Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 6 by masterfulmastus masterfulmastus

How does Carrie respond?

Can't stop talking about how much bigger David is

"God I...baby do you really want to hear?" she asked, and your fear began to grow. Carrie reached a hand down, rubbing the head of your hard cock against her pussy lips.

"He was...fuck his cock is just perfect! He's...God damn!" she said as she threw her head back in delight.

"Are you serious?" you blurted out as Carrie sunk down, taking every inch of you with ease.

"I can stop," she said, "I can just stop telling you if you don't want to hear."

"No...I...I want you to be honest," you said, hesitance clearly in your voice. Either Carrie didn't notice it or she didn't care as she slid up on your aching dick, building up a slow rhythm.

"Honestly? I've never cum that fast in my fucking life," Carrie admitted as she bounced on your cock.

"Or cum that hard before. Or that many fucking times! It was fucking heaven!"

Carrie continued to gush about David, not even looking down at you as she spoke.

"He stretched me out baby. Like just think about that, fuck! I mean, you can probably feel it can't you? Your girlfriend's tight little cunt got stretched and pounded by a thicker, longer man."

She was right. You didn't want to admit it, but you could feel it. It wasn't exaggerated like it often was in porn, but you could feel the difference. She had experienced thicker and longer dick, and her pussy wasn't clinging quite as tight to yours now that she'd enjoyed David.

"Fucking you now just makes it seem even worse. Jesus I knew he was bigger than you but..." Carrie trailed off, and looking at her face, you could see her expression was different. Like a mixture of disappointment and regret.

"I'm sorry but you just don't measure up to David baby," she said, looking into your eyes for the first time since she took your cock. As she did, you felt your orgasm building, the words she spoke weren't enough to stop you from enjoying your girlfriend's amazing riding ability as you drew closer to cumming.

(If you like what I've written here, please consider donating at http://ko-fi.com/masterfulmastus)

What happens next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)