Sloppy seconds only.

“...if he could only enjoy fucking a pussy after it had been used by another man,” she finished. “After all, that one includes him liking it, right?” Thinking back to your wording, you realize she’s right.

You’re a bit disappointed, because part of the fun had been messing with her ‘real’ boyfriend, but maybe you could still work this to your advantage. “Well,” you tell her, smiling, “Now that it’s been decided, why don’t we get started?” From there, the sex actually starts. Taylor lays down on her bed, ass up, and you take her. Her pussy feels amazing, and her ass is the perfect handhold while you work your magic on her. From her moans, she’s clearly loving it too. But that’s what you want. It’s right then, as you’re pounding her, when you ask a new question. “Taylor, would you rather call Michael and tell him about our relationship while I fuck you, or have me stop having sex with you right now?”

Of course, she is so enthralled with the sex, you know exactly what she is about to pick. “The first one! Hand me my phone!” she moans, and you do as she asks. Soon, she had Michael on speaker phone. “Hey, Micahel! I, uh, have a few things to tell you,” Taylor starts, taking a second to audibly moan between words while you’re still thrusting into her pussy. “First off, I have another boyfriend now.” She takes a pause, making sure the phone can pick up the wet sound of your fucking. “He’s going to be fucking me a lot from now on, the way you never could. Now, I know you’ll like this, but you can watch if you want to, and fuck my pussy only while it’s still full of his cum.” She says all of it, as best she can, without any seeming awareness of how it would hurt Michael. It just makes you harder.

“...” There’s nothing on the other end of the call at first, so you assume Michael is just listening to you both fucking. Is he getting hard off of it, you wonder? “...okay. Thanks for telling me.” Then he hangs up, with nothing else to say.

You are amazed at how robust your power is. In no time at all, you’ve turned a once-faithful girlfriend into your main squeeze, willing to cuckold her boyfriend with you. It even made the other guy like it. Still, you’re enjoying fucking Taylor, but can you go farther?