Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 13 by ZamboniLTJ ZamboniLTJ

What's next?

John, again

You were so enraptured by the sight of Miranda getting up after having blown you and watching her panty-clad ass sway on the way back to the name bowl that it barely registered to you when she gigglingly called out, "Well, looks like it's John's turn again!" and shoots you a lewd little smirk that makes your cock give a throb.

"I may need a moment to recover," you reply with a nervous chuckle. With the direction this game had been headed all night, you were definitely somewhat worried about the girls wanting to overuse your endowment. Your cock, on the other hand, had no similar qualms, the blood flow quickly returning to the swelling length as you gazed at the evil smirk that crossed Miranda's lips.

"Oh, don't worry. We'll give little John a rest," she teased. Tom chuckled at the "little" comment, and Miranda shot him an indignant look that made your heart beat a little quicker and your cock grow a little stiffer.

"Nicole looks like she was really enjoying our show. I dare you to take off her panties with your teeth and let us all see just how much she was enjoying it?"

The look on Miranda's face told you that your jaw must have hit the floor, which is the exact same expression on Nicole's face, along with all the color rushing to her cheeks. Tom and Sarah both had huge smirks across their lips, while Matt's face was a little more level, obviously not sure of what to make of this dare.

This was not the follow-up you expected from Miranda after the eagerness of her dick-sucking. Maybe she was just playing along with the dare after all? Even so, why was she trying to get you to do stuff with Nicole, whom she knew was one of your oldest friends?

Slowly you rose from your seat, your eyes locked on Nicole, whose expression had softened quite a bit from her initial reaction. As you approached, you could see her biting her lower lip and squirming a bit in her seat. It was so adorable, and you felt your recently-sucked cock slowly stirring back to attention as you approached her.

As you knelt down in front of her, your gaze meets Nicole's and you stop for a moment.

"Well," Tom cuts in, sounding both anxious to see more female flesh as well as a little ticked that no one had been attending to his needs yet, "Get on with it!"

You drop your head lower and, as you do, amazingly you find Nicole uncrossing her legs and leaning back a bit, presenting her lower half to you. You could smell the scent of her arousal and feel the heat radiating from her, and your heart pounded in your chest. This was your childhood friend, now half-naked with your head descending into her lap!

With all the thoughts racing through your mind, you just went with what felt natural. You take a moment to teasingly run your tongue up against the fabric of her panties, eliciting a soft gasp from Nicole's lips before you take the cotton fabric between your teeth. You gingerly draw it down her pale thighs, which close against one another in an attempt to hide her bare pussy, a tuft of fuzz visible above it, while you draw her underwear off her legs and drop it from your mouth.

After a few moments, Sarah cuts in, "Hey, the dare was to let us see how much she enjoyed it, and I can barely see anything!"

"Yeah, let's see that wet twat!" Tom cuts in, making you bristle a bit before you calm yourself down.

Still saying nothing, you press your hands against the insides of Nicole's thighs and start to push them apart. Surprisingly, you find very little resistance from your friend to your touch, though she is turning her head to the side so she doesn't have to see the others' expressions as you expose Nicole's glistening pussy to them.

A pang of guilt hits you as you see Tom and Matt both adjust their throbbing erections at the sight of Nicole's pussy, though you find yourself unable to keep from looking at it. You also realize, with a bit more guilt, that you're licking your watering lips as thoughts of eating out your childhood friend race through your mind.

"Alright, John, that's good enough, it's your turn," Miranda cuts in with a smirk, and you release Nicole's silky smooth legs, which almost immediately close once more.

Your cock now rock hard, you have a bit of trouble walking over to the bowl, where you draw another name out of it.

Who's next?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)