Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 13 by skedlee skedlee

Where does the threesome go down?

The bedroom

Natalie pulls off and you grasp her wrist. You pull her to her feet and lead her into Carrie's bedroom. Once you get to the king sized bed, you push her onto it, her limbs flailing in surprise. You nod at Carrie, and she quickly sheds her panties and heels, leaving her in just the garter belt, stockings, and bra. You give her a quick kiss, and she clambers onto the bed after Natalie. Natalie is just focused on your dick as it slowly bobs up and down. You get on the bed, and Carrie begins to suck one of Natalie's tits. You take the other one, and quickly toy with her clit at the same time. You use this opportunity to see how wet Natalie is, and in your opinion she's wet enough to fuck. But, on the other hand, this might be your one opportunity to fuck Natalie. And you have to make it the fuck of her lifetime.

You take this opportunity to go down on Natalie, slowly inching away until your mouth is poised near her pussy. You begin by teasing the clit with your tongue as you insert two fingers into her cunt, slowly sawing them in and out. Natalie arches her back in pleasure but Carrie pushes her right back into the bed, cupping her other tit in the process. You ramp up your tonguing and Natalie begins to shudder in pleasure.

"God yes!" She moans, interrupting the sound of her wet pussy as you finger her roughly. Your tongue is occupied, so you can't reply right away but you don't have to because Carrie pulls off her tit and jumps in.

"Shut up whore." Carrie's harsh language surprises you, but she keeps going on before you can pull off and ask her what's going on. "You mention offhandedly to me how Chet wasn't been too affectionate with you since the wedding, and what do you do? Jump on the first fat cock you see. Even if it's my boyfriend."

"No...that's not it." Natalie pleads. "I'm not a whore. Y-y-you don't know what you're talking about." Natalie's voice is stuttered, her speech scattered by the pleasure you're giving her.

"Admit it whore. You jumped on my offer of helping satisfy my boyfriend after you saw his big dick at the movies. I know that you've been with pin-dick Chet for almost three years now, and you needed your slutty cunt truly filled, no matter who it is."

Carrie gives you a glance and you know it's time to make Natalie cum. You quickly flick your tongue over her clit quicker and quicker while Carrie mauls her breasts. In no time Natalie cums, her pussy clenching tightly around your fingers. You withdraw them, and step forward to insert your dick into her.

Before you do, however, you sense that Carrie wants to **** Natalie further. You tease Natalie by slapping your cock down on her twat and teasing her slit with the head. Carrie nods in approval and continues her taunting.

"I told you to admit that you're a fucking whore. You're not getting John's cock until you do. And if you don't do it soon, I'll let John **** your virgin ass. Well, it won't be **** because I know you'll love it so damn much."

Natalie shakes her head, her blonde locks matted in sweat on her head. In fact, she has tears running down her face as Carrie berates her. Her makeup is quickly starting to become ruined, the black eyeliner streaking down her cheeks. A small voice in your head talks about how this might be abusive but your horniness is overriding your morality at this point.

Seeing Natalie gingerly hold out, whimpering in need, Carrie takes action. She takes her right hand and grasps her throat while her left hand snakes its way down to her cunt. Your brunette girlfriend maneuvers its way around your dick and shoves four fingers straight into her pussy. You guess that it's a testament to just how wet Natalie is that Carrie appears to encounter absolutely no resistance. Your girlfriend, showing you for the first time that she has quite the dominant streak, begins rubbing her thumb on her best friend's clit. In no time at all, Natalie begins to succumb to Carrie's ministrations.

"F-f-f-fine. I'm a fucking whore. You happy now? You told me two months into Chet and my relationship that if I wasn't happy with the sex I would never be. You were right. And all I've heard for the past three months is how your new boyfriend is such a fucking stud and I realized how envious of you I am. So after seeing that John's well equipped and his impressive stamina, I agreed to your offer for a threesome. I figured it was to get us square from when you, me and Chet had a threesome that one time." Natalie's confession has moved her to tears, and she sobs out the rest of it. "So you win. I have to deal with a dead bedroom the rest of my life. Are you happy now? "

"Of course not, babe." Carrie withdraws her hands from Natalie's pussy and throat immediately and has transformed back into a caring best friend so fast that it almost gives you whiplash. "I don't feel good from saying 'I told you so.' But it's been obvious to me for so long that you haven't been happy in your relationship. And I'm sorry, but this was the best way for you to admit to yourself that you aren't good with Chet. While he might look good on paper, he's not what you need. And I know what you need right now. John's cock."

Carrie nods at you and you take that as your cue, pushing your dick into her soaked cunt. You love the dual feeling of the it's tightness and wetness, and you hope that this isn't the last time you fuck Natalie. Natalie gasps at the sudden intrusion, but that gasp quickly becomes a series of moans. Carrie smiles in delight, and unhooks her bra and she leans down to kiss Natalie on the lips.

You're taken aback by the vision in front of you. Your girlfriend's best friend getting pounded by you in missionary, her hefty tits bouncing in time with your thrusts. They sure don't seem fake right now, and her wide nipples look positively delectable. Her mouth is occupied by Carrie's, the two of them making out like high schoolers at homecoming, and the passion surprises you. Maybe one of the reasons that Carrie was so enamored with the thought of a threesome was just as much for her as it was for you. You wouldn't be the least bit surprised if your loving girlfriend had some bisexual leanings.

You start getting into a groove, and pretty soon Natalie has to turn away from Carrie, her voice shouting out in orgasm. Carrie takes this opportunity to flash you a quick thumbs up, then starts to speak to Natalie again.

"Well, now that my boyfriend has given you an orgasm, I think it's time you return the favor to me." With that, she gets to her knees and swings a leg over Natalie's face. As Natalie calms down and recovers from her orgasm, she cranes upwards towards Carrie's pussy and begins to eat her out. A surprised grunt from Natalie indicates that she's tasting the remnants of your creampie from the restaurant, and it's strange how long ago that seems.

Happy that Carrie is now being sexually satisfied by your bedroom guest, you start fucking Natalie hard. You can feel an orgasm coming soon, and you figure that it has to be your last one of the night. Four in one night wasn't quite your record, and you're sure the combined ministrations of the two lovely ladies could theoretically revive you, but you don't want to risk it.

It's not too long before you have to cum. You begin toying with Natalie's clit in order to ensure that she cums along with you. Feeling that it's the courteous thing to do, you call out that you're about to orgasm.

"I'm about to cum. Where should I deposit my load."

Natalie's mouth is occupied, but you think you hear a muffled 'my cunt' from between Carrie's legs. Carrie grins, but shakes her head. "No, you need to learn the taste of John. You'll have more opportunities for a creampie in the future, but I know for a fact that you're not on birth control currently. No, you'll get a nice slutty facial, just what you deserve."

You pull out, and climb up onto the bed, straddling Natalie's body. Your dick parts her impressive cleavage, and you stroke your cock, intending to cum on Natalie's face. Carrie takes this opportunity to climb off, her content expression signifying that she's came as well. Natalie lifts her upper body off the bed as much as she can, uses her right hand to help you stroke. You spurt out what might be the largest load of your life, surpassing the record you set last night. Carrie looks on in pride as your spurts paint Natalie's face, her face looking like the result of an impressive one man bukkake.

You flop down on your side of the bed, utterly drained from your four orgasms since work ended. The worst part is that in five hours you have an important meeting, so you probably need to get to bed soon. Carrie, as always, knows precisely what you're thinking and begins to gather what she needs to clean the bed of the evidence of your threesome. You do, however, catch Carrie grabbing her phone to take a picture of Natalie's facial, and you're surprised at how accommodating Natalie is of her request. You wouldn't want evidence of your infidelity out there, but it seems Natalie is too drunk on her orgasms to care much about that right now. You pull yourself up to the pillows and are quite glad of the fact that Carrie has such a large bed, as it gives you room to stretch out and still have Natalie and Carrie do some last little playing together. The last sight you see before falling asleep is the two of them feeding each other your cum, and you think to yourself that this might be the best day of your life.

What does the next morning bring?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)