Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 37 by OppositeOfMiddle OppositeOfMiddle

How do we wait out the rain?

Tension in the tent

A hand wrapped around the shaft of my cock and squeezes. Neither girl gave an indication of who is doing it. Jamie snuggled her head on my shoulder and asked, “Have you ever been with two naked women before?”

Please log in to view the image

Hmm maybe it was her hand making the first move in a threesome. I thought I chose the right girl after all. I answered, “I have never been this lucky before. Hopefully Monica doesn’t mind that you’re seeing me naked.”

A squeeze of my cock. Monica said, “It’s okay. But I will tell Jamie that the cold rain had an effect on you. You looked tiny crawling into the tent.” She giggled at my embarrassment.

My cock grew in the squeezing hand. Jamie said, “It didn’t look that small to me.” She looked up at me and winked.

Monica asked, “Whose the biggest guy you’ve been with?”

I still couldn’t tell whose hand was now lightly stroking my cock. They were getting me excited. I started massaging each of the girls shoulders as they talked. This was getting hot.

Jamie thought, “Umm Ian was really really big.”

Monica screamed in surprise, “Really!? Ian was my best guy friend in college. I had a crush on him. I didn’t know he was hung.”

“Oh yeah. Like a horse. And he was uncircumcised,” Jamie continued. “We were never a thing, just some booty calls.”

The hand stopped stroking, and Monica sat up, turning to face Jamie. She said, “Ian was circumcised. He pissed in front of me one time, and he definitely had a mushroom head.”

Uh oh. Things were going so smoothly.

Confronted with her lie, Jamie backtracked, “Oh I must have confused his dick with someone else. But Ian did have a big one.”

Monica looked pissed, “Stop lying. You never hooked up with Ian. He would have told me.”

Please log in to view the image

Jamie defended herself, “Of course he never told you! He knew you had a crush on you and you would’ve been pissed. You’re just mad he fucked me and not you.”

Oh shit. This was not going well. I had to stop this. I tried to get up, and put myself between the two women. I ended up accidentally knocking Jamie in the arm with my swinging erection.

She looked down at my hard cock, and covered her mouth, “Oh my god! Holy shit Chandler!”

I tried to apologize, “I’m sorry. Being between two beautiful women got me a little excited. I’m sorry I’ll try to make it go down.”

Monica said, “See why I thought it looked small before?”

Jamie couldn’t take her eyes off my erection, “Sorry I didn’t know they grew so much. I mean I’ve never seen one change size so much. The guys I've been with, uhh, didn’t umm grow so much.”

Monica said, “Please just tell the truth. We won’t judge.”

Jamie stopped staring at my cock, and admitted, “Fine. I’ve never hooked up with Ian. And I’ve never really had a boyfriend. I’ve only sucked one penis, and it was hard when he pulled it out so I don’t know had it changed.” She looked so defeated. “I’m a virgin.”

Monica looked guilty she had **** her friend to tell the truth. She said, “It’s okay that you haven’t had sex. I just don’t like being lied too.”

Jamie said, “It’s not that I haven’t wanted to. I feel like I have a high sex drive. I have toys and pleasure myself a lot. I just haven’t found the right guy.”

“So you’re not saving yourself for marriage or something,” Monica asked.

Jamie shook her head and then looked back down at my hard cock. Monica noticed the attention she was giving it. She asked, “Do you want to play with Chandler a little bit?”

How did Jamie answer?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)