Lube and a Butt Plug

Kilm smirked as she produced from her many sex toys a stoppered vial of Goddess Tear Extract, a natural lubricant harvested from the Goddess Tear flowers. It was very common in Thrall'Dom and had many sexual and medicinal uses. Carefully she popped it open and parted Thea's red ass cheeks. Thea winced as her sore cheeks were parted only to shudder and gasp as she felt something cool and wet dribbling down her crack. "Reach back here and hold your cheeks open for me," Kilm commanded and Thea reluctantly obeyed. She flinched and hissed at first, touching her own tender cheeks but gritting her teeth managed to pull them apart for Kiml to continue applying the lubricant. "How's that feel?"

"My ass hurts… a lot Ma'am but whatever you are dribbling between my cheeks… it's cold," Thea said, she shuddered as Kilm poured more of the lubricant between her ass cheeks. "But it also feels good… my cheeks are burning, and the cold is nice." Thea whimpered as she felt a leather clad finger covered in the lubricant poke at her puckered asshole.

"It will numb the pain, let me get some of it onto your cheeks and then we'll work some more in here," Kilm said, giving Thea one last firm poke into her butthole before pulling out. She coated the rest of her hand in the lubricant and ran it over Thea's butt cheeks, rubbing it into both of them and the half-elf's hands. "Better?"

"Much," Thea sighed as the pain faded away. The healing properties of the Goddess Tears were just strong enough in this lubricant version of the extract to numb the pain, for now. Although she felt physically better, right now she dreaded what Kilm was about to do next to her ass. She had never ventured into this territory herself, but she knew more than a few tales of other women that had enjoyed the pleasures of anal sex. But there was something so… shameful about it… there was a deep-seated embarrassment that welled up with Thea at the mere thought of having anything come close to entering her ass. And it was as Kilm's finger returned to her lubricated hole that Thea felt those feelings in full ****. "Please Ma'am…"

"Please what my little milkmaid?" Kilm asked, not stopping her probing of Thea's ass, as the tip of her finger pressed into her tight little hole.

"Please not in there, Ma'am," Thea squealed her eyes closing shut as she grunted at the feeling of that finger pushing into her untouched entrance. Her face was glowing with heat as she could not help but kick her feet up and down at the sensation. Kilm easily held her in place.

"Mmm and why should I?" Kilm asked teasingly as she slowly pushed into Thea's ass the first segment of her finger barely making it in causing the half-elf to gasp and cry. She pulled back and Thea whimpered, before Kilm applied a generous amount of lube to her finger and pushed back in even deeper.

"Please… you can fuck my pussy all you want but not my ass please…" Thea cried as she felt herself stretched out in a way she never had been before. She continued to inadvertently squirm and wiggle about.

"You're right I can fuck your pussy all I want and your ass if I pleased. That was our deal," Kilm said offhandedly. By now she had worked her way down to the second knuckle. She continued to move her finger steadily into and then out of Thea's ass, applying more and more lube, before driving it back in. "You still have not told me why I should spare your ass."

"Because it hurts," Thead winced as she felt more and more of that large half-orc finger filling her up. Despite her protests and inability to remain still, Thea fought to keep her hands in place, pulling open her mammoth sized ass cheeks and exposing her rear hole to Kilm. She did not want to fail Kilm and risk whatever punishment would be in store for her. "Please Ma'am…"

"I think you're lying," Kilm said as she pushed her finger deep into Thea till she could not fill her any further. The half-elf continued to squirm and kick beneath her but Kilm easily kept her in place with a strong hand on her back. "You can take pain, you proved that with the spanking, you enjoyed the pain." Thea whimpered and moaned as Kilm spoke. She did not know if it was the vivid reminder of her recent sexual experience at Kilm's hand or the fact that the half-orc had started moving her finger around in slow circles deep within Thea's ass. Probably a combination of the two. Either way Thea could feel herself once more getting off to this and that just caused her to well up with even more shame. "This is something else… tell me and I won't fuck your ass… at least not this time."

Thea gasped and groaned as Kilm continued to stretch out her anal passage from the inside. She felt such conflicting emotions as the pain started to fade and along with that came this weird pleasure. It was not like having her pussy fingered. It was not just the physical sensation. It went deeper than that. It was an arousal and pleasure that came from the emotions of having her ass violated like this. The shame, the embarrassment, the humiliation… it felt good but at the same time it was too much. Thea did want it to stop. "It's humiliating!" She cried her whole body jumping as in response to that Kilm pressed deeper into her ass. "Ma'am… it's not the pain… I barely feel the pain anymore… it's embarrassing! It's shameful… my pussy is right there… why don't you fuck that? Not my ass… it's not… I don't… I feel…"

"You feel almost as wet as you did when I spanked you," Kilm said. She could feel the half-elf's wetness upon her other knuckles as they rubbed up against that pussy. "As shameful as this might be to you… as embarrassed as you might feel… your body loves having your ass played with. And I think a little part of you, a part you have kept hidden your whole life, loves being humiliated." Thea could only whimper in defiance as Kilm tormented her. "But a promise is a promise… so no ass fucking for you."

Thea shuddered as she felt that finger pull back out of her ass before whimpering as it left her completely. She felt strangely empty once it was removed from her. She could barely admit it herself, but she wanted that finger back inside her. "Ma'am…" Thea said her voice low. Maybe if she begged...

"Don't worry milkmaid," Kilm hushed her as she rummaged through her coat. "I know you regret that deal already but as I said… I keep my word, so no fucking your ass today." Thea could not help but let out a soft whine at that. She could hear Kilm doing something behind her back. Droplets of that lubricant dripped down onto Thea. She tried to turn her head to see what was going on… "Head down milkmaid." Thea got an elbow in her back for her trouble before turning her head back down to the ground. Whatever Kilm was doing… Thea gasped, her eyes widened as something cold, metal and blunt prodded at her recently fingered asshole. "Steady milkmaid… just relax and let me put this inside you."

Thea could only nod her head and whimper as she held her butt cheeks wide open for the solid metal intruder that Kilm was forcing into her. Like Kilm's finger it was well lubricated and pushed into her at a slow but steady pace. However, unlike that finger this object widened a lot as it went, stretching open Thea's ass wider than it ever had been before. Tears formed in Thea's eyes as she grunted in pain.

"There, there my little anal-slut," Kilm said softly. She really had to push now to get her toy into Thea's ass, it was so incredibly tight. It was a good thing she had brought her smallest plug in with her and not one of the larger toys. "I had hoped to warm you up some more with at least two of my fingers fucking your asshole… but you didn't want that." She made it sound as if Thea was to blame for how much this hurt her. "Maybe next time you'll reconsider questioning me and accept your place as my little plaything?" Thea could only wince as the plug continued to push into her ass, going deeper than even Kilm's finger had. "Almost there… just a little more… you can do that, can't you?"

Thea nodded as she held back her tears only to shudder as the last inch of the toy sunk into her and her asshole closed around it as the widest part of it made it past her sphincter. "You can let your ass go now," Kilm said, and Thea did as instructed. She felt her hefty ass cheeks come back together around the toy, but some sort of metal base of the toy kept them slightly parted but beyond that it felt… weird. A hand grasped her by her hair and pulled her up while another strong hand pushed her off of Kilm's lap and onto her knees. "How you are going milkmaid?"

"I'm okay Ma'am," Thea said, looking up into Kilm's face for the first time since she had been placed over her lap. She could see there was both genuine concern for her in those eyes as well as a pleased smile upon her lips. "It still hurts a bit, and I can feel it inside me… constantly. It's weird… it's like this strange feeling of fullness where I did not know there was anything to fill." A blush came over Thea's face as she squirmed about on her knees before Kilm. "It still feels… shameful but you are right… I do like it."

"You do know there's nothing wrong with having something up your butt, right milkmaid?"

"Yeah, I know… my parents were… let's just say there was no beating around the bush when it came to explaining how to get down and do the nasty," Thea said before clearing her throat. Her eyes dropped from Kilm's face, focusing instead upon the half-orc's toned thighs and the dripping snatch between them. Thea's own juices had coated one of Kilm's legs and pooled upon the floor between them, but she was glad to note Kilm had made her own mess upon the bed, soaking into the furs. "I know it's okay but there's something inside of me that feels ashamed about it… but in a good way… it's like before when you teased taking me outside, tied up and in the nude… it was embarrassing to imagine but also really, really hot."

"Hmmm…" Kilm said as she lifted up her booted foot and placed it upon Thea's thick thigh. She pushed her down, her ass back onto her calves and Thea moaned as the plug within her was pushed on by her ass cheeks against her thighs. "So, you are into pain, humiliation and from the looks of it submitting to someone like me." Kilm's other boot came up to Thea's chin, pushing her head back till her eyes were once more locked with one another's. "You have been a good little whore so far… I will let you decide what we do before we run out of time. Anything else you want to explore about yourself or me. Your turn to decide what we do… but I will still decide how, understood?”

Thea went to nod, only to realise she could not with Kilm's fancy heeled boot holding her head up. "Yes," Thea said as a lump formed in her throat. Oh Goddesses above. What should she request? There was so many things Thea had fantasies about doing but never thought they would be remotely possible. Even other times she had had sex with Kilm or others passing through she had kept it strictly vanilla. But after today a whole realm of possibilities had opened up for her. What was she going to say?