Carrie submits excitedly

“So, let me get this straight”

Carrie asked with a straight, serious looking face as he licked the underside of David’s throbbing cock, wiping clean any remnants of his cum with her luscious tongue, just as David had instructed.

“You want me to pretend that I didn’t have the best sex of my life and go back to my ‘boyfriend’ as if his roommate didn’t fuck the living shit out me, not to mention filled me with his cum?” Carrie asked rhetorically.

“And then, you want me to continue living and sleeping with my boyfriend of several months as if nothing out of the ordinary happened while you continue to fuck, come and fill me with your abnormally large dick, all behind his back?” Carrie finally stopped, staring at David to check on his response.

“Pretty much” David casually shrugs his shoulders.

“OH GOD! That’s so fucking hot!” Carrie screamed out as her face morphs into a flurry of expressions, some you recognize when you first suggested Carrie to fool around with David.

“Shhhh…Keep it down, will you?” David said as he desperately tries to calm your girlfriend down who was hopping excitedly upwards and downwards on the bed.

“I can’t wait for you to take me when he’s around, we should do it when he’s cooking or…or playing games, fuck I can’t wait to see his face when he finds out” Carrie bursts into full fangirl mode as she lists down ideas of when her and David should fuck. All the while, you feel your heart sink deeper and deeper.

You can’t believe your girlfriend would do this to you, at this point, you wonder if you can even call Carrie your girlfriend anymore. Never in a million years would you think Carrie would be attracted to David, let alone choose him over you.

“Wow, you’re really fucked up you know that?” David said as Carrie continued checking off her list.

“Hey mister, it was your idea you know?” Carrie teased back as she placed her hands on her hips playfully.

” True but don’t call me mister”

“Would you prefer if I called you s-sir? Or Master? Maybe even daddy?” Carrie flashed a naughty, mischievous smile as she draped David’s cock on top of her cheeks lustfully.

“Why you cheeky slut” David smirked as he easily lifts Carrie’s entire body from the bed, bending her over his right shoulder with her bare ass showing.

“Woah…. hey” Carrie smiled, clearly enjoying being picked up like a fuck toy.

“Who owns this gorgeous ass huh?” David asked before slapping Carrie’s thick ass with his bare hands. An act that seems to pierce your heart like a dagger.

“Y-you do!” Carrie yelps as her breasts jiggle and bounce from David’s firm slap.

“I can’t hear you” David gives Carrie another tight slap on her ass, this time, the sound of his hand cuts through the entire room, causing Carrie to elicit a short moan.

“A-argh…. you do…. D-David owns my ass” Carrie moaned out.

“And don’t you forget it” David said as he squeezed Carrie’s ass with his hands.

“I won’t” Carrie giggled playfully as she still rests on David broad shoulder.

“Good, now let’s have you cleaned up, no fuck toy of mine will walk around smelling like sex” David said before heading to his bathroom.

“Wait, one more thing” Carrie said, interrupting David who was no doubt eager to shower together with Carrie.

“Hmm?”

“Are you going to let me sleep with my boyfriend or nah, because I kind of told him I’ll do anything he asks that’s related to sex. It’s how I ended up here on your shoulder actually” Carrie giggled playfully. David stays silent for a moment, clearly thinking on the pros and cons of his decision. A part of you hopes David says yes while the other part of you is realizing how stupid it feels to let your roommate decide if you can fuck your girlfriend or not.

Author's notes:

Hello guys, thanks for reading my chapter(s), if you like what you're reading, please leave a like to show that I'm not completely wasting my time here. A thumbs up is great but I love to know your thoughts on the chapters so far so do consider leaving a comment so we can start an conversation. Some suggestions on where to progress the story in this branch would help too.

Thanks for reading and have a great day!