Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 17 by Mynamajeff Mynamajeff

Do you pull out in time?

No.

You try your hardest to take your cock out of Nicole's tight opening, but it seems to get tighter as you try to.

You let out a grunt, as you shoot one of the biggest loads you ever have into her fertile pussy.

"Oh fuck." You murmur, a feeling of dread spreading through your body.

"Did you cum in me, John?" Nicole asks, to which you nod slowly. "Aw. Accidents happen, I guess." She shrugs, strangely not caring about potentially getting knocked up.

"But-" You try to protest, before she cuts you off again.

"Look, John, even if there is a chance you've gotten me pregnant, I can just get a morning after pill." She replies, sensing that you're worried.

"Yeah, right." You reply, feeling a little better. You pull your now limp cock out of her, and lay next to her on the bed.

She turns over, looking deeply into your eyes, while playfully trailing her fingertips across your chest. "That was fucking amazing, John." She giggles, lovingly nuzzling your neck. "I love you."

"I love you too, Nicole." You respond, feeling yourself begin to get a little harder again. "Do you forgive me for not realising it sooner?"

"Of course." Nicole replies, happily. "And do you forgive me for not realising how much I liked you sooner?"

"You don't need to apologise for that, Nicole." You smile, finding it cute that she'd think to apologise for that.

She sits up on the bed, and climbs on top of you, straddling you, her ass brushing against your quickly hardening cock. She kisses you again, slowly grinding against your cock.

"Up for round 2, lover?" She asks, a devilish smirk on her face.

"Fuck yes." Is all you can manage.

You get ready to let her slide your cock into her pussy, before she stops.

"I had... something else in mind." She smiles sheepishly. "John, could you take my anal virginity too?"

You couldn't believe your ears. "Of course." You reply, a little overly enthusiastically, but she just giggles and raises her ass slightly, holding your cock against her other tight virgin hole.

She begins to lower her ass down on it, and, despite it's tightness, you're amazed at how easily it goes in. She must have had practice.

She begins moaning softly as she starts to ride your cock, pretty well for someone who was a virgin less than half an hour ago.

The sensation is incredible, being so much tighter than her pussy, though it's a pretty close competition.

"Just, ugh, tell me when you're gonna cum this time, yeah?" She smirks, her moans breaking up her speech.

All you can do is nod, as you know that it won't be long until you'll need to tell her.

After another couple minutes of Nicole bouncing up and down on your cock, you feel yourself about to cum. "Nicole, I'm gonna-"

You're cut off by Nicole quickly climbing off your cock, and taking it into her mouth. You cum pretty much straight away.

She looks up at you, and makes unbreaking eye contact as she swallows your load, then smiles proudly.

"Holy fuck." You laugh, as she lays back down next to you, wrapping your arms around her.

You lay there in silence for a couple minutes, until you realise that Nicole has fallen asleep. You smile softly, and soon join her, falling asleep in each other's arms.

What's next?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)