With a wide grin

"You did believe it was for real?" She asks turning to you. Her eyes are still full of tears but her lips form a genuine smile "You have nothing to be sorry about. Men like you should do what they want, take what they desire."

You stare at her in disbelief "Was it just an act?"

"Silly. I said you that you can't truly **** me." Carrie wipes her tears off "I'll always want you. And I won't leave you unless you kick me out. But I needed to let that inner you out. Wasn't this enjoyable for you?"She smiles again and reaches up to touch your face.

"Carrie but it was so wrong... I acted like some animal." You try to protest while her gentle fingers caress your cheek.

"Don't apologize, I know how much you really love me," She says with a wink before kissing you on the lips. "Besides," she continues after breaking the kiss "It was hot as fuck!"

You don't know whether to laugh, cry, or be angry at her manipulation. This rollercoaster of emotions was something you were not prepared for. You end up laughing and hugging her tight.

"So," she says "Will you do the same with Cassidy? Will you take what you want?"

"Carrie, don't start this again." You groan

"Or what? You'll screw my cunt again?" She asks with a laugh.

"Carrie! I'm not having this argument again!"

"Yes, you are. Because I know how much you enjoyed '****' me. Now imagine doing it for real. Don't you want it?"

You pause "It is wrong to desire such things. But I can't lie. It was... Something different to anything I experienced before."

"Then just do it!" she says with encouragement. "**** her! Stick your dick in that cunt or her tight, little ass. She told me she never allowed any man there, imagine being the first to ravage her ass while she begs you to stop!" Again, her enthusiasm for **** her own sister is frightening.

Yet, you must admit, the idea does have its appeal. The mental image of having Cassidy at your mercy, both physically and emotionally, is quite a turn on. Both memories of what you just did and imagining something similar with Cassidy **** your dick to wake up.