More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 17 by OppositeOfMiddle OppositeOfMiddle

Did we become best friends with benefits for the night?

We enjoyed sexual benefits for the night

I responded, “I know we are basically bros. But after a summer with a virgin, I am so horny, and you really have such a sexy body Carol. Let’s do it. Nothing but friends fulfilling a sexual need.”

“That sounds perfect to me,” Carol leaned down over the bed and picked something up. She came back up and handed me a condom. “Here. For when you need it.”

I took it and then continued to massage her big tits. She looked back and up at me. I bent down and kissed her. The kiss felt weird. We both broke it at the same time. I said, “How about no kissing?”

“Yeah that was like kissing my brother. How about no looking at each other? I like it from behind anyway.” She backed her booty into my hard cock again.

“Sounds good. Take off your clothes, turn off the lights and we’ll do this.” Unfortunately for me, she turned off the lights before she got undressed so I didn’t get to fully check out her nude body. I pulled off her tiny shorts and threw them at her as she ran back to bed.

She hopped into bed and we picked up where we left off. In the spooning position, she ground her thick ass cheeks up and down my hard cock, but this time is was skin-on-skin. I couldn’t get enough of squeezing her big tits and pinching her nipples, so I did that while I kissed on her neck. Carol had her hand between her legs and was fingering her pussy.

At one point, she raised her wet finger and put it into my mouth. She said, “I’m ready for you.”

In the dark, I fumbled around to find the condom. I found it and ripped it open and rolled it on. Luckily Carol kept her hand down between her legs and helped guide my cock in. She felt so wet and tight. For the first minute, I just kept my cock sitting inside her while I continued to massage her tits.

Finally I started pumping my hips, working my cock in and out of her. I took it slow, and enjoyed every moment of it. From the game, I knew she complained that Kyle came too quickly, so I made sure I lasted way longer than him.

We started in a traditional spooning position, but I would occasionally change the position of Carol’s leg and would fuck her from a new angle. I love the feeling of her soft ass hitting my hips.

Carol’s moans started out really soft, but got gradually louder as the fucking continued. She wasn’t vocal with words. It probably would have ruined it hearing my best friend talk dirty to me. I think we would both imagining we were fucking a sexy stranger. I was all over her body. It was made for hard fucking: soft and compact with her fat in the right places.

I finally turned her face down, and I fucked her while she was prone. This is the position I really wish I had the lights on for. I wanted to see how her ass looked as I pounded her from behind. I had to settle for just feeling it, and that was Heaven enough.

I brought both hands down and massaged her thick ass cheeks as my cock thrusted in and out of her wet pussy. The feeling of pleasure overwhelmed me as I thrusted deep inside her and orgasmed. I prayed that the condom hadn’t broken. Carol moaned,“Oh fuck what a good idea. I’m going to sleep like a baby.”

To make sure the condom didn’t break, I pulled out and ran to the bathroom to turn on the light. Thank good it was drooping off my cock filled with cum. I looked into the other room at Carol. She is passed out nude on the bed. Her thick ass cheeks looked so incredible. I had to go over and give me a smack. I said, “Good game, bro. I’m going to hit the showers.”

Did I ever fuck Carol again?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)