Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 15 by Stagger Stagger

Who is it?

You.

Seeing your name, Matt yells into the closet with an irritated tone. "Tom, you drew John."

It's a moment before Tom responds, and he sounds a bit impatient. "...Oh yea, I've still got to dare right? ...Uh, whatever, just fuck the first girl out there who raises her hand or something."

Everyone's quiet for moment in the face of Tom's lazily constructed, yet fairly major dare.

You're just starting to wonder if you should ask for a time limit in case no hands go up, but looking to Nicole, you can see her fidgeting nervously while shooting glances at your cock, her hand flexing as if she's considering raising it.

You swallow nervously; both you and Nicole have been friends for so long that neither of you saw each other as a member of the opposite sex before tonight... but you've had your eyes on her partly revealed tits on and off all night, and she's been staring at your dick whenever she thinks no one is paying attention.

You can almost see the urge to raise her hand winning, but you feel a tap on the shoulder all of a sudden.

Looking over, you see Sarah's sidled up next to you and has one hand outstretched to get your attention, the other raised high above of her head.

You just stare at her for a moment, while a shameless grin creeps onto her face.

You can see Nicole looking a mix of relieved and disappointed as she notices Sarah's raised hand too, but Sarah pulls your attention back by leaning close to whisper into your ear.

From so close, you can smell both Matt's and Nicole's "juices" on her face despite the cleanup she's done in the mean time.

"You were staring pretty hard at Nicole there. I wouldn't normally cut in like this, but you've been showing off that big dick of yours for so long now, and" a slight pout enters her voice, "I still haven't had a chance to get off tonight."

Her voice sounds a little excited as she adds. "If you're upset though, feel free to take it out on me; I like it rough." Laughing, Sarah pulls back and grins at you.

Without Sarah taking up your field of view, you realize Matt looks furious from where he's sitting, though he doesn't seem to know where to aim it. You're going to be fucking Sarah, but Tom is the one who set up the stupid dare.

Right in front of you, Sarah wriggles out of her pants, then gives you a provoking grin, raising an eyebrow as if to say 'well?'

After the rather 'stressful' game, involving your crush sucking Tom's dick and now doing who-knows-what in the closet with him, and now you having to fuck your friend's crush, you feel your temper flaring up more than usual in the face of her challenging smirk.

Pushing Sarah to the ground and climbing on top of her, you hear let out a playful shriek at your sudden movements, but she's clearly not trying to prevent you from pinning her.

The exaggerated look of mock-fear on her face irritates you, and you feel an urge to punish her enough to wipe the expression off her face as you line up your cock at the entrance of her pussy and ram it into her.

Sarah lets out a moan as you cram her pussy full of your large dick in one hard thrust. The warm insides of her cunt feel incredible, but being pissed at Sarah at the moment, this fact annoys you even more.

Sarah moans and gasps underneath you, letting out a stream of obscenities as you fuck her more and more roughly.

Seeing Sarah lose her composure gives you a moment of satisfaction, and you keep up the pressure, pounding her with your dick while she thrashes and moans more and more energetically.

Feeling your orgasm building, you begin thrusting harder and deeper, and can't resist the urge to blow inside of Sarah.

As your cum rises up and begins shooting out from the tip of your cock and deep inside of Sarah, you feel her quiver underneath you while letting out another loud obscenity, her legs squeezing your body while she has a very intense and very obvious orgasm.

You finish cumming inside her while she continues to tremble with pleasure, then pull free as your lust fades enough to make you realize you just came inside your friend's crush right in front of him.

Sarah remains lying on her back with a very satisfied expression on her face, cum leaking from her thoroughly-fucked pussy. You console yourself that a slut like Sarah is definitely on birth control...

...You'd felt like you had the upper hand during your fuck, but somehow now you can't help but like a puppet on her strings, doing exactly what she wanted while feeling like you were punishing her...

After a few moments, you remember there's still a game going, and go to the hat to draw.

Who do you draw?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)