Take her ass.

You push her forcefully onto the counter, sending a fork flying onto the floor. You hungrily eye her tight pucker, spreading open her cheeks to rub it with a thumb.
"...oh... James, I don't know..." her voice hitches as you press against her asshole with your thumb, popping inside the sphincter. You grab some butter, melted for bagels, that's resting on the counter.
"J...James.. I've never..."
"Good..." you rub the butter onto her hole, slicking it up, and then you begin to press your cock against the entrance. "Just relax, baby girl."
"aaaaAAAHHHH!!!!" Her delicious cry rings in your ears as you breach her rear entrance.
"It's okay. Just let it happen." You press on, slowly, ever so slowly exploring deeper. Fuck.... it's the tightest....she really has never had anything up there before.
"NNnnnnnnn!! Nnnnnnn!!!!!" She whimpering so loud now. She looks back with tears in her eyes... "it...hurts...."
"Do you want me to stop?" It sounds like question, but you fix her eyes with your lustful gaze, and give little thrusts as you say it, working further in.
"...n.....no...." you're getting off on the whine in her pathetic voice.
"Just relax...I promise, it'll get better once you do."
A few minutes of crying, whimpering and slow thrusting later, and you've finally worked her hole well enough for a balls-deep stroke.
"Ahhhhh....!!!!" She groans as you bottom out. "That....that feels so weird...." her hands are behind her back, with your hand gripping them at the wrists.
You thrust rhythmically, slowly at first and increasing in tempo. Her whimpers and grunts of pain never stop, but they slowly change, including more pleasure and less pain as you go. Tears are still streaming down her face, but she starting to rub her clit with one hand that you've let free.
"Do....does it feel good, J...James..?" The whine is still strong in her voice.
"Baby girl, it feels incredible. It's the best, tightest ass in the world." You rub the small of her back. "You're such a good, brave girl."
She smiles through her tears. "Th...thank you daddy..." Incredibly, she starts to buck back against you a little bit, despite the winces it produces. "It's...it's not as bad as it was a minute ago... and it does feel good, too..."
"Oh Jesus, Tara. I'm going to cum." You grip her hips, pounding her ass with short, quick strokes.
"AH! AH! OH my GOD!" Tara rubs furiously at her clit as you **** her asshole.
"Here it comes, slut..." you bottom out, and your shaft pulses, balls tightening, pumping a load deep into her bowels.
"Ngggggggggggggg!!!!!!!" Tara's eyes roll up. "That's so gooooood......" her legs start shaking as her fingers bring her to an orgasm of her own. The tightening of her ass pushes you out, and a stream of white goodness trickles out after.
"oooo.....oooo......" Tara's soft coos echo in the kitchen as she gently rubs her ruined sphincter. "You.... you really fucked my ass... I can't believe it..." Her face is covered in tears and sweat. You grab paper towel, wetting it with cold water, and clean her face.
"You did so well."
"It was...intense. I don't know if I liked it or not, but it was definitely different..." she's panting.
You give her a loving kiss.
"I'm sorry if I went too far."
Tara shakes her head. "I... I like it when your forceful." she grips your pecs through your shirt. "It's such a turn on to be a helpless little thing, at your mercy." She grins suddenly. "You heartless bastard, destroying my asshole like that..." she winces. "That's going to be sore, for fuck's sake."
"Shit, I have to get going. I'll see you later?" You start pulling on your shorts.
"Definitely. And I'm still interested in that job in your office. I never want to go back to the restaurant now."
You smile. "And you don't have to if you don't want."
You practically run to the garage to grab your clubs, then run to your car and throw them in the trunk.
You head off to golf, thinking fondly of Tara's tight virgin asshole, and how a nice fat load of your spunk is still resting inside.