He wants more than one

Phoebe gestures to Ross, “You have the biggest dick. Please claim your prize for the night. Then Chandler you can choose next. Joey will get who is left.”

Ross walks over and examines the topless women like this isn’t the first time he’s imagining fucking one of them. He stops in front of his wife and traces a finger on the curve of her magnificent breast. He ponders, “Maybe I should choose my wife. I’m not sure either of these guys deserve to be with someone so amazing.”

“That’s sweet, babe,” Rachel says, “But pick someone else. Let’s really have fun tonight.” Her blue eyes flick to me. She wants me to pick her so badly. She wants to have fun with me.

Monica says, “Hurry up and pick. I’m getting chilly over here.”

That draws Ross’s attention. His eyes immediately lock onto her rock hard nipples. His tongue unconsciously pokes out of his mouth before he realizes it and sucks it back in.

Impatiently Phoebe says, “Neither of us are gonna beg you to pick them. Just do it already. You won’t hurt our feelings.”

She is being standoffish so she won’t get picked? Does she want the opportunity for me to pick her? She doesn’t give it away with her eyes like Rachel, but she’s definitely not trying to win Ross’s favor.

Ross says, “I have an idea.” He turns from the half-naked wives to me and Joey. “How about we split this up into two threesomes? I take both your wives, and you guys can take mine.”

Joey lights up at the idea of a threesome, “I’m down. Let’s do it.”

“Oh no!” Phoebe says. “We just can’t change the rules of the competition after it happened. We agreed on swapping not choosing threesome groups.”

Monica says, “I’m fine with that change.” She looks at me, “Are you okay sharing a woman with Joey? That would be a deal breaker for me.”

I look at Joey who seems so eager. He’s nodding, trying to get me to agree. “It’ll be great dude. Trust me.”

I really don’t want to share Rachel with him, but if that’s the only options, I’ll go along. Maybe I can still get out of it: I say, “I’ll do it as long as Rachel agrees.”

Rachel looks at me considering. Her desire for me outweighs her dislike for Joey. She says, “I’ll do it as long as Joey is obedient. He has to do everything I say or he’s kicked out.”

Joey gets down on his knees, “I’ll be an obedient as a Golden Retriever. Thank you so much.”

Phoebe growls, “What the fuck! This is not what we agreed on!”

Monica puts her arms around Phoebe’s shoulders, “It’s alright. Maybe after this we can swap, and you can get a round with my husband.” She whispers, “That’s why you’re so angry right? You wanted a chance with Chandler?”

She doesn’t look at me, but it’s obvious that’s why Phoebe is upset. She huffs, “Fine. We’ll do the threesomes. And maybe afterwards if people are still horny, we can swap.”

That perks me up. After a threesome with Rachel, I get to fuck Phoebe. How did I get so lucky?

Ross looks around, “So we doing this out here, or back in the house?”