Setting the Stage

An old grandfather clock ticks away in the background. The leather couch envelops you as you lay on your back naked while waiting for Claire's girlfriend, Alexa. You're in a small living room with a few couches, a TV, and carpeted floor.

Clair lays on the ground, her red hair in disarray around her naked body. She looks at you with an all encompassing lust, though you can still see the disgust etched into her face. By now, though, your earlier question had reduced her to a state of almost pure sexual need.

Her fingers frantically plunge into and out of her snatch. Juices flow from her crotch, soaking the carpet beneath her. You watch her tits bounce with each needy thrust of her fingers and idly play with your own dick.

For the fun of it, you turned on their electric fireplace in the corner. The slight crackle and dancing of the flames give you something to focus on during the brief moment's you look away from Claire.

"Fuuuuck, please let me cum, pleaaase, FUCK!"

Claire lays on the floor, staring at you desperately. Lazily, you reach out a hand and roll a tit in your fingers, feeling the soft flesh in your grasp.

With a wry smile, you reply, "Nah, I think I'll let you wait a bit longer."

Her eyes widen in desperation, but she can't move at all from her position on the ground, let alone get up and try to fuck you. Her thighs slap against the ground as she leans her head back, arching her back and tensing her neck. "GOD, I can't fuck- ungh, fucki- aaaahhhhh, fucking take it!"

You pat her head and say, "Sure you can."

At that, you hear the door to the garage open around the corner. Well, she's finally here, you think to yourself.

You crane your neck to see Alexa enter the living room. You feel your dick rise up as you realize that she's somehow hotter than Claire. Her plump lips and smooth, beautiful face immediately grab your attention. Bleach-Blonde hair falls in light, semi-curls to her shoulder blades. Huge tits bounce beneath a bra, and her wide hips and bubble butt are practically on display given the small pink thong she's wearing. Besides, her smooth, thick thighs and pink nipples only add to the pure picture of sex before your eyes.

Wait, bra? Thong? Exposed Nipples?

You do a double-take even as Alexa notices your existence. As she takes a step back and starts to scream, you see her eyes fall to Claire on the floor. Her hands fly to her tits, and anger seeps into her eyes.

"What the fuck Claire!"

"I can't- he- um, there's, mmmm," Claire moans as she keeps masturbating, unable to stop. You realize that she can't tell Alexa about what you've been doing, but she surprises you by shouting, "RUN!"

Alexa almost replies, but the panic returns to her eyes. She turns in a hurry, but before she can do anything you loudly call out, "It's fine Alexa! Would you rather stay and masturbate next to Claire or suck your tits on your knees by the couch?"

In the next room, you hear a muffled reply. Alexa shuffles in, her eyes darting around the room as she falls to her knees at your feet. Her hands slowly rise to her tits, and she starts to bounce and massage them in their almost nonexistent covering.

"What, what are-"

"I'm changing you and Claire. Maybe experimenting a little, who knows. Right now Claire needs some relief. Isn't that right?"

"Yes, God I need to fucking cum already!" Claire slams her hips harder and harder into her fingers, her face scrunched up in ecstasy and pain. Mustering up something foolhardy within her, she then says, "Fuck you, you fucking monster."

A ridiculous test immediately strikes you, though the fact it came so naturally might not be that great. As she moans desperately, you say, "I thought you might have learned your lesson. Oh well. Would you rather constantly be deepthroating a random person's cock from afar who is having a wet dream without actually making physical contact with it, or have two huge vibrators that you keep in your ass and mouth at all times and switch every morning and night without cleaning."

Well, that was long winded and probably impossible.

Alexa's brows knead together, and she whispers, "Wait, what the hell?"

Claire, still in the throes of a prolonged ecstasy, gunts out, "The first one!"

Immediately, you see her eyes and lips widen. You can't see anything there, but she's suddenly gagging and can't seem to form words to speak.

Apparently, the power really is limitless.

"What. The. Fuck." Alexa stares at Claire, her hands still tossing her tits around enticingly.

You sit up and cup her chin in your hand. She looks at you, wordlessly moving her mouth, and you say, "Whenever I ask a question, you have to choose and your choice will happen. Now, here's your first question; would you rather feel horny and have a need to cum or feel a need to have my dick in your pussy?"

Her lip turns up in disgust, but she says, "I guess the former."

Her body shakes, and redness flushes into her cheeks. Her hips thrust lightly, and her hands start massaging her tits more sensuously.

"One more question first. I'm enjoying this and do want sex, but I know the two of you are lesbians. So, would you rather have a powerful orgasm whenever I cum in you, but only when I cum in you, or have a powerful orgasm whenever I cum in Claire?"

Alexa freezes, but her hands continue jiggling her boobs and tweaking her exposed nipples. In the background, Claire makes a series of muffled sounds and squirms on the carpet before she starts gagging and **** a little, still masturbating furiously.

After a moment's thought, Alexa raises her head and replies, "I'll orgasm only when you cum in me. I can't do that to Claire." She turns to look at Claire struggling on the ground. Her face is pained, but not for the reason Alexa thinks. "It's okay, honey. I'll be fine." It looks like she's going to say something else to you, but one look at Claire shuts that down.

You suddenly press forward and kiss Alexa, pushing her back slightly. She falls back a little, but regains her balance. You pull back and say, "Would you rather fuck me as well as you can cowgirl or reverse cowgirl style?"

Confused, she says, "I don't know... Cowgirl, I guess?"

Hmm, apparently it doesn't matter if they know what they're choosing.

She stands abruptly while you lay back down on the couch. She straddles you, leaning in for a quick kiss. You reach up and grasp her tits, feeling them squish in your hands. With a small struggle, she removes her thong, then guides your dick into her incredibly wet cunt.

Your hands grasp her hips as she starts to rock slowly into you. Your eyes lock onto her tits, still in their amazing bra. She moans as you squeeze one of them while she thrusts all the way onto you. Her tight pussy pulls at your dick with each glorious thrust.

Given your inexperience, you quickly find yourself approaching the edge. You grip each of her tits and say, "I'm gonna cum!"

She rocks into you faster, her need to orgasm overwhelming everything else. Within seconds you feel your cock pulse inside of her and squeeze her bountiful chest even harder as you thrust deeper into her.

The second you start cumming, Alexa starts her own orgasm. Her pussy contracts on your spasming cock, dragging out your orgasm even as she moans in pure ecstasy on top of you. Her hands push into your chest and her hips thrust hard into your cock, her whole body shaking in the hardest orgasm she had ever felt.

Finally, you each finish. She falls against you for a moment, breathing heavily. She quickly realizes who you are however and gets up. As she does, she suddenly lurches to the foot of the couch and starts to play with her tits again.

"What, I don't..."

As you watch her start up again and see Claire still gagging and fingering herself, you realize that her previous choice to play with her tits came back into effect once she had fucked you. Sidetracked for a moment, you think about it and decide that it's likely because you didn't imagine an end time for that question, whereas you had imagined the fucking only happening once.

Huh, I'll have to experiment with that a bit more later.

"Why can't Claire finish?"

You lean down, looking Alexa in her eyes, and say, "Because she needs my cum in her to orgasm."

Realization dawns on Alexa's face. "Fuck, you- how-"

"Now, now, I gave you an out this time. I can either cum in her when I'm ready, or you can get a sizeable amount of my cum from your own pussy into her mouth. If you can move over there, that is. Or if I give you the option."

"You sick-"