Matt puts on a duo show with Nicole

"Matt, hmm." This is only the third time your buddy's name has come up, but he's not hurting for attention. He's already blown a load on Sarah and nearly another between her tits. Still, from the way he's still staring at her gloriously naked body, he definitely wouldn't say no to another round.

"What's the dare?" he asks, folding his arms across his chest. "I'm ready for anything," he says, echoing Tom from a moment ago. Nicole, standing beside him, puts a hand on his shoulder to catch his attention and then very deliberately lowers her eyes to his still half-erect prick.

"I'll bet you are," she murmurs, and a bit of color shows up in his cheeks.

"How 'bout you show that, then, 'cause I dare you two to race to see who can jack to orgasm first."

"Hey, I just fingered myself," Nicole grouches. "And that was your dare too. A little creativity, please. It's not even supposed to be a dare for me!"

"Fine, second to cum, then," replies Tom, not missing a beat and with his smirk growing even wider, "and don't finger yourself, I dare Matt to finger you while you give him a handjob. On the couch, next to each other, without panties." That still sounds like a dare for Nicole at least as much as Matt, but she doesn't object any more, just turns bright red as she moves back to the couch with Matt and drops her black panties. You've got some vague sense of outrage and jealousy in the back of your mind, but mostly you look appreciatively for the first time at Nicole's pussy. The tuft of hair is blonde; no, she hasn't been dyeing.

"What do we even get for winning?" Matt asks as the pair take their seats and give each other other hesitant looks, then glance at you, then look at anything but each other.

Before Tom can answer, Sarah chimes in, "I'll finish off the winner myself!" Not quite an enticement for Nicole, maybe... but more than enough to motivate Matt.

Nicole starts to say something, but Matt speaks over her, "Sold!" and lays a hand on her pale upper thigh. Her words come out as a squeak as his fingers glide up and slip between her lips. Gently, but her eyes still go wide and she bites her lips as he rubs slowly. Then she takes on the look of determination you know so well and her fingers encircle his cock and begin to slide up and down with a loose grip. You know she's fooled around with boyfriends before, but it certainly doesn't look like she's experienced doing this. Still, Matt's cock responds quickly in her grasp, standing straight and proud. As you and Tom watch eagerly, Matt moves his fingers more quickly, teasing her clit as a small gap comes from her. He's not reaching inside her, though, and you realize he's being careful with a girl he knows is a virgin. He's a good guy, you tell yourself while quashing jealousy. And we're all playing. And it's not like he chose to do this. At least she's enjoying herself and Tom's not the one doing what I... You can't finish that thought, even to yourself. But you look over at Miranda, who has her lower lip cutely caught between her teeth and remind yourself where your priorities are as you put an arm around her shoulder. She gives you a quick smile and doesn't object but keeps her eyes on the action.

Meanwhile Nicole's hand is pumping rhythmically on him with a quiet rasp of skin on skin as Sarah suddenly moves towards them. "Stop for a second," she tells Nicole, and then sinks to her knees before Matt and looks up at before quickly sliding her lips up and down his length a couple of times. "See? Gotta keep things wet. Now it's slick enough to jerk properly." Interfering with the contest, maybe, but no one's complaining. Matt's just grinning ear to ear as Nicole's hand glides more freely along his cock, Sarah remains on her knees and touches between her own legs again, and Nicole is now flushed and panting from Matt's successful efforts, her legs drawn up and spread wide. He looks intent, but shares a tight smile with Sarah as he tangles his free hand in her long red hair.

They keep it up for a couple of minutes. Matt's hand strokes down Sarah's hair to play with her big breasts and she presses her chest forward against his exploring fingers while continuing to work her hand into herself. Matt's hand tweaks and strokes Nicole's clit and she responds with quiet grunts and moans and wrings answering sounds from him as her hand works with increasing speed on his cock.