Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 16 by UF UF

What Happens Next?

Part 14

As their kiss grew deeper and deeper, Peter brought Kaley into the bathroom, closing the door behind them before making quick work of getting rid of the redhead’s dress. Peter then picked Kaley up and brought her back to his counter dropping the woman on it and forcing her legs apart and began rubbing his groin against her.

Kaley gasped as she felt the thick cock against her wet hole and she started to kiss Peter back as he explored her body with his hands. Surprising herself, Kaley threw her arms around his shoulders and clasped her legs around Peter’s waist, wanting to get as close to him as possible while Peter quickly discarded his clothes and groped and squeezed her ample breasts, as he continued to French-kiss her deeply.

Unable to hold back, Peter twisted Kaley around and pushed down on her back so that she was bent over on all fours across the bathroom counter with her ass and pussy now completely exposed to him and Peter lowered his head down and began by circling her clit with his tongue clockwise, gradually increasing the speed and pressure, teasing her wet hole.

“Ohh… Ohh… Ohh… Ohh,” Kaley groaned as Peter spent the next several minutes devouring her pussy, licking her clit and her pussy, up and down, in one long stroke, often changing speeds as her legs and her whole body were trembling with a combination of lust, anxiety, and fatigue from Peter’s actions. “Peter… Ohh… Ohh… Peter, you're going to make me cum!”

Then, Peter suddenly stopped and pulled Kaley down so that she was kneeling on the bathroom floor with his rock-hard dick in front of her face. Immediately, Kaley started to gently pump the shaft a bit before carefully putting her mouth over the head of his dick and tried to take as much of his cock into her mouth and throat as possible.

After only a few inches, Kaley gagged and had to take it out before sucking the head of his tool while pumping the rest with her hand. Occasionally, Kaley would lick the length of his shaft all the way up to the head and after several minutes, Peter swiftly brought Kaley up to her feet and bent her over the counter once more.

Kaley then felt Peter mount her and she braced herself as Peter leaned over, pulled her red hair to one side, and started to suck the back of her neck as he rammed half of his dick into her pussy.

“Ahhhhh,” Kaley gasped as it felt like he was ripping her apart.

Peter started to pump slowly as he felt Kaley’s pussy adjust to his enormous size before he slowly sped up. Within a couple of minutes, Peter had thrust the remainder of his cock into her tight pussy and Kaley groaned into the sink and her eyes filled with tears while Peter pumped into her with everything he had and grunting with every thrust as he pinched her dangling nipples.

“Ohhh Kaley… You’re such a good fuck.” Peter whispered into Kaley’s ear.

“Yessss…” Kaley groaned in response as she erupted with a series of orgasms; one after another as Peter continued to fuck her.

Soon, Peter flipped Kaley onto her back, positioning her smooth legs over his shoulders and began with long, slow strokes, where he pulled his cock almost the whole way out of her cunt, before slipping it back into the hilt and Peter quickly picked up the pace and accelerated his thrusting.


Meanwhile, Xander and Siobhan found themselves sitting by themselves at the table in silence, Siobhan making every effort to ignore her ex-boyfriend every time he tried to say something. Instead, she found herself thinking about Peter and Kaley, wondering what they were doing in the bathroom of the restaurant and she found herself, getting annoyed at the thought of Peter fucking Kaley, something that surprised the redhead.

Eventually, as the thoughts consumed her, Siobhan found herself imagining each and every position, Peter could be taking the other redhead, each one turning Siobhan's mood sour and eventually Siobhan stood from the table and without a word to Xander, she made her way over to the bathroom.

Looking around to make sure no one could see her, opened the door to find Peter fucking Kaley whose legs were over his shoulders as his large, hard cock thrust in and out of her pussy and realising that Peter was getting close to erupting, Siobhan made her way into the bathroom, locking the door behind her, getting Peter and Kaley's attention.

"Don't you fucking cum in her!" Siobhan demanded as she looked at Kaley who seemed slightly out of out, probably because of the orgasms she had thanks to Peter, Siobhan deduced.

"Siobhan, what?" Peter said in confusion as he pulled out of Kaley, letting the redhead fall to the ground as she attempted to recover from the highs of her pleasure. "You asked me to..."

"And you did what I said, you helped me get **** on Xander by fucking the girl he ditched me for," Siobhan responded as she looked at Kaley with a smirk on her face. "That doesn't mean she gets your cum, I know the perfect place for that," Siobhan smiled. "So, Grayson, ready for your reward?"

"Reward?" Peter said in confusion.

"The one thing that not even Xander got," Siobhan said as she undid the zip of her dress and lowered it onto the ground, before turning around and bending over the sink, showcasing her curvy ass for him. "My ass. It's yours, so what do you say, Grayson?”

To Be Continued...

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)