John

“Well, well, well, looks like John is gonna have to take a dare this turn,” Sarah said, grinning from ear to ear.

Miranda was still recovering from her orgasm, but managed to throw a look your way that left no room for doubt as to whether she understood what was about to happen. You weren’t sure what was better at this point – the idea that she was about to unleash some erotic fantasy on you, or the idea that you were about to get off easy because she had just gotten her own release.

Whatever was better, the answer was quickly decided as she opened her mouth.

“I want you… I dare you to fuck anyone you want in this circle… besides me, because of those stupid fucking rules. You don’t stop until I cum.”

The room went dead silent. You didn’t dare tear your eyes away to see how the others were reacting, though; you were focused entirely on your crush’s face. Even though she’d just come, you’d never seen more lust or more wanton desire in the eyes of anyone, male or female. The orgasm she’d just had was apparently not enough to sate her, and you could care less whether it was you or just your dick she wanted to take advantage of. Whether it was because Miranda wasn’t a lesbian or because Sarah wasn’t as good as she liked to think, she wanted to watch someone getting dicked while she came again.

“I’m okay with this dare,” Sarah said, raising her hand as a volunteer before anyone else could even ask if the other two girls were okay with Miranda’s dare.

“I…” Nicole said, trailing off and looking up toward the ceiling. The room remained deadly silent for a long while before she spoke again, nervously shifting her glances from the ceiling to the floor as she avoided looking at the center of the group.

Well, that wasn’t a refusal… but it wasn’t an agreement either. And you had to choose how best to fulfill Miranda’s dare… considering that you weren’t going to do one of the guys, and Sarah seemed way more willing, that seemed like the obvious path. But you couldn’t help the spring in your nether regions as you imagined taking Nicole, and hearing her moans as you broke every taboo that had ever been established in your relationship…