Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 15 by UF UF

What Happens Next?

Part 13

Making his way into the restaurant with Siobhan on his arm, the maitre'd, a woman with long blonde hair, green eyes, a slender body with medium-sized breasts and a toned ass highlighted by her uniform and greeted them with a cheery smile.

"Peter, Siobhan, nice to see two of my favourite customers and on a date together." Ruby Black greeted the pair.

"This is so not a date," Siobhan commented. "Can we have that table over there?" Siobhan asked as she pointed across to a table near a window.

Peter glanced over to where the table was and noticed immediately it was right next to a table where Xander McCraven and his date, Peter's first-ever girlfriend, Kaley Simmons were sitting.

Xander McCraven was a teenager with short brown hair, green eyes with an athletic build along with several tattoos and was dressed in a t-shirt and a pair of jeans. Kaley Simmons on the other hand was a true vision of beauty with long red hair and brown eyes and wore a black cocktail dress that highlighted her large breasts and curvy ass.

"Of course " Ruby said before escorting Peter and Siobhan over to the table and handing them menus, leaving them to decide what they wanted and Peter noticed that Xander had glanced over and had seen him and Siobhan together.

"Siobhan?" Xander said in surprise upon seeing his ex-girlfriend.

"Peter?" Kaley said as she followed her date's eyes to the pair.

"What are you..." Xander glared at Siobhan as he spoke.

"Oh, hey Xander, I didn't realise you," Siobhan responded innocently in a way that made Peter think she could be one hell of an actress one day. "Maybe we should call Ruby back and get these tables pushed together. Turn it into a double-date of sorts?"

"I don't know... Xander and I..." Kaley said awkwardly while looking at her ex-boyfriend.

"What do you think, babe?" Siobhan ignored the other redhead and looked at Peter.

Not sure of where his date for the evening was going with her plan, Peter simply nodded in agreement and said. "I don't see a problem, we're all friends here..."

"Perfect," Siobhan mischievously smiled. "Ruby… Hold on…"


Sitting down together at a table that was for four people, much to Xander's displeasure, Peter found himself sitting next to Kaley while Siobhan sat opposite him and next to Xander. Spending the next several minutes talking to their dates, Peter noticed that Xander was scowling at him and instead, Peter tried hard to focus on his date however it seemed Siobhan had other plans.

"So Kaley, you and the Sirens had a great show the other night," Siobhan commented. "You ever catch the show, Peter?"

"Yeah, I did. Claire and I are friends and so are Kaley and I so I go to show my support," Peter responded as he looked at Kaley. "You guys are amazing."

"Thank you," Kaley said with a smile. "I know you and I were a long time ago but it's still great you do show up."

"I'd love to come too," Xander found himself interrupting. "You Sirens are hot and I bet the music you make is too."

"Well we could always use more people in the audience," Kaley said.

"Good luck, getting Xander somewhere that isn't a strip club," Siobhan commented. "Peter on the other hand, he loves music and to support his friends but I don't need to tell you that..."

"You don't," Kaley said with a small smile as she looked over at her ex-boyfriend.

"What can I say, I'm always there for the people I care about…" Peter smiled.

"He's not the only one,” Xander said while trying to interject himself back into the conversation. “Did I ever tell you about the time I…”

“Yeah, no one cares Xander,” Siobhan coldly said as she took Peter’s hand in full view of both Xander and Kaley. “We’re talking about Peter and what a great guy he is. Only a fool would give someone as nice and caring…” Siobhan said with a smirk at Kaley before leaning across the table and saying to Kaley. "You know, Kaley, I've been meaning to ask you something. Do you even like Xander?" She glanced over at Xander, then back at Peter, a mischievous glint in her eye. "Because I could think of better ways to spend an evening," Siobhan added before leaning back in her seat again.

As the table grew awkward in the silence moments after, Kaley excused herself to the restroom and Peter also excused himself, based on the way Siobhan was indicating for him to follow her and so Peter made his way towards the hallway where as soon as they were out of sight, Peter found Kaley waiting for him.

“Want to tell me why Siobhan is trying hard to sing your praises?” Kaley said as she leaned against the wall.

“Why do you think?” Peter responded. “Because you and I both know it’s true.”

“I’ve heard the stories,” Kaley admitted. “And I have to admit it does make a girl think about her first-ever boyfriend and what might have happened if we were a little older and still together…”

“Well, you could always find out,” Peter said as he leaned in closer to Kaley and he reached out, tracing a finger down her arm, sending shivers down her spine. "Because I think I could show you a much better time than Xander ever could."

And without waiting for her reply, Peter leaned in closer, his lips brushing against hers, the contact sent a wave of heat coursing through her veins, and she moaned softly into his mouth.

What Happens Next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)