Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 12 by OppositeOfMiddle OppositeOfMiddle

What does Phoebe request?

Really sweet cuddles

“Can you just cuddle and be sweet with me?” Phoebe requests.

“Are you serious,” I say. No way this over-sexualized woman just wants to cuddle.

“Yeah I am. Joey always just fucks, then falls asleep. I want something cute and romantic. We don’t even have to have sex. Just sweet cuddling, and if we do happen to have sex, even better, but you’ll still hold me afterwards.”

“Sure. Let’s cuddle,” I say. This woman just sucked my cock from behind and licked my asshole, and now she wants me to be sweet to her. This is the most shocking thing that’s happened all night.

I hand her a towel and help her dry off. We brush our teeth together. She stands in front of me, and I can see over her head. She spits out her toothpaste and says, “We look cute together. You’re taller than me but not too tall like Joey. We make a much better looking couple.”

I wrap my arms around her shoulders and kiss her head. “You do look pretty adorable in my arms.”

She runs her hands on my forearms, “You know you’d look so sexy with tattoos on your arms.”

“I haven’t gotten a tattoo yet,” I say. “I don’t think you’re going to convince me tonight.”

We walk through the living room to her bedroom. Soft moans travel under one of the bedroom doors. I don’t know if that’s Rachel or Monica. Phoebe holds my hand and leads me right to the bed. We get under the covers totally naked.

She faces me and snuggles up against me. I wrap my arms around her. She turns her head and lays her ear against my chest. “You’re really warm.”

“My wife calls me a furnace,” I say. Maybe I shouldn’t talk about my wife. I don’t know the etiquette for these situations.

Phoebe let’s out a long breath, almost like a purr, as she snuggles into me. I can feel the softness of her tits. The cold metal of her piercing. Her foot rubs on my calf. Everything totally innocent and relax. She may fall asleep in my arms.

And after a long bout of silence and steady breathing, I think she is asleep, until she asks, “Have you hooked up with an Asian girl before?”

“No,” I answer honestly.

“So you don’t have some fetish about me?”

“No. I just tease you and check you out because you’re smoking hot,” I say. “I always forget that your mom is Japanese.”

“My mom would like you.” Her hands rub my arms. “Are you sure you don’t want to run away and be together? Have freaky sex and then cuddle like this.”

“No way you wouldn’t have noticed me if we were both single. You only know me because I’m Joey’s friend. No way I would’ve been able to compete against all the suitors in your life. They all had more money and looks than me. I don’t know how Joey got your attention, but I never would’ve stood a chance.”

“Yeah. I was sort of a bitch back then.” Her hand runs down my back to the top of my ass. “But I’ve changed and mature. You’re a much better man for me than all those men.”

“I’m just saying even if we were both single right now. I can’t see you going for me. You’d still have a ton of rich, sexy men going for you. Sorry if it’s a downer, I’m just being realistic.”

“Don’t be so down on yourself. You’re a great guy. If both Joey and Monica die, then we have to get married. Is that a deal?” Phoebe asks.

“Deal,” I say, and Phoebe flips over and becomes little spoon with her back to me. Her soft soft ass presses into the top of my thighs. She takes my arms and wraps them around my chest.

“You’re not cocky and arrogant like my husband. That’s one of the reasons I like you. One of the reasons I knew you were packing before the contest tonight.”

Her hips grind up against me. My hand gently cups one of her tits. The perfect soft warm handful. I softly kiss her exposed neck. I whispered in her ear, “You knew I was packing the first time you accidentally saw me pissing on the trail.”

Her ass rubs on me. My cock hardens, rising slowly. “True. I did see your penis on that hike. But it’s hard to judge a penis when it’s soft.”

“I was so embarrassed. I thought Joey would try to fight me. I thought I was far enough off trail, but you just walked right into the perfect line of sight.”

Phoebe laughs, “You tucked it away so quickly. That made me think you had a small willy and were afraid of me finding out.”

I slightly twist her nipple piercing. She gives a soft moan. “Careful teasing me when you’re so ****.”

“If that’s how you’re going to react to me teasing you, I’m going to tease you even more.” Her plumb ass cheeks now run up and down my hard cock. A little movement forward and I could bury myself deep inside her.

Does she continue to tease me or do I fuck her?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)