No, but she has discovered you...

"No, maybe another time."

Nicole looks at you after answering and turns to you.

"Can we talk, John?"

You head back to the room where you both had the previous conversation, a little curious.

"I heard you talking with Sarah." She informs you before you can say anything. "I'm a little mad, John. I thought you said we had to be honest with each other?"

Oh shit. You're totally screwed now, aren't you?

"Tell me something, John. Answer completely honestly, please. Would you leave me for her?"

"Of course Not!" You respond immediately. You don't need to think that answer.

"But you still like Miranda." Nicole states.

You lower your head in shame, some tears start to form in your eyes. "I'm sorry, Nicole. I,"

You are interrupted when Nicole takes your face in his hands and kisses you firmly but tenderly.

"We can't help our feelings, John. I know, trust me."

How the hell can this girl continue to surprise you? You kiss her again with the same tenderness, but she breaks the kiss in no time.

"Do you want to try dating Miranda?" Nicole asks you.

"Nicole, I'm dating you now. I love you!" You reply to her.

"That's not what I asked you. Answer yes or no."

"Yes. Part of me still wants to try dating Miranda. But..."

"Then I'll talk to her," Nicole interrupts you. At your surprised look, she rolls her eyes, sighs dramatically, and continues her explanation.

"Look, you're obviously still in love with her. You may not love her the same way you love me, but you love her and that's what matters. I want to make you happy. If that means sharing you with another girl, I'm ready for that. Hell, we could both play together for you if that's what you want. Who knows? She might be willing to humiliate you the way you like it. Whether it's with other men or even..." She nervously bites her lower lip and continues. "Maybe with me?"

You look at her in surprise for a moment and then it hits you.

"The idea of sharing me excites you, doesn't it? Now that you know Miranda is no match for you, you love the idea of sharing me with her. I bet that sadistic side of you likes the idea of rubbing it in, don't you? You want to show me off to her as your conquest, rub it in that you'll always be first for me..."

She looks at you with surprise for a moment, but then smiles at you with a mischievous look.

"If it's any consolation, I won't hurt her. Well, if she begs nicely, maybe..." A wicked little laugh leaves her lips, but she soon turns serious again. "Look, let me talk to her and we'll go from there, okay? I mean, if Miranda isn't willing to share, what's the point of planning what's never going to happen?"

You simply nod. She's right, after all. If Miranda is not willing to share you with Nicole, nothing will happen between you two. Now that you're finally dating her, Nicole is and always will be first for you, and you won't risk that for a slim chance with Miranda. Never.