David says yes but for ulterior motives

David took a solid minute to formulate an answer, his mind calculating all the possibly consequences of his decision. During which, your heart was beating like a protagonist in a really awful horror movie, the ones with the cheap costumes and pornstar quality actors. All the while, your girlfriend Carrie was hanging on your roommare's shoulder, completely nude as the day she was born with David's cum oozing out of her holes.

"Yea why not, you can still fuck him" David said nonchalantly, much to the surprise of both you and Carrie.

"What? Really?" Carrie asked, completely caught off guard by David's response.

"What, you're surprised?"

"Well....yea, figured an alpha male of your specimen would be possesive of his..." Carrie stopped short of finishing her sentence, presumably just to create a dramatic atmosphere for no reason whatsoever.

"Fucktoys" She continued.

"Hahahahaha, aren't you too cute to be a slut?" David joked as he squezeed Carrie's ass playfully, much to the delight of Carrie.

"Don't worry, you can still have sex anytime you want with your 'boyfriend'." David made sure to place extra emphasis on 'boyfriend' when mentioning you, adding a not so subtle layer of sarcasm.

What a prick.

"But I'm only allowing it so you can compare how awful your so called 'boyfriend' is compared to the real deal" David smugly says as he gives Carrie another tight slap on the ass.

"Ah there it is, there's the alpha male attitude I was looking for" Carrie smirked playfully.

"Once your boyfriend has had his little fun, feel free to come crawling to my room anytime for a real fuck from a real man okay honey?" David said as smug as always.

"Message received d-daddy" Carrie teased before David carried her into the bathroom, presumably to shower and erase the stench of adultery from their degrading souls.

Taking a deep breathe, you look down and realize you had a hard on the entire time David started to pound your girlfriend up until now. Who knew watching your roommate drill your girlfriend's insides into mush would have an effect on someone.

You went marching back to your room, uncertain how to feel about it all. A part of you feels insanely angry that Carrie went behind your back and slept with your roommate. After all you and her has been through for the past couple of months. After all the 'I love you's' after each facial and cumshot you gave Carrie.

Then again, Carrie did exactly what you asked for. You asked Carrie to sleep with David and she did, so why do you feel so furious?

"Gee, I don't know, maybe it's because Carrie just admitted to having the best sex of her life with your roommate and swearing herself to be his royal fucktoy while treating you like a highschool virgin with laughable stamina and a less than stellar cock" A voice creeps up inside your mind.

"Yea, probably that" You though to yourself as you open your bedroom door, crashing headfirst onto your bed. The very same bed your girlfriend just professed her love for you a few hours before getting nailed by some fucker called David.

Your thoughts dwell on what to do. Should you confront Carrie and ask why she's such a slut after you told her to be so? Should you keep quiet and let your roommate continue to pay his share of the rent while fucking your girlfriend on the side? Or should you just break up with Carrie and move on to more vanilla chicks?