David kicks you out

Their orgasms seemed to last for an hour as you stood and watched your roommate filling your girlfriend with a seemingly endless supply of cum. As far as you had known, you were the first man that Carrie ever fucked bare and allowed to cum inside her like that. Now David was the second, Carrie was letting another man cum inside of her pussy for the first time in her life, and was clearly loving every glorious second of it.

Finally, the end seemed to be in sight as David let out one final moan, his cock still buried inside of Carrie as he slumped over a bit on top of your girlfriend. Carrie and David were both panting and recovering from what had just occurred, with David slumped over and Carrie collapsed onto his bed.

"That was the best fucking sex of my life," Carrie said, her voice muffled with her face half buried in David's sheets. What she said was clear enough that David heard though, a cocky grin on his face as he looked over at you.

"I think I broke my new toy," he said. Carrie giggled a little, shockingly okay with being called David's toy. David leaned down, planting a gentle kiss on the side of your girlfriend's cheek before stepping back. His cock fell out of Carrie and thick cum oozed out and dripped onto his bed, with David stretching and groaning for a second before giving Carrie a gentle slap on her ass.

"Fuck look at all that cum. I hope you're on the pill, otherwise this idiot is gonna be a fuckin dad," he said, gesturing over to you. Carrie was still lost in her own post orgasm bliss and barely acknowledged his comment. Turning away from your girlfriend's freshly used body, you looked over to David. He took a step forward towards you, naked and with a cocky grin on his face.

"Alright, I let you watch. Now get the fuck out," he said.

"Wha?" was all that came out of your mouth. David took another step forward, his expression becoming more serious.

"I said get the fuck out. I'm gonna fuck Carrie's ass next and you don't fuckin get to watch that."

A few seconds of silence followed as Carrie looked back at you, locking eyes for a brief second. Before you could say anything else though, David had a hand on your shoulder.

With a gentle shove you were pushed out of his room, with David shutting the door in your face, leaving you surprised and aroused. Part of you wanted to barge in and demand that Carrie stop, that it was supposed to be a one time teasing of David that had gone too far. Part of you wanted to press your luck and try to watch as David became the second man to fuck your girlfriend's ass. And part of you knew better than to test David and thought maybe you should just go back to your bedroom and take care of your own raging erection.