No, stay quiet

You aren't a virgin, so you stay as silent as the rest of the girls are in the wake of the Red Witch's call. Her gaze scans the crowd expectantly, looking down over everyone from her seat. You notice a hand slowly rise over the crowd, and the other witches part to reveal who it belongs to. You see a somewhat shorter asian girl in a costume not unlike your own, with her hair in black pigtails beneath a pointy hat.

"I'm... a virgin," she says to the smirking watch of the Red Witch. She's pushed to the front of the crowd, right up to the cauldron as everyone seems to be celebrating her admission.

"Perfect," the Red Witch says above the clamor of excitement. The asian girl is quickly swept off her feet by the girls surrounding her, and lifted up over the cauldron. "Put her in!" shouts the Red Witch. With wide eyes and a cry of surprise, the girl is thrown into the liquid, causing it to splash out and over those gathered nearby. People erupt in a cheer for her addition to the concoction, and you just stand by wondering what happens next.

The asian girl momentarily thrashes in the cauldron, gasping and sputtering as she holds herself up by gripping the sides of the big iron bowl. She never went more than chin-deep, yet in her panic struggles to right herself in the mixture of god-knows-what. Her hat is grabbed and tossed away, and other girls' hands reach in to take hold of her limbs and drag them over the side of the cauldron, leaving her torso submerged.

The Red Witch inserts her spoon into the brew between the girl's legs, proceeding to use it as a lever to pry her butt above the surface. Straddling the handle, the Red Witch balances the lever as she leans forward, a wicked grin spreading on her face. She produces a long, thick red wand from her ample cleavage, meeting the wide eyes of the asian girl as she lifts the soaked black skirts of her costume.

With her limbs held by the witches around the cauldron, the girl can only watch as the wand is brought under those skirts, and used to extract the final ingredient of this congregation's strange potion. She gasps and groans, squeezing her eyes shut as the Red Witch leans back, holding up the wand and standing from the spoon's handle to let the girl sink into the brew.

Another cheer erupts from the girls around you. The Red Witch decides to climb in with the girl, sending the liquid into chaos as it washes over the two of them. You notice a pink steam arise from the cauldron as it appears to react to the mixing. The asian girl begins to cough and gasp, still in the grip of the witches around her. The Red Witch stands up out of the liquid, her scantily clad body soaked and shiny. She grips the wet fabric of the girl's skirts, lifting them to peer at what lay beneath.

"A success!" she proclaims. She then reveals the asian girl's body to everyone, presenting the erect penis sticking out from her panties. The girl's expression by now is still shocked, however she seems rather dazed as she follows the collective gazes of those crowding the cauldron. You notice she must not have had that phallic member before, as she also has a pussy beneath it.

The Red Witch now raises her hand, holding a ring up, held between her fingers. "Our potion was a success! This lucky girl has had the first sip, granting her untold thrills, but only for the night! Her company shall be bestowed upon whomever can claim this ring!" She grins as she dangles the silver spider-looking ring over the cauldron.

You watch as the crowd cheers. This is the kind of thing you only heard bits of rumors about, and now it's happening right before your eyes. You decide to not let the chance to be part of it pass you by, and as the Red Witch drops the ring into the concoction, you join the throngs of girls rushing the edge of the cauldron.

The frenzy you find yourself in is so chaotic, you have trouble hearing yourself think. You **** yourself to focus on grabbing that ring, plunging your hand into the liquid, joining the countless others that grab blindly beneath the body of the asian girl held in the middle of it all.

Finally, you feel the small metal spider, and grab ahold of it, quickly raising your hand in the air with a shout of triumph. Avoiding the grabbing hands of those nearby, you catch the attention of the Red Witch, who makes sure you retain your prize with a few jabs of her long spoon.

"Congratulations," she says with a smile. "She's all yours." With that, she works to lift the asian girl from the cauldron, and help her get out of the mixture. The girl seems to have retained some of her cognizance, even having swallowed the stuff. You feel light-headed just breathing the steam.

The asian girl, in her soaked witch costume, stands by you now, and you help her stand and avoid the groping hands of the other girls. You start to wonder just what you'll do now, when everyone seems to usher you two toward a door off to the side of the room. Most apparently forget about you as they instead practically throw themselves into the potion, and you're left shoved into the room with your 'prize'.

You look around, finding yourself in a bedroom--or at least, a room with a big bed, dimly lit by candles and jack-o-lanterns. You decide to lock the door behind you, before turning your attention to the girl who now sits on the floor, confused and examining herself.