily shuddering at the intrusion.

"Well, it's this or we're going in dry into your ass, so you choose!" Tom replies, while he pushes another inch of the butt plug into Miranda. Deciding this was the lesser of two evils, Miranda bites her lips, and does her best not to show any signs of pleasure as Tom finally pushes all of the butt plug into her pussy, and slowly begins to fuck her with it.

"Well well, look at that. I've barely started and it's already almost dripping with your juices! Sure you don't just want me to use the real thing?" Tom says.

"Don't even fucking think of it. It's wet enough, just get on with it you creep." Miranda replies frostily.

"Oooh, still got some sass in you huh? You really shouldn't antagonize the guy about to stick something up your ass though, princess." Tom responds. Without any warning, he pulls the butt plug out of Miranda's pussy, and then, in one steady motion, roughly shoves it all the way into her ass hole, not giving her any time to adjust to it.

Miranda let's out a strangled moan of surprise, pain, and to her own embarrassment, pleasure, as she feels her pussy suddenly vacated, and her back entrance uncomfortably full for the first time in her sexual life. Still, she quickly struggles to her feet, and pulls her panties back up, not giving Tom a chance to do anything else back there.

"Awww, spoil sport" Tom says, before getting up himself. "Well, time for you to pick a name!"

Miranda hobbles over to the bowl, still sore and not quite used to the foreign object now lodged in her bowels, and pulled a name out.